Skip to content

Roth Conversion Calculator

Filing status

The 2026 brackets for a single filer are 10% to $12,400, 12% to $50,400, 22% to $105,700, 24% to $201,775, 32% to $256,225, 35% to $640,600, and 37% above that.

Your 2026 taxable income before this conversion, from Form 1040, line 15. The conversion sits on top of this figure, so it is taxed at your highest brackets first.

How much you plan to convert from a traditional, SEP, or SIMPLE IRA to a Roth IRA in 2026. Enter 0 to see the room you have to convert at your current rate.

Your age in 2026. It decides whether the Medicare surcharge check applies to this conversion and when required minimum distributions begin.

How many years the converted money will grow before you withdraw it. Enter 0 to compare with no growth.

The annual return you expect on the converted money, before tax. The comparison assumes the same rate every year.

The federal rate you expect to pay when the traditional IRA money comes out. The tool also works out the break-even rate for you.

Your 2026 modified adjusted gross income before this conversion. Medicare uses it, two years later, to set your premiums. Leave it blank to skip the Medicare check.

A flat state rate for a rough state estimate. Enter 0 if your state has no income tax. Your state has its own brackets, so this is an estimate only.

Pay the conversion tax from outside funds?

Paying from savings keeps the full conversion in the Roth, where it grows tax-free. Paying from the conversion shrinks the Roth balance by the tax bill, which weakens the comparison.

Extra federal tax on this conversion

How the tax was worked out

      This tool estimates the 2026 federal tax on a Roth conversion from the numbers you enter, for general guidance only. It is not tax advice. The estimate assumes the whole conversion is taxable and uses the 2026 IRMAA tiers as the estimate for 2028 premiums. It does not model the pro-rata rule, Social Security taxation, premium tax credits, or state tax beyond a flat rate you enter. Check your result with a tax professional before you convert.
      Converting to a Roth IRA in 2026 adds the converted amount to your taxable income, taxed bracket by bracket: a $30,000 conversion on $60,000 of single income costs $6,600 in federal tax at 22 percent. The conversion also raises your MAGI, which can add $1,148.40 a year to your 2028 Medicare premiums at the first IRMAA tier. The Roth wins when your future tax rate beats the break-even rate, which is 19.11 percent in that example. Enter your income, conversion, age, horizon, growth, and future rate above for your tax, IRMAA warning, and long-term comparison.

      Last reviewed: 20 November 2026. Reviewed every 180 days; next review due 19 May 2027.

      How to use the Roth Conversion Calculator

      This calculator answers three questions about a Roth conversion for tax year 2026: how much federal tax the conversion adds this year, whether it pushes your Medicare premiums up two years from now, and whether the Roth or the traditional IRA leaves you better off over the long run. Enter your taxable income before the conversion, your filing status, the amount you want to convert, your age, your horizon, the growth rate you expect, and the future tax rate you expect to pay, and it works out the extra tax bracket by bracket, the fill-the-bracket room, the IRMAA tier warning, and a year-by-year comparison of the two paths, with every step printed so you can check the numbers yourself. It uses the 2026 federal brackets from IRS Revenue Procedure 2025-32, section 4.01, read from the IRS document itself, and the 2026 Medicare premium tiers published by the Centers for Medicare and Medicaid Services.

      A Roth conversion is a trade: you pay tax now, at your current rate, to move money from a traditional IRA into a Roth IRA, where it grows tax free and comes out tax free. The trade pays off when your tax rate now is lower than the rate you would pay later on the same money. It loses money when the rate now is higher than the rate later. The hard part is that the rate now is not one number: the conversion stacks on top of your existing income and is taxed bracket by bracket, and it can also push your Medicare premiums up, push more of your Social Security into tax, and push other income over thresholds. This calculator works out the tax and the Medicare effect exactly, and the long-term comparison shows the break-even future tax rate, the one number that decides whether the trade pays.

