Deer-Vehicle Collision Cost Calculator
Your out-of-pocket cost
How the numbers were worked out
Plan the rest of the picture: our Deer Live Weight and Meat Yield Estimator works out live weight from a chest-girth measurement, our Deer Rut Timing Calculator finds the peak rut window when deer cross roads most, and our Rental Car Insurance Calculator checks what a rental costs while your vehicle is in the shop.
Last reviewed: 20 November 2026. Reviewed every 180 days; next review due 19 May 2027.
How to use the Deer-Vehicle Collision Cost Calculator
A deer strike is one of the most common expensive surprises in American driving. State Farm estimates there were more than 1.6 million animal collision insurance claims in the United States between July 1, 2025, and June 30, 2026, and it paid $1.9 billion in claim costs in that period. Deer are by far the animal drivers hit most often. The average repair is measured in thousands of dollars, not hundreds, and the amount that comes out of your pocket depends on three things you can name before anything happens: what you drive, how hard the hit is, and what your policy says. This calculator puts those three things together with the odds for your state and tells you, in plain dollars, what a strike would cost you, what your insurer would pay, and whether the comprehensive coverage that pays for it earns its premium back on deer strikes alone.
The calculator answers four questions at once. First, what is the repair bill for a strike of a given severity on your vehicle? Second, how much of that bill lands on you after your comprehensive deductible? Third, how likely is a strike where you drive, in a year and over ten years? Fourth, does the comprehensive premium you pay come back to you, on average, in deer-strike claims avoided? The last question is the one most drivers never work out, and it is the one this tool is built around: the payback check shows the math and lets you decide. It never tells you to buy or drop coverage, because the deer-only math is only part of the value of comprehensive coverage, which also pays for theft, fire, hail, broken glass, and vandalism.
To get your result, follow these steps:
- Pick your state. Your state sets two numbers: the odds of an animal collision claim, from State Farm's 2025-2026 ranking, and the default comprehensive premium, from the National Association of Insurance Commissioners (NAIC) 2022/2023 Auto Insurance Database Report. The odds range from 1 in 46 in West Virginia to 1 in 852 in Hawaii, so the state you pick changes the answer more than any other input. Pick the national average only if you drive in many states or you want the countrywide picture.
- Pick your vehicle type. Repair costs differ by vehicle type. The Highway Loss Data Institute (HLDI) found front-center animal strike claims averaged $2,874 for passenger cars, $3,171 for SUVs, and $2,606 for pickups, so the tool prices SUVs about 10 percent above cars and pickups about 9 percent below. The gap comes from ride height and front-end equipment: an SUV's taller front end meets more of the animal, and its bumper hides more sensors and cameras.
- Pick the impact severity. A glancing blow that clips a bumper and a grille is a minor strike. A direct hit that takes out the bumper, a headlight, the hood, and the radiator is moderate. A high-speed strike that reaches the frame, deploys an airbag, or bends structural parts is severe. About half of all deer claims fall in the moderate band. If you are unsure, pick moderate: it is the middle of the distribution and the band the average claim sits in.
- Enter your comprehensive deductible. This is the amount you pay first on a comprehensive claim, printed on your policy declarations page. Common choices are $250, $500, and $1,000. The tool defaults to $500 if you leave the box blank. Your deductible is the single biggest lever on your out-of-pocket cost: when the repair is above your deductible, you pay exactly the deductible and your insurer pays the rest. When the repair is below your deductible, you pay the repair in full, not the deductible, and there is nothing to claim.
- Enter your annual comprehensive premium, or leave it blank. This is what you pay a year for comprehensive coverage alone, not your whole auto policy. Your declarations page lists it separately from liability and collision. If you leave the box blank, the tool uses your state's NAIC average comprehensive premium for 2023, which runs from $117.23 a year in Hawaii to $472.78 in South Dakota, with a countrywide average of $238.24. Enter your own premium for a payback check that matches your policy.
- Say whether you carry comprehensive coverage. If you carry only liability coverage, the full repair bill is yours, and the tool shows it that way. The payback check still runs: it shows what buying comprehensive coverage would save you on deer strikes, against the premium you entered, so you can judge the trade for yourself.
The tool updates as you type, so you can try different numbers quickly. Try the example buttons under the form: a Pennsylvania car in a moderate hit with a $500 deductible, a West Virginia SUV in a severe hit with a $1,000 deductible, a Hawaii pickup in a minor hit with a $250 deductible, and a Michigan car in a moderate hit with no comprehensive coverage at all. The four examples show the four shapes the answer takes: a routine claim, a bad hit in the highest-risk state, a cheap claim in the lowest-risk state, and the full bill with no coverage.
Read the full result, not just the headline. The headline leads with your out-of-pocket cost for one strike. The cards show the repair bill, what your insurer pays, your annual chance of a strike, your expected cost a year, your expected strikes in ten years, and the comprehensive payback. The severity table shows all three severities side by side for your vehicle and deductible, so you can see how the bill grows from a glancing blow to a severe hit. The guidance explains the result in plain language, the warnings flag the cases that need a second look, such as a deductible above the repair or a severe hit that can run past the top of the band, and the steps print the full working so you can check every figure.
How it works
The calculator runs five calculations in order: the repair band, your out-of-pocket share, your insurer's share, your expected cost over time, and the comprehensive payback. Each one uses the result of the one before it, and the steps section on the page prints all five so you can check them against your own arithmetic. Every dated figure in the tool comes from a named publisher and is listed in the sources section below with its verification date.
Step 1: the repair band
The repair band starts from national guide estimates for deer-collision repair by severity, synthesized from collision-repair industry pricing guides and verified in August 2026: minor strikes run $2,500 to $4,000, moderate strikes $4,000 to $6,500, and severe strikes $6,500 to $12,000. About 30 percent of claims fall in the minor band, about 50 percent in the moderate band, and about 20 percent in the severe band. The weighted middle of those bands, $5,450, sits between the Highway Loss Data Institute's published averages: $4,373 across 2014 to 2023 and $5,980 in 2023 alone. That cross-check matters, because repair bands published without claim shares can drift far from what insurers actually pay.
The band is then scaled by your vehicle type, using HLDI's point-of-impact data. In HLDI Bulletin Vol. 31, No. 14 (September 2014), front-center animal strike claims, the most common kind, averaged $2,874 for passenger cars, $3,171 for SUVs, and $2,606 for pickups. The tool turns those averages into factors: 1.00 for a car, 1.10 for an SUV, and 0.91 for a pickup truck. A moderate strike on a car runs $4,000 to $6,500. The same strike on an SUV runs $4,400 to $7,150, and on a pickup $3,640 to $5,915. The factors come from 2004 to 2013 claim data, so they describe the shape of the difference between vehicle types, not today's dollars: the dollars come from the 2026 bands, and the shape comes from HLDI. The middle of the band is the simple average of its two ends: ($4,000 + $6,500) / 2 = $5,250 for a moderate strike on a car.
Two honest limits apply to the band. First, the severe band tops out at $12,000, but severe strikes can run past it: airbag deployment, frame damage, and multiple electronic modules can push a bill into five figures, and a Wisconsin body shop that repairs deer strikes daily prices severe damage at $10,000 to $20,000. The tool warns you whenever you pick severe. Second, the bands are national guides. A shop in a high-cost city charges more than a shop in a small town, an older car with cheaper parts costs less to fix than a new one loaded with sensors, and a strike that totals the vehicle pays the vehicle's value minus the deductible, not a repair bill at all.
Step 2: your out-of-pocket share
Your out-of-pocket cost is the lower of the repair and your deductible, worked out at each end of the band. With a $500 deductible and a moderate strike on a car, the repair runs $4,000 to $6,500, both ends above the deductible, so you pay $500 at both ends and your insurer pays $3,500 to $6,000. With a $5,000 deductible and a minor strike on a car, the repair runs $2,500 to $4,000, both ends below the deductible, so you pay the repair in full, $2,500 to $4,000, and your insurer pays nothing. With a $3,000 deductible and the same minor strike, you pay $2,500 at the low end, where the repair is cheaper than the deductible, and $3,000 at the high end, where the deductible binds. Out of pocket can never go below zero and never above the repair: a repair below the deductible means you pay the repair, not the deductible.
If you carry no comprehensive coverage, your out-of-pocket cost is the full repair band, and your insurer pays nothing. That is the honest comparison the payback check is built on: the difference between the full repair and the deductible is exactly what comprehensive coverage saves you on a strike, and the payback check prices that saving against the premium.
Step 3: your insurer's share
Your insurer's share is the repair minus your out-of-pocket cost, at each end of the band and at the middle. At the middle of a moderate strike on a car with a $500 deductible, the insurer pays $5,250 minus $500, which is $4,750. At the low end it pays $3,500, and at the high end $6,000. With a $0 deductible the insurer pays the whole repair. With a deductible above the top of the band the insurer pays nothing on that strike. The middle-of-band figure is the one the payback check uses, because the payback is an average over many strikes, and the middle of the band is the tool's best single estimate of a typical strike of that severity.
Step 4: your expected cost over time
Your state odds come from State Farm's 2025-2026 animal collision analysis, which ranks all 50 states and the District of Columbia by the likelihood of an animal collision claim per licensed driver, from claims between July 1, 2025, and June 30, 2026. West Virginia leads at 1 in 46, Montana follows at 1 in 54, and Hawaii sits last at 1 in 852. The national figure is 1 in 145, improved from 1 in 139 the year before. The tool converts the odds to an annual chance: 1 in 64 is 1.56 percent a year, 1 in 46 is 2.17 percent, and 1 in 852 is 0.12 percent. It also works out expected strikes in ten years: 10 divided by the odds, so 0.22 in West Virginia and 0.01 in Hawaii.