      To get your result, follow these steps:

      1. Pick your filing status. Single, married filing jointly, head of household, or married filing separately. Your status sets the bracket edges and the IRMAA thresholds: a joint return gets brackets twice as wide as a single return at the lower rates and IRMAA thresholds twice as high. Married filing separately gets the narrowest IRMAA treatment of all, with the top surcharges starting at much lower income.
      2. Enter your taxable income before the conversion. This is the figure from Form 1040, line 15, before you add the conversion. It is not your salary and not your AGI: it is the income left after your standard or itemized deductions. If you only know your AGI, subtract your deduction first. Our Tax Calculator works out your taxable income and your tax from your income and deductions.
      3. Enter the conversion amount. How much you want to move from the traditional IRA to the Roth IRA this year. Enter 0 if you only want to see where you stand today: the tool still shows your current tax, your marginal rate, and the room in your bracket. Conversions are often spread over several years, a little at a time, to stay inside a bracket or below a Medicare tier.
      4. Enter your current age. Your age decides two things: whether the IRMAA warning applies to you, and whether required minimum distributions are already in force or will start inside your horizon. The IRMAA warning matters from age 63, because a 2026 conversion affects 2028 premiums, and you need to be 65 in 2028 for the surcharge to bite.
      5. Enter your horizon and growth rate. How many years the money will grow before you need it, and the annual return you expect. The horizon is the single biggest lever in the long-term comparison: the longer the money grows tax free, the more the Roth gains on the traditional IRA. Be honest about the growth rate: a high rate flatters the Roth, because the tax-free growth is worth more when the growth is larger.
      6. Enter the future tax rate. The rate you expect to pay on a traditional IRA withdrawal in the future. This is the rate the conversion is really betting against. If you expect to retire in a lower bracket, enter a low rate. If you expect required minimum distributions to push you into a higher bracket, or tax rates to rise, enter a higher one. The break-even rate in the result tells you how high it has to be for the conversion to pay.
      7. Enter your current-year MAGI, if you want the IRMAA check. Your modified adjusted gross income for 2026, before the conversion. Medicare looks at MAGI, not taxable income, so this field is separate from your taxable income. Leave it blank if you are under 63 or do not want the Medicare check: the tax and comparison results do not need it.
      8. Enter your state tax rate, if you want a state estimate. A flat rate applied to the conversion amount, on top of the federal tax. Most states tax conversions as ordinary income, but a few do not tax retirement income at all, and a flat rate is only an approximation in states with graduated brackets. Enter 0 if your state has no income tax or you only want the federal figure.
      9. Say whether the tax is paid from outside funds. This choice changes the long-term comparison more than any other single input. Paying from a taxable account leaves the full conversion amount in the Roth. Paying from the conversion itself shrinks the Roth by the tax, and the money that never reaches the Roth never grows tax free.
      10. Read the breakdown. The headline shows the extra federal tax and the winner of the long-term comparison. The cards show the tax before and after, the marginal and effective rates, the fill-the-bracket room, the IRMAA tier change, and the Roth and traditional balances at your horizon. The chart shows the two paths growing apart or together year by year. The tables print the bracket-by-bracket tax, the Medicare tier change, and the year-by-year comparison. The steps explain the working in words, and the warnings flag anything that could change the answer, such as an IRMAA crossing, a 5-year rule problem, or required minimum distributions starting inside your horizon.

      Try the example buttons under the form: a 64-year-old single filer converting $30,000 on $60,000 of income, where the conversion crosses the first Medicare tier but the Roth still wins; a married couple converting $50,000 on $150,000 of income with a 5 percent state tax, where the Roth only pulls ahead in the last years; a 45-year-old converting $10,000 and paying the tax from the conversion itself, where the traditional IRA wins by more than $7,000; a 70-year-old head of household whose $80,000 conversion jumps two Medicare tiers at once; and a zero conversion, which shows where you stand today with no conversion at all. The five examples show the five shapes the answer takes.

      What a Roth conversion is

      A Roth conversion moves money from a traditional IRA, or another pre-tax retirement account, into a Roth IRA. The money you move counts as ordinary income in the year of the conversion, and you pay income tax on it at your ordinary rates, just as if it were wages. Once it is in the Roth, it grows tax free, and qualified withdrawals come out tax free. The Roth IRA also has no required minimum distributions for the owner, so the money can stay invested for as long as you like.

      There is no income limit on conversions. Anyone with a traditional IRA can convert, whatever their income, and there is no limit on how much you can convert in a year. That is what makes conversions useful for high earners who cannot contribute to a Roth IRA directly: the conversion route, sometimes called a backdoor Roth, has no income ceiling. The tax is the price of admission, and the question is always whether the price is worth paying now rather than later.