Your expected out-of-pocket cost a year is your middle-of-band out-of-pocket cost divided by the odds. A Pennsylvania driver with a $500 deductible and a moderate strike expects $500 divided by 64, which is $7.81 a year. Over ten years that is $78.10. A driver with no coverage in Michigan expects $5,250 divided by 68, which is $77.21 a year, or $772.10 over ten years. These are averages over many drivers and many years, not predictions for one driver. Most drivers in a state go years without a strike, and a few are hit twice in one season. The average is the right way to price insurance, and the wrong way to predict your next drive.
The odds are odds of a claim, not odds of a crash. State Farm's figures count insurance claims, and they cover all animals, not deer alone: rodents, dogs, raccoons, cattle, coyotes, cats, turkeys, hogs, and bears all appear in the data. Deer are by far the most frequently struck animal, which is why the tool treats the odds as deer odds, but a driver whose claim involves a raccoon or a cow is in the same count. The odds also count only drivers who file claims. A driver who hits a deer and pays a small repair out of pocket without claiming never appears in the figures.
Step 5: the comprehensive payback check
The payback check asks one question: does the comprehensive premium come back to you, on average, in deer-strike claims it pays? It works it out in two steps. First, the saving a year: the insurer's middle-of-band share divided by the odds. A Pennsylvania driver with a $500 deductible saves $4,750 divided by 64, which is $74.22 a year. Second, the payback: the annual premium divided by the saving a year. Against the NAIC Pennsylvania average premium of $240.89 a year, the payback is $240.89 divided by $74.22, which is about 3.2 years. In West Virginia, where the odds are 1 in 46 and a severe strike on an SUV puts $9,175 at the middle of the insurer's share, the saving is $199.46 a year, and the payback against a $302.12 premium is about 1.5 years. In Hawaii, where the odds are 1 in 852, the same math gives a payback of about 36.9 years.
The payback has four shapes. When the premium you enter is $0, the coverage costs nothing and there is nothing to pay back. When the saving is $0, because your deductible sits above the repair, the coverage never pays for itself on deer strikes alone. When the payback is under a year, the coverage pays for itself quickly on average. When it runs past five years, the tool calls it a long payback and warns you. The five-year line is a judgment call, not a rule from any publisher: five years is longer than most drivers keep the same car, so a payback past five years means the coverage is unlikely to return its premium on deer strikes during your time with the vehicle.
The payback check counts deer strikes only, and that limit cuts both ways. Comprehensive coverage also pays for theft, fire, hail, broken glass, and vandalism, so the deer-only payback understates the coverage's value: a policy with a long deer payback can still be worth carrying for the other perils. On the other side, the payback uses averages, and averages hide the shape of the risk. A driver who is hit once in year one gets the full benefit at once; a driver who is never hit gets none of it. The tool shows the math and leaves the decision to you. It never advises for or against carrying comprehensive coverage, because that decision turns on your finances, your vehicle, and the other perils, none of which this tool prices.
Worked example 1: Pennsylvania, car, moderate hit, $500 deductible
Pennsylvania, car, moderate severity, $500 deductible, no premium entered, comprehensive coverage carried. The tool uses the NAIC Pennsylvania average comprehensive premium for 2023, $240.89 a year.
- Repair band: $4,000.00 to $6,500.00 at the car rate, times the car factor 1.00, gives $4,000.00 to $6,500.00. Middle of the band: $5,250.00.
- Out of pocket: $500.00 at both ends, because the repair is above the deductible throughout. Insurer pays $3,500.00 to $6,000.00, $4,750.00 at the middle.
- Annual chance: 1 in 64 = 1.56% a year. Pennsylvania ranks 4 of 51, in the High risk band.
- Expected out-of-pocket cost a year: $500.00 / 64 = $7.81. Over 10 years: $78.10. Expected strikes in 10 years: 0.16.
- Comprehensive payback: the coverage saves $74.22 a year on deer strikes ($4,750.00 / 64), against a $240.89 annual premium. Payback: $240.89 / $74.22 = about 3.2 years.
Worked example 2: West Virginia, SUV, severe hit, $1,000 deductible
West Virginia, SUV, severe severity, $1,000 deductible, no premium entered, comprehensive coverage carried. The tool uses the NAIC West Virginia average comprehensive premium for 2023, $302.12 a year.
- Repair band: $6,500.00 to $12,000.00 at the car rate, times the SUV factor 1.10, gives $7,150.00 to $13,200.00. Middle of the band: $10,175.00.
- Out of pocket: $1,000.00 at both ends, because the repair is above the deductible throughout. Insurer pays $6,150.00 to $12,200.00, $9,175.00 at the middle.
- Annual chance: 1 in 46 = 2.17% a year. West Virginia ranks 1 of 51, in the High risk band.
- Expected out-of-pocket cost a year: $1,000.00 / 46 = $21.74. Over 10 years: $217.40. Expected strikes in 10 years: 0.22.
- Comprehensive payback: the coverage saves $199.46 a year on deer strikes ($9,175.00 / 46), against a $302.12 annual premium. Payback: $302.12 / $199.46 = about 1.5 years.
Worked example 3: Michigan, car, moderate hit, no comprehensive coverage
Michigan, car, moderate severity, $500 deductible, $236.90 premium entered, no comprehensive coverage. The deductible and premium describe the policy the driver would buy, so the payback check shows what buying it would save.
- Repair band: $4,000.00 to $6,500.00, middle $5,250.00.
- Out of pocket: the full repair, $4,000.00 to $6,500.00. Insurer pays $0.00, because there is no comprehensive coverage to pay it.
- Annual chance: 1 in 68 = 1.47% a year. Michigan ranks 5 of 51, in the High risk band.
- Expected out-of-pocket cost a year: $5,250.00 / 68 = $77.21. Over 10 years: $772.10. Expected strikes in 10 years: 0.15.
- Comprehensive payback: buying coverage would save $69.85 a year on deer strikes ($4,750.00 / 68), against a $236.90 annual premium. Payback: $236.90 / $69.85 = about 3.4 years.
Worked example 4: Pennsylvania, car, minor hit, $5,000 deductible
Pennsylvania, car, minor severity, $5,000 deductible, no premium entered, comprehensive coverage carried. The tool uses the NAIC Pennsylvania average comprehensive premium for 2023, $240.89 a year.
- Repair band: $2,500.00 to $4,000.00, middle $3,250.00.
- Out of pocket: the full repair, $2,500.00 to $4,000.00, because the whole band sits below the deductible. Insurer pays $0.00 at both ends.
- Annual chance: 1 in 64 = 1.56% a year.
- Expected out-of-pocket cost a year: $3,250.00 / 64 = $50.78. Over 10 years: $507.80.
- Comprehensive payback: the coverage saves $0.00 a year on deer strikes at this deductible, so it never pays for itself on deer strikes alone. It still covers theft, hail, glass, and vandalism, which this tool does not price.
Worked example 5: Hawaii, pickup, minor hit, $250 deductible
Hawaii, pickup truck, minor severity, $250 deductible, $117.23 premium entered, comprehensive coverage carried.
- Repair band: $2,500.00 to $4,000.00 at the car rate, times the pickup factor 0.91, gives $2,275.00 to $3,640.00. Middle of the band: $2,957.50.
- Out of pocket: $250.00 at both ends. Insurer pays $2,025.00 to $3,390.00, $2,707.50 at the middle.
- Annual chance: 1 in 852 = 0.12% a year. Hawaii ranks 51 of 51, in the Low risk band.
- Expected out-of-pocket cost a year: $250.00 / 852 = $0.29. Over 10 years: $2.90. Expected strikes in 10 years: 0.01.
- Comprehensive payback: the coverage saves $3.18 a year on deer strikes ($2,707.50 / 852), against a $117.23 annual premium. Payback: $117.23 / $3.18 = about 36.9 years, a long payback on deer strikes alone.
Features
Repair bands by vehicle type and severity
The tool prices nine combinations: three vehicle types times three severities. A minor strike on a pickup runs $2,275 to $3,640, while a severe strike on an SUV runs $7,150 to $13,200. The severity table under the result shows all three severities for your vehicle and deductible at once, so you can see the full range before you pick. The bands are national guide estimates, not quotes, and the tool says so in every result: a shop estimate is the only figure that binds.
State-by-state odds from State Farm
All 51 jurisdictions in State Farm's ranking are in the tool, with the 2025-2026 odds and rank for each, plus the national average of 1 in 145. The risk band follows State Farm's own map: High at odds of 1 in 100 or shorter, Medium from 1 in 101 to 1 in 190, Low above 1 in 190. Seventeen jurisdictions sit in the High band this year, from West Virginia at 1 in 46 to Kentucky and North Dakota at 1 in 100. The odds refresh every September when State Farm publishes its annual analysis, and the tool's review cycle is set to catch each new edition.
State-by-state default premiums from the NAIC
Leave the premium box blank and the tool fills in your state's average comprehensive premium for 2023, from Table 3C of the NAIC 2022/2023 Auto Insurance Database Report. The range is wide: South Dakota averages $472.78 a year, Wyoming $452.24, Colorado $446.80, and Texas $400.01, while Hawaii averages $117.23, Nevada $135.76, California $150.04, and Washington $153.93. The state average is a starting point, not your price: your premium depends on your vehicle, your driving record, your ZIP code, and your insurer. Enter the figure from your declarations page whenever you have it.
The deductible edge cases, handled honestly
Most deer cost guides assume the deductible always binds. It often does not. A $1,000 deductible against a minor repair of $2,275 to $3,640 binds at the top end and not at the bottom. A $5,000 deductible against any minor or moderate repair never binds at all, and the tool says so plainly: the insurer pays nothing, the payback never arrives, and the coverage's value on deer strikes is zero at that deductible. A $0 deductible flips the picture the other way: the insurer pays the whole repair, and the payback is as fast as the odds allow. The tool warns you whenever your deductible sits above the middle of the repair band, because that is the point where the coverage stops doing much work on deer strikes.