      One thing a conversion is not: it is not a recharacterization, and it cannot be undone. Before 2018, a conversion could be reversed if the market fell or the tax turned out higher than expected. The Tax Cuts and Jobs Act eliminated recharacterization of conversions from 1 January 2018, so a conversion is final the moment it is made. That is why the arithmetic matters before you convert, not after. Run the numbers first, and if the answer is close, convert less this year and more next year rather than converting too much at once.

      The tax on a conversion is figured on the untaxed part of the money you move. For most people that is the whole conversion, because traditional IRA contributions were deductible and the growth was never taxed. If you have after-tax money in any traditional, SEP, or SIMPLE IRA, the pro-rata rule on Form 8606 makes part of every conversion tax free, in proportion to the after-tax share of all your IRA balances. This calculator assumes the whole conversion is taxable, so if you have after-tax IRA money, the tax it shows is higher than the tax you will actually pay. The pro-rata rule also means you cannot convert only the after-tax part: every dollar you convert carries the same mix of taxable and tax-free money as your IRA balances as a whole.

      How the tax stacks

      The converted amount sits on top of your existing taxable income. It does not replace it, and it is not taxed at your average rate: it fills your brackets from where your income leaves off, and each slice is taxed at the rate of the bracket it lands in. If your income already reaches into the 22 percent bracket, the first dollars of the conversion are taxed at 22 percent, and the conversion only reaches the 24 percent bracket when it crosses the top of the 22 percent bracket. This is why two people converting the same amount can pay very different tax: the one with lower starting income pays less, because more of the conversion falls in lower brackets.

      The 2026 federal brackets for a single filer and for a married couple filing jointly are:

      RateSingle: taxable income overMarried filing jointly: taxable income over
      10%$0$0
      12%$12,400$24,800
      22%$50,400$100,800
      24%$105,700$211,400
      32%$201,775$403,550
      35%$256,225$512,450
      37%$640,600$768,700

      Head of household brackets start at $17,700 for 12 percent, $67,450 for 22 percent, $105,700 for 24 percent, $201,750 for 32 percent, $256,200 for 35 percent, and $640,600 for 37 percent. Married filing separately follows the single brackets through 32 percent, then 35 percent starts at $256,225 and 37 percent at $384,350. All four sets of brackets come from IRS Revenue Procedure 2025-32, section 4.01, and the calculator works through them slice by slice, rounding each slice to the cent.

      Two rates come out of that working, and they answer different questions. The marginal rate is the rate on the last dollar of the conversion: the bracket your income lands in after the conversion. It is the rate that matters for the next dollar, and it is the rate to compare with your expected future rate when you are deciding whether to convert a little more. The effective rate is the total extra tax divided by the conversion amount: the average rate the whole conversion paid. When a conversion spans two brackets, the effective rate sits between them, and it is the rate that matters for the whole conversion at once. The calculator shows both, and the break-even rate in the comparison is built from the effective tax, not the marginal rate.

      One detail to know before you compare the result with your filed return: the IRS Tax Table applies to taxable income under $100,000 and figures tax in $50 bands, so the tax on a filed return can differ from this calculator by a few dollars. The calculator uses the continuous bracket formula, which is the exact figure the brackets describe. The difference is small, and it does not change any decision the calculator is for.

      Fill-the-bracket strategy

      The fill-the-bracket strategy is the most common reason people run this calculation. The idea is simple: in a year when your income leaves room in a low bracket, convert exactly enough to fill that room, and stop before the next bracket starts. You pay tax at the low rate on the whole conversion, and you never pay a higher rate on any of it. The calculator shows the room in your current bracket after the conversion, so you can see how much more you could convert before the rate rises.

      The room is measured after your conversion, not before it. If you enter a conversion of $30,000 and the tool shows $15,700 of room left, you could convert a further $15,700 this year and still pay no more than your current marginal rate on any of it. If the room is zero, your conversion landed exactly on a bracket edge, and every further dollar is taxed at the next rate up. If you are already in the top 37 percent bracket, there is no room at all: every further dollar is taxed at 37 percent, and the fill-the-bracket idea has nothing left to offer this year.