An estimate, labeled as one
Every result carries the same sentence: this is an estimate only, and your policy governs what your insurer pays. That is not boilerplate. Policies differ on what counts as a covered animal strike, on whether aftermarket parts are used, on rental reimbursement while the vehicle is repaired, and on whether a claim affects your premium. The tool models the deductible and the repair band, which are the two numbers that decide most deer claims, and it leaves the rest to your policy documents.
Use cases
Choosing a deductible before renewal
The deductible choice is the most common reason to run this tool. A higher deductible lowers your premium and raises your out-of-pocket cost on a claim, and the right balance depends on how often you are likely to claim. Run the tool at $250, $500, and $1,000 for your state and vehicle, and compare the out-of-pocket figure and the payback at each level. In a high-risk state such as West Virginia, where the odds are 1 in 46, a lower deductible pays back faster because claims are more frequent. In a low-risk state such as Hawaii, where the odds are 1 in 852, the payback is long at any deductible, and the premium saving from a higher deductible may matter more than the claim saving. The tool shows both sides of that trade in dollars, and it never picks a side.
Deciding whether to keep comprehensive on an older car
Comprehensive coverage pays the vehicle's value minus the deductible when the car is totaled, so its value falls as the car ages and the value drops. A driver with a car worth $4,000 and a $1,000 deductible gets at most $3,000 from a total loss, and the deer-strike math is worse: a moderate repair of $4,000 to $6,500 on a car worth $4,000 is likely to be written off as a total loss rather than repaired. Run the tool with your vehicle's value in mind: if the repair band is near or above what the car is worth, the insurer's real exposure is the value minus the deductible, not the repair band, and the payback the tool shows overstates the coverage's value. Our Auto Loan Calculator helps with the financing side if the car is still under a loan, and a lender may require comprehensive coverage until the loan is paid off, which settles the question regardless of the payback.
Budgeting for a move to deer country
Moving from a city to a rural county changes your deer risk more than almost anything else you can do. A driver moving from California, at 1 in 430, to Pennsylvania, at 1 in 64, faces nearly seven times the yearly chance of a strike. Run the tool for both states before you move: the expected yearly cost, the payback, and the state premium average all change, and the difference is a real line in a household budget. Our Budget Calculator can carry the expected yearly figure into a monthly budget. If the move is for hunting season, our Deer Rut Timing Calculator finds the peak rut window when deer cross roads most, and our Deer Live Weight and Meat Yield Estimator works out live weight from a chest-girth measurement.
After a strike: checking the estimate against the band
When a shop hands you an estimate after a strike, run the tool for your vehicle and severity and compare. An estimate inside the band is unremarkable. An estimate far above the band deserves a question: what is in it that the band does not cover? Common answers are sensor recalibration, which CCC Intelligent Solutions found in 28.3 percent of repairable estimates in 2025 at an average fee of about $486, a second damaged panel the first look missed, or a parts shortage pushing labor hours up. An estimate far below the band deserves a different question: is anything being skipped? A bumper cover replaced without the radar unit behind it recalibrated can leave automatic emergency braking blind, which is a safety problem, not a saving.
Renting a car while yours is repaired
A deer strike often takes the car off the road for a week or more while parts arrive. Comprehensive coverage does not pay for a rental car unless rental reimbursement is on the policy, so the rental is a second out-of-pocket cost the tool does not model. Our Rental Car Insurance Calculator checks what the rental itself costs and whether the rental counter's insurance is worth buying. Check your policy for rental reimbursement before you need it: it is usually a small addition to the premium, and it is too late to add after the strike.
What the averages hide
The average deer claim is a useful anchor and a misleading promise. HLDI's average animal strike severity for 2023 was $5,980, and AAA East Central reported an average of $5,620 in high-risk states in 2024, while AAA's regional figure for late 2026 was $7,251. The Insurance Information Institute puts the average wildlife vehicle collision claim at $4,135. Those numbers disagree because they measure different things: different years, different states, different mixes of animals, and different mixes of severity. None of them is the price of your strike. Your strike is one draw from a wide distribution, and the band is a better guide to it than any single average.
The most common confusion is between the all-animals average and the deer average. State Farm paid $1.9 billion on more than 1.6 million animal collision claims in the year to June 2026, which works out to about $1,187 a claim. That figure includes rodents that chew through wiring, a cheap claim that drags the average down, and it is not a deer repair figure at all. Deer strikes cost far more than the all-animals average because a deer is a 150 to 250 pound animal meeting a vehicle at road speed. The tool never uses the $1,187 figure for repair costs, and any guide that quotes it as the cost of hitting a deer is mixing two different measures.