      Filling a bracket is not always the right move. The bracket edge is only one of the lines a conversion can cross. The Medicare tiers, the threshold where more of your Social Security becomes taxable, and the premium tax credit cliffs for marketplace insurance all sit at different income levels, and a conversion that fills a bracket neatly can still cross one of those lines. The calculator shows the room to the next Medicare tier alongside the room in your bracket, so you can see which line is closer. The binding limit is whichever room is smaller.

      The strategy works best in years when your income is unusually low: the gap years between retiring and starting Social Security, a year between jobs, or the first years of retirement before required minimum distributions begin. In those years the low brackets have the most room, and a conversion fills them at rates you may never see again. Spreading a large conversion over several low-income years, filling the same bracket each year, usually beats converting the whole amount in one year and pushing half of it into a higher bracket.

      The IRMAA two-year lookback

      IRMAA, the income-related monthly adjustment amount, is the surcharge Medicare adds to Part B and Part D premiums for higher-income beneficiaries. It is a cliff, not a slope: cross a threshold by one dollar and the surcharge jumps by the full step for the whole year. And it looks back two years. Medicare sets your 2028 premiums from your 2026 tax return, so a conversion you make in 2026 raises the premiums you pay in 2028, not the premiums you pay now. By the time the bill arrives, the conversion is two years old and cannot be undone.

      The 2026 IRMAA tiers, published by the Centers for Medicare and Medicaid Services, are based on modified adjusted gross income. The standard Part B premium for 2026 is $202.90 a month. The table shows the monthly Part B premium and the monthly Part D surcharge at each tier. The thresholds are for individual filers, with the joint thresholds in parentheses. Each tier starts above its threshold, except the top tier, which starts at $500,000 for an individual and $750,000 for a couple.

      MAGI, individual (joint)Part B per monthPart D surcharge per month
      $109,000 or less ($218,000)$202.90$0.00
      Over $109,000 to $137,000 ($218,000 to $274,000)$284.10$14.50
      Over $137,000 to $171,000 ($274,000 to $342,000)$405.80$37.50
      Over $171,000 to $205,000 ($342,000 to $410,000)$527.50$60.40
      Over $205,000 to $500,000 ($410,000 to $750,000)$649.20$83.30
      $500,000 or more ($750,000)$689.90$91.00

      The first step is the one most conversions hit. Moving from no surcharge to the first tier adds $81.20 a month to Part B and $14.50 a month to Part D, which is $1,148.40 a year, per person. On a joint return with both spouses on Medicare, the household cost is double: $2,296.80 a year. The steps get bigger as income rises. A head of household filer with $170,000 of MAGI who converts $80,000 lands at $250,000 of MAGI, jumping from tier 2 to tier 4 in one move: Part B rises from $405.80 to $649.20 a month, and the extra cost is $3,470.40 a year, per person, for the whole of 2028.

      The calculator warns you in two ways. If the conversion crosses a tier, it shows the tier change and the extra annual cost per person. If the conversion leaves you within $5,000 of the next tier, it warns you that you are approaching it, because a small change in income, a capital gain, or a slightly larger conversion could push you over. It also shows the room to the next tier, which is the other fill-the-line number: how much more MAGI you could take before the next surcharge starts. Remember that the room to the next tier is a distance to the line, not a safe conversion amount on its own, because the conversion also raises the MAGI it is measured against.

      Two honest limits apply to this check. First, the 2028 tiers that will actually apply to a 2026 conversion are not published yet. The calculator uses the published 2026 tiers as the estimate, and the 2028 tiers will be higher after inflation adjustments. That makes the check conservative: a conversion that stays below a 2026 tier is safely below the 2028 tier, while one that crosses a 2026 tier may still fall short of the higher 2028 tier. Second, the check only matters if you will be 65 in 2028, which means age 63 or older now. If you are younger, the calculator still computes the tier change, but it does not warn you about it, because the surcharge does not apply to you yet. There is also a life-changing-event appeal: if your income falls because you stop working, retire, lose a spouse, or divorce, you can ask Social Security to use a more recent year instead of the two-year-old return.

      Married couples filing separately get the harshest IRMAA treatment. If you lived with your spouse at any time during the year, the top surcharges start at $109,000 of MAGI instead of $500,000: income from $109,000 up to $391,000 pays the tier 4 surcharges, and $391,000 and over pays the tier 5 surcharges. A conversion that looks harmless on a separate return can land in the top tier at once. If you lived apart from your spouse for the whole year, the individual thresholds apply instead.

      Paying the tax from outside vs from inside

      Where the tax comes from changes the long-term answer more than any other choice you make. If you pay the tax from a taxable account, the full conversion amount goes into the Roth and the full amount grows tax free. If you pay the tax from the conversion itself, the Roth starts smaller by the tax, and the money that never reaches the Roth never grows tax free. The difference compounds for decades.

      The comparison in this calculator is fair to both sides. When the tax is paid from outside funds, the calculator counts the cost of those funds: the tax money you hand over would otherwise have stayed in a taxable account, grown at the same rate, and been taxed on its growth at your future rate. The Roth path is credited with the full conversion growing tax free, and charged with the after-tax value of the outside funds given up. When the tax is paid from the conversion, there is no outside cost, but the Roth starts at the conversion amount minus the tax. Either way, the traditional side is the same: the full conversion amount grows in the traditional IRA and is taxed on withdrawal at your future rate.

      The worked examples below show how much the choice matters. In the first example, paying $6,600 of tax from outside funds costs $17,962.33 in after-tax value over 20 years at 6 percent growth, because that money would have grown too. Even so, the Roth wins by $3,204.76, because the tax-free growth on the full $30,000 outweighs the cost. In the third example, paying the tax from the conversion shrinks the Roth from $10,000 to $7,840 on day one, and over 30 years at 7 percent that $2,160 of missing principal costs the Roth $16,442.47 of growth. The lesson is practical: if you have cash outside the IRA, use it to pay the tax. If you do not, convert less, so the tax you have to take from the conversion stays small.

      One more caution for people under 59 and a half: if the tax is withheld from the conversion itself, the withheld amount counts as a distribution, not as a conversion, and it can attract the 10 percent early withdrawal penalty on top of the income tax. Paying from outside funds avoids that entirely. If you are under 59 and a half and cannot pay from outside, convert an amount you can afford to pay tax on from savings, or wait.

      The long-term comparison and the break-even rate

      The long-term comparison projects the same money down two paths. On the Roth path, the converted amount grows tax free at your growth rate for your horizon, and comes out with no further tax. On the traditional path, the same amount grows at the same rate in the traditional IRA, and the whole balance is taxed at your future rate when it comes out. The calculator shows both balances at your horizon, the advantage of the winner, and a year-by-year table so you can see when, if ever, the Roth pulls ahead.

      The break-even future tax rate is the future rate at which the two paths tie. If your actual future rate turns out higher than the break-even rate, the Roth wins. If it turns out lower, the traditional IRA wins. The break-even rate is the one number to hold in your head when you decide. In the first worked example it is 19.11 percent: the conversion pays if your future rate is above 19.11 percent, and the assumed future rate of 22 percent clears it comfortably. In the third example it is 21.6 percent, exactly the effective rate of the conversion, because the tax was paid from the conversion itself: when the tax comes from inside, the break-even rate is the effective rate, and the conversion only pays if your future rate beats the rate you paid.

      The year-by-year table matters because the advantage is not there from day one. In the second worked example, the Roth starts $1,500 behind, is still $405.72 behind after 10 years, and only moves ahead in the final years, finishing $377.34 in front after 15 years. A conversion that needs 15 years to pay off is a different decision from one that pays off in 5, and if your horizon is short, the table shows it plainly. With a horizon of zero, the comparison is just the tax: the Roth is behind by the tax paid, and there is no growth to recover it.

      The comparison assumes the same growth rate every year, a single future tax rate on the whole traditional balance, no fees, and no required minimum distributions. Real returns vary, and the future rate is a guess. Treat the break-even rate as the decision tool and the dollar advantage as an illustration of the size of the bet, not as a prediction. Our Compound Interest Calculator shows how the growth assumption alone moves the numbers, and our Retirement Calculator puts the conversion in the context of your whole retirement picture.