Severity is the widest source of variation. A glancing blow at low speed can cost less than $2,500 if only a bumper cover and a grille are damaged. A direct hit at highway speed that reaches the radiator, the condenser, the hood, and the frame can pass $12,000, and a strike that deploys an airbag or totals the vehicle costs more still. The month matters too: HLDI found the average November claim ran $4,997 across 2014 to 2023, against $3,854 in February, the mildest month, because November strikes happen at higher speeds on darker roads during the rut. The tool's bands are built for that spread, which is why they are bands and not single numbers.
Vehicle age matters as much as vehicle type. CCC Intelligent Solutions reported an average repair cost of $3,682 for vehicles seven years and older, against $5,721 for vehicles six years old or newer, across its broader repairable-claim data. A new vehicle carries more sensors, more cameras, and more expensive headlights, and each of them adds to the bill when the front end is damaged. An older vehicle with the same damage costs less to fix and is more likely to be totaled, because the repair quickly passes the vehicle's value. The tool's bands do not adjust for vehicle age: treat the low end as closer for an older car and the high end as closer for a newer one.
State Farm animal collision odds, 2025-2026
The full ranking from State Farm's 2025-2026 analysis, claims July 1, 2025, to June 30, 2026. Odds are the likelihood of an animal collision claim per licensed driver in a year. The risk band follows State Farm's own map: High at 1 in 100 or shorter, Medium from 1 in 101 to 1 in 190, Low above 1 in 190. The national figure is 1 in 145.
| Rank | State | Odds | Risk band |
|---|---|---|---|
| 1 | West Virginia | 1 in 46 | High |
| 2 | Montana | 1 in 54 | High |
| 3 | Wisconsin | 1 in 62 | High |
| 4 | Pennsylvania | 1 in 64 | High |
| 5 | Michigan | 1 in 68 | High |
| 6 | Iowa | 1 in 81 | High |
| 7 | Mississippi | 1 in 81 | High |
| 8 | Virginia | 1 in 81 | High |
| 9 | Maine | 1 in 85 | High |
| 10 | South Dakota | 1 in 86 | High |
| 11 | Kansas | 1 in 89 | High |
| 12 | Minnesota | 1 in 91 | High |
| 13 | North Carolina | 1 in 95 | High |
| 14 | Wyoming | 1 in 96 | High |
| 15 | Missouri | 1 in 97 | High |
| 16 | Kentucky | 1 in 100 | High |
| 17 | North Dakota | 1 in 100 | High |
| 18 | South Carolina | 1 in 103 | Medium |
| 19 | Massachusetts | 1 in 106 | Medium |
| 20 | Ohio | 1 in 108 | Medium |
| 21 | Alabama | 1 in 109 | Medium |
| 22 | Georgia | 1 in 115 | Medium |
| 23 | Indiana | 1 in 116 | Medium |
| 24 | Maryland | 1 in 117 | Medium |
| 25 | Oklahoma | 1 in 124 | Medium |
| 26 | Tennessee | 1 in 129 | Medium |
| 27 | Vermont | 1 in 133 | Medium |
| 28 | Arkansas | 1 in 135 | Medium |
| 29 | Delaware | 1 in 152 | Medium |
| 30 | Idaho | 1 in 159 | Medium |
| 31 | Nebraska | 1 in 161 | Medium |
| 32 | New Hampshire | 1 in 179 | Medium |
| 33 | New York | 1 in 185 | Medium |
| 34 | Rhode Island | 1 in 193 | Low |
| 35 | Illinois | 1 in 195 | Low |
| 36 | Louisiana | 1 in 215 | Low |
| 37 | Oregon | 1 in 223 | Low |
| 38 | Texas | 1 in 223 | Low |
| 39 | New Jersey | 1 in 245 | Low |
| 40 | Utah | 1 in 251 | Low |
| 41 | Colorado | 1 in 253 | Low |
| 42 | Connecticut | 1 in 289 | Low |
| 43 | New Mexico | 1 in 292 | Low |
| 44 | Washington | 1 in 305 | Low |
| 45 | California | 1 in 430 | Low |
| 46 | Florida | 1 in 543 | Low |
| 47 | Alaska | 1 in 580 | Low |
| 48 | District of Columbia | 1 in 635 | Low |
| 49 | Arizona | 1 in 682 | Low |
| 50 | Nevada | 1 in 838 | Low |
| 51 | Hawaii | 1 in 852 | Low |
Pennsylvania had the highest number of estimated claims of any state, about 141,000, even though its odds rank fourth: it has far more licensed drivers than West Virginia or Montana, so the same odds produce more claims. That is the difference between odds and counts, and it is why the tool uses odds, which describe your chance as one driver, rather than claim counts, which describe a state's size.
Average comprehensive premiums by state, 2023
The NAIC 2022/2023 Auto Insurance Database Report, Table 3C, gives the average comprehensive premium for each state. The countrywide average for 2023 was $238.24, up from $196.12 in 2022. The five highest and five lowest state averages show how much the premium varies by where you live.
| State | Average comprehensive premium, 2023 |
|---|---|
| South Dakota | $472.78 |
| Wyoming | $452.24 |
| Colorado | $446.80 |
| Texas | $400.01 |
| Montana | $365.45 |
| United States (countrywide) | $238.24 |
| New Hampshire | $158.20 |
| Washington | $153.93 |
| California | $150.04 |
| Nevada | $135.76 |
| Hawaii | $117.23 |
Comprehensive premiums are high in states with hail, theft, and animal claims, not only in states with deer. Colorado's $446.80 average reflects hail as much as wildlife, and Texas at $400.01 reflects hail, theft, and storms. The premium average is a starting point for the payback check, not a quote, and your own premium is the figure that matters.
Sources
- State Farm, "How likely are you to have an animal collision?" (published September 28, 2026): the 2025-2026 animal collision likelihoods for all 50 states and the District of Columbia, from claims July 1, 2025, to June 30, 2026, with the top ten animals involved and safety tips. The per-state odds and ranks in this tool were read from State Farm's own published data file for the page. Read November 20, 2026. statefarm.com
- State Farm newsroom, "20 Years of Animal Collision Data, One Goal: Safer Roads Ahead" (September 15, 2026): more than 1.6 million animal collision claims in the study period, $1.9 billion in claim costs, national odds of 1 in 145 improved from 1 in 139, West Virginia at 1 in 46, Pennsylvania with the most estimated claims at about 141,000, and 210 deaths in 2024 in crashes involving animals, per the Insurance Institute for Highway Safety. Read November 20, 2026. newsroom.statefarm.com
- Highway Loss Data Institute, Bulletin Vol. 41, No. 14, "Losses due to animal strikes" (May 2024): average animal strike claim severity $4,373 across 2014 to 2023, $5,980 in 2023, $3,176 in 2014; claim frequency 6.8 per 1,000 insured vehicle years; November frequency 13.8 per 1,000 against 4.3 in August; November severity $4,997 against $3,854 in February; overall losses $30 per insured vehicle year; West Virginia November frequency 44.8. Based on more than 573 million insured vehicle years and more than 3.8 million claims. Massachusetts excluded. Read November 20, 2026. insurance.maryland.gov
- Highway Loss Data Institute, Bulletin Vol. 31, No. 14, "Point of impact distribution for animal strike claims" (September 2014): average animal strike claim $2,730 against $3,510 for collision claims, 2004 to 2013; 87 percent of animal strike claims to the front of the vehicle; front-center averages of $2,874 for passenger cars, $3,171 for SUVs, and $2,606 for pickups, the source of the vehicle factors 1.00, 1.10, and 0.91. Read November 20, 2026. iihs.org
- National Association of Insurance Commissioners, 2022/2023 Auto Insurance Database Report, Table 3C: average comprehensive premiums by state for 2019 to 2023. Countrywide 2023 average $238.24, 2022 $196.12. Adopted December 2025, released February 13, 2026. Read from the NAIC's own PDF November 20, 2026. content.naic.org
- Collision-repair industry pricing guides, as synthesized August 2026: deer-collision repair cost by severity: minor $2,500 to $4,000, about 30 percent of claims; moderate $4,000 to $6,500, about 50 percent; severe $6,500 to $12,000, about 20 percent; average deer-collision claim about $4,600. The weighted middle of the bands, $5,450, sits between HLDI's 2014-2023 average of $4,373 and its 2023 average of $5,980. Read November 20, 2026. dailydriveradvocate.com
- Wheeler's Auto Body, "Deer Collision Repair in Central Wisconsin": a working body shop's bands, which run higher than the national synthesis: light damage $2,500 to $4,500, moderate damage $5,500 to $9,000, severe damage $10,000 to $20,000, with most moderate repairs at $4,000 to $8,500. Cited here as the conflict the tool discloses, not as its source: the tool uses the national bands, and notes that shop prices vary by region. Read November 20, 2026. wisconsinrapidsautobody.com
- Insurance Information Institute, via the NW Insurance Council: average wildlife vehicle collision claim $4,135, and more than 1.5 million deer vehicle collisions a year. Read November 20, 2026. nwinsurance.org
- AAA: average deer-related claim $7,251 in the region, reported November 2026. Cited as a cross-check on the repair bands. Read November 20, 2026. acmonews.ace.aaa.com
- CCC Intelligent Solutions data, via DaxStreet, "What a Deer Strike Actually Costs to Repair, Explained": average total cost of repair across repairable claims approaching $4,800 in 2025; calibration in 28.3 percent of repairable estimates in 2025 at an average fee of about $486; average repair cost $3,682 for vehicles seven years and older against $5,721 for vehicles six years old or newer; AAA East Central average animal-collision claim cost of $5,620 in high-risk states in 2024. Read November 20, 2026. daxstreet.com
- AAA Foundation for Traffic Safety, "Animal-related Crashes, Injuries, and Deaths in the United States, 2020-2024": at least 353,800 police-reported animal-related crashes, 49,725 injuries, and 277 deaths each year. Read November 20, 2026. aaafoundation.org
Conflicts resolved in this build. State Farm's newsroom release says fifteen states sit at odds of 1 in less than 100, but its own map code bands odds of 100 itself as high risk, which covers seventeen jurisdictions including Kentucky and North Dakota at exactly 1 in 100. The code governs what the map shows, so the tool bands 1 in 100 as High. State Farm's $1.9 billion over 1.6 million claims gives an all-animals average of about $1,187 a claim, which includes cheap rodent damage claims and must not be read as a deer repair figure; the tool's deer bands come from the repair guides and are cross-checked against HLDI's deer-heavy severity averages instead. The national repair bands disagree with one Wisconsin body shop's higher bands; the tool uses the national synthesis, discloses the shop's higher figures here, and warns on severe strikes that bills can run past the top of the band.