      Worked examples

      Example 1: single filer, $30,000 conversion, Roth wins

      A 64-year-old single filer has $60,000 of taxable income and $95,000 of MAGI, and converts $30,000. Her tax before the conversion is $7,912. The conversion sits entirely in the 22 percent bracket, from $60,000 to $90,000, so the extra federal tax is $30,000 times 22 percent, which is $6,600, and her tax after the conversion is $14,512. Her marginal rate is 22 percent and her effective rate on the conversion is also 22 percent. The room left in the 22 percent bracket is $15,700, up to the bracket top of $105,700. Her MAGI rises to $125,000, crossing the first IRMAA tier, which adds $1,148.40 a year to her 2028 Medicare premiums. The room to the next IRMAA tier is $12,000.

      Over 20 years at 6 percent growth, with the tax paid from outside funds and a future tax rate of 22 percent, the Roth path leaves $78,251.73 after tax and the traditional path leaves $75,046.97. The Roth wins by $3,204.76. The break-even future tax rate is 19.11 percent, so the conversion pays as long as her future rate stays above 19.11 percent. The IRMAA cost of $1,148.40 for one year is real, but it is a single year of premiums against a $3,204.76 long-term advantage, and the 2028 tiers will be higher than the 2026 tiers used here, so the crossing may not even happen.

      Example 2: married couple, $50,000 conversion, a late win

      A 66-year-old married couple filing jointly has $150,000 of taxable income and $180,000 of MAGI, and converts $50,000. Their tax before the conversion is $22,424. The conversion sits entirely in the 22 percent bracket, from $150,000 to $200,000, so the extra federal tax is $11,000, and their tax after the conversion is $33,424. Their state tax at 5 percent adds $2,500, for a total tax now of $13,500. Their marginal rate is 22 percent, and the room left in the 22 percent bracket is $11,400, up to the joint bracket top of $211,400. Their MAGI rises to $230,000, crossing the first IRMAA tier, which adds $1,148.40 a year per person to their 2028 premiums, or $2,296.80 for the household if both spouses are on Medicare. The room to the next tier is $44,000.

      Over 15 years at 5 percent growth, with the tax paid from outside funds and a future tax rate of 24 percent, the Roth path leaves $79,376.61 after tax and the traditional path leaves $78,999.27. The Roth wins by $377.34, but only just, and only late: after 5 years the Roth is $1,019.27 behind, after 10 years it is $405.72 behind, and it moves ahead only in the final years. The break-even future tax rate is 23.68 percent, close to the assumed 24 percent, so this conversion is a marginal call. If their future rate turned out to be 22 percent instead of 24 percent, the traditional IRA would win. This is the kind of case where converting a smaller amount, or waiting for a lower-income year, is worth considering.

      Example 3: younger filer, tax paid from the conversion, traditional wins

      A 45-year-old single filer has $50,000 of taxable income and converts $10,000, paying the tax from the conversion itself. Her tax before the conversion is $5,752. The conversion straddles two brackets: the first $400 is taxed at 12 percent, from $50,000 to the bracket top of $50,400, which is $48, and the remaining $9,600 is taxed at 22 percent, which is $2,112. The extra federal tax is $2,160, her tax after the conversion is $7,912, her marginal rate is 22 percent, and her effective rate on the conversion is 21.6 percent. The room left in the 22 percent bracket is $45,700. She is under 63, so no IRMAA warning applies, and she entered no MAGI.

      Because the tax comes from the conversion, her Roth starts at $7,840, not $10,000. Over 30 years at 7 percent growth, with a future tax rate of 12 percent, the Roth path leaves $59,680.08 and the traditional path leaves $66,987.84. The traditional IRA wins by $7,307.76. The break-even future tax rate is 21.6 percent, exactly the effective rate she paid, and her expected future rate of 12 percent is far below it. She paid 21.6 percent now to avoid 12 percent later, which loses money on its face, and paying the tax from the conversion made it worse by shrinking the Roth on day one. If she expects a 12 percent rate in retirement, she should not convert at 21.6 percent. She should wait for a year when her income is lower, or convert a smaller amount that stays inside the 12 percent bracket.

      The 5-year rule

      There are two 5-year rules, and they do different things. The first governs earnings. A withdrawal of Roth earnings is tax free only if the Roth IRA has been open for at least five years and you are 59 and a half or older, disabled, using up to $10,000 for a first home, or the withdrawal goes to a beneficiary after your death. The five years are counted from 1 January of the first tax year you contributed to any Roth IRA, not from the date of a particular conversion, and the clock runs once for all your Roth IRAs together.

      The second rule governs each conversion separately. Converted amounts can be withdrawn tax free at any time, because you already paid tax on them, but if you withdraw converted money within five years of the conversion and you are under 59 and a half, the 10 percent early withdrawal penalty applies to the amount withdrawn. Each conversion starts its own five-year clock on 1 January of the year of the conversion. The calculator warns you when your horizon is under five years, because a short horizon means you may need the money before the clock runs out. If you are already 59 and a half, the second rule does not bite: the penalty does not apply at that age, and only the earnings rule matters.

      Converted money comes out in a fixed order: regular contributions first, then converted amounts oldest first, then earnings last. That ordering is generous to converters, because the money you can withdraw tax free and penalty free comes out before the earnings. But the ordering does not help if you need the earnings too, and it does not help if you convert money you will need within five years. A conversion is a long-term move. Money you will need soon should stay where it is.

      What your result means

      The headline gives you the extra federal tax and the winner of the long-term comparison. Read the two together: the tax is the price, and the winner is the verdict on whether the price is worth paying at your assumed future rate. A large tax bill is not by itself a reason not to convert, and a Roth win is not by itself a reason to convert, if the break-even rate is close to your assumed future rate and the margin is thin.

      The cards tell the story in stages. Tax before and tax after show the jump. The marginal rate tells you what the next dollar costs. The effective rate tells you what the whole conversion cost on average. The fill-the-bracket room tells you how much more you could convert at the same marginal rate. The IRMAA cards tell you whether the conversion crossed a Medicare tier and what that costs per person per year. The Roth and traditional balances tell you where the two paths end up, and the advantage tells you the size of the bet.

      The chart shows the two balances growing year by year. When the Roth line starts below the traditional line and crosses it, the crossing year is the payback point: the year the conversion starts to pay. When the lines never cross, the conversion does not pay at your assumptions, and the table shows the gap widening. When the Roth line starts above the traditional line, the conversion pays from day one, which usually means your future rate is well above the rate you paid.

      The warnings deserve as much attention as the numbers. An IRMAA crossing warning means a real bill in 2028. A 5-year warning means the money may be locked up when you need it. A required minimum distribution warning means the traditional IRA will start forcing withdrawals inside your horizon, which changes the future rate you should assume, because RMDs can push you into a higher bracket whether you want the money or not. Converting before RMDs start is one of the strongest reasons to convert: every dollar converted is a dollar that will never be forced out as an RMD. Our Social Security Calculator and 401k Calculator help with the other pieces of the retirement picture that a conversion touches.

      Common mistakes to avoid

      Converting at a higher rate than you will ever pay later

      The most expensive mistake is converting in a high-income year at 24 or 32 percent when your retirement rate will be 12 or 22 percent. The break-even rate in the result is the check: if your expected future rate is below it, do not convert, or convert less. The third worked example shows a conversion that loses $7,307.76 for exactly this reason.

      Forgetting the Medicare surcharge

      The tax bill arrives in April. The IRMAA bill arrives two years later, and by then the conversion cannot be undone. A conversion that fills a bracket neatly can still cross a Medicare tier and cost $1,148.40 a year, or $2,296.80 for a couple, for the whole premium year. Check the IRMAA room before you convert, not after.

      Paying the tax from the conversion without realizing the cost

      Withholding tax from the conversion feels painless, because no cash leaves your pocket. But it shrinks the Roth by the tax on day one, and the missing principal never grows. Over 30 years at 7 percent, $2,160 of tax taken from a $10,000 conversion costs $16,442.47 of growth. Pay from a taxable account when you can.

      Forgetting the pro-rata rule

      If you have after-tax money in any traditional, SEP, or SIMPLE IRA, part of every conversion is tax free, and you cannot choose to convert only the after-tax part. People who convert expecting a tax-free backdoor Roth and discover the pro-rata rule afterwards get a surprise tax bill. Check your Form 8606 basis before you convert.

      Converting money you will need within five years

      Converted amounts withdrawn within five years of the conversion attract the 10 percent penalty if you are under 59 and a half. A conversion is a long-term move. Money you will need for a house deposit, a car, or living costs in the next few years should stay in the traditional IRA or in a taxable account.

      Ignoring the effect on Social Security and other benefits

      A conversion raises your income, and higher income can make more of your Social Security taxable, reduce premium tax credits for marketplace insurance, and push investment income over the net investment income tax threshold of $200,000, or $250,000 on a joint return. This calculator models the federal tax and the Medicare surcharge. It does not model Social Security taxation or premium tax credits, so check those separately before you convert a large amount.

      Converting everything in one year

      A large conversion in one year pushes the top slices into high brackets and can jump two Medicare tiers at once. Spreading the same total over several years, filling the same bracket each year, usually costs less tax in total and keeps the Medicare surcharge lower. The fill-the-bracket room in the result is the annual amount to aim for.

      Using the wrong income figure

      The calculator needs taxable income before the conversion, not salary and not AGI. Entering your salary overstates the tax, because it ignores your deductions. Entering your AGI overstates it too, for the same reason. Use Form 1040, line 15, or work it out with our Tax Calculator first. And remember that the IRMAA check needs MAGI, which is a different figure again: closer to AGI than to taxable income.

      Frequently asked questions

      How much tax will I pay on a Roth conversion?

      The converted amount is added to your taxable income and taxed bracket by bracket at your ordinary income tax rates. If your income is already in the 22 percent bracket and the conversion stays inside it, a $30,000 conversion costs $6,600 in federal tax. If the conversion crosses into the next bracket, the part above the line is taxed at the higher rate. Enter your taxable income and conversion amount above for the exact bracket-by-bracket figure.

      What is the IRMAA two-year lookback?

      Medicare sets your premiums from the tax return filed two years before the premium year, so a 2026 conversion affects your 2028 Part B and Part D premiums. If the conversion pushes your modified adjusted gross income over a threshold, a surcharge applies for the whole premium year: the first tier adds $1,148.40 a year per person. The calculator warns you when a conversion crosses or approaches a tier.

      Should I pay the conversion tax from outside funds?

      Yes, when you can. Paying from a taxable account leaves the full conversion amount in the Roth to grow tax free. Paying from the conversion itself shrinks the Roth by the tax on day one, and the missing principal never grows: on a $10,000 conversion at 7 percent growth for 30 years, $2,160 of tax taken from the conversion costs $16,442.47 of growth. If you are under 59 and a half, tax withheld from the conversion can also attract the 10 percent early withdrawal penalty.

      What is the break-even future tax rate?

      The break-even future tax rate is the future tax rate at which the Roth path and the traditional IRA path leave you with the same amount after tax. If your actual future rate turns out higher than the break-even rate, the Roth wins. If it turns out lower, the traditional IRA wins. When the tax is paid from the conversion itself, the break-even rate equals the effective rate you paid on the conversion.

      What is the 5-year rule for Roth conversions?

      There are two 5-year rules. The earnings rule says Roth earnings are tax free only if the account has been open five years and you are 59 and a half or meet another qualifying condition. The conversion rule says each conversion has its own five-year clock: withdraw converted money within five years and before age 59 and a half, and the 10 percent early withdrawal penalty applies. After 59 and a half, only the earnings rule matters.

      Can I undo a Roth conversion?

      No. Recharacterization of Roth conversions was eliminated by the Tax Cuts and Jobs Act from 1 January 2018. A conversion is final the moment it is made, so the arithmetic has to be done before you convert, not after. If the answer is close, convert a smaller amount this year and more next year rather than converting too much at once.

      Does a Roth conversion affect my required minimum distributions?

      Yes, and usually for the better. Money you convert leaves the traditional IRA, so your future required minimum distributions fall, and the Roth IRA has no required minimum distributions for the owner. Required minimum distributions start at age 73 if you were born between 1951 and 1959, and at age 75 if you were born in 1960 or later. Converting in the years before distributions start is one of the strongest reasons to convert.

      How much should I convert each year?

      A common approach is to convert up to the top of your current tax bracket, or up to the next Medicare tier, whichever room is smaller, and to repeat that each year in low-income years. Spreading a large conversion over several years usually costs less tax in total than converting everything at once. The calculator shows both rooms after your conversion, so you can see how much more fits this year.

      Sources

      2026 federal