Frequently asked questions
How much does it cost to repair a car after hitting a deer?
A minor strike runs $2,500 to $4,000, a moderate strike $4,000 to $6,500, and a severe strike $6,500 to $12,000, at the car rate. SUVs run about 10 percent higher and pickups about 9 percent lower. About half of all deer claims fall in the moderate band. The Highway Loss Data Institute put the average animal strike claim at $5,980 in 2023, and AAA East Central reported an average of $5,620 in high-risk states in 2024. Severe strikes can run past $12,000 when airbags deploy or the frame is damaged, and a strike that totals the vehicle pays the vehicle's value minus the deductible instead of a repair bill.
Does insurance cover hitting a deer?
Yes, if you carry comprehensive coverage. A direct strike with a deer is normally a comprehensive claim, not a collision claim, because the animal is not another vehicle or object you drove into. Liability coverage alone pays nothing toward your own repair. If you swerve to miss the deer and hit a tree, a guardrail, or another car instead, that is usually a collision claim, with a different deductible and different fault rules. Your policy governs the details, including any exclusions, so read it before you assume a strike is covered.
What deductible applies to a deer strike?
Your comprehensive deductible applies, because a deer strike is a comprehensive claim. Common deductibles are $250, $500, and $1,000. You pay the lower of the repair and the deductible: with a $500 deductible and a $5,250 repair, you pay $500 and your insurer pays $4,750. With a $5,000 deductible and a $3,250 repair, you pay the $3,250 repair in full, not the deductible, and your insurer pays nothing. A repair below the deductible means you pay the repair, not the deductible.
Will my rates go up if I hit a deer?
Usually not by much, but it depends on your insurer and your state. Insurers generally treat a direct deer strike as a not-at-fault event outside the driver's control, so a comprehensive claim for a deer strike rarely triggers the premium increase that follows an at-fault collision claim. Some insurers still count comprehensive claims when they price a renewal, and some states limit how insurers can use not-at-fault claims. A police report from the scene helps: it gives the insurer third-party evidence that an animal caused the damage, which supports the not-at-fault treatment. Ask your insurer how it treats comprehensive claims before you decide whether to file a small one.
Which state has the highest odds of hitting a deer?
West Virginia, at 1 in 46 in State Farm's 2025-2026 ranking, a spot it has held for more than a decade. Montana follows at 1 in 54, Wisconsin at 1 in 62, Pennsylvania at 1 in 64, and Michigan at 1 in 68. The national figure is 1 in 145. Pennsylvania had the most estimated claims of any state, about 141,000, because it has far more licensed drivers than the states ahead of it. Hawaii has the longest odds, at 1 in 852.
When is deer collision season?
October through December, with November the peak month. State Farm names November, October, and December, in that order, as the months drivers are most likely to hit a large animal. The Highway Loss Data Institute found animal strike claims more than twice as frequent in November as the yearly average, at 13.8 claims per 1,000 insured vehicle years against 4.3 in August, the quietest month. The peak coincides with the rut, the deer mating season, when deer move more and pay less attention to roads, and with the end of daylight saving time, which moves the evening commute into dusk, when deer are most active.
Is comprehensive coverage worth it for deer strikes?
It depends on your state, your deductible, and your premium, which is what the payback check on this page works out. In West Virginia, where the odds are 1 in 46, a severe strike on an SUV with a $1,000 deductible pays the premium back in about 1.5 years on average. In Pennsylvania, a moderate strike on a car with a $500 deductible pays back in about 3.2 years. In Hawaii, where the odds are 1 in 852, the payback runs about 36.9 years. The payback counts deer strikes only: comprehensive coverage also pays for theft, fire, hail, glass, and vandalism, so the deer-only payback understates its value, and the tool never advises for or against carrying it.
What should I do right after hitting a deer?
Move the vehicle to a safe location if you can, turn on your hazard lights, and check for leaking fluids, damaged tires, and broken lights before driving on. Call police if the animal is blocking traffic or anyone is hurt. Do not approach an injured deer. Photograph the damage, the road, and the animal from a safe distance, and get a police report at the scene: it gives your insurer third-party evidence that an animal caused the damage, which supports a comprehensive claim. Then contact your insurer to report the collision. If the radiator is damaged, do not keep driving: an engine without coolant overheats within minutes and turns a radiator repair into engine damage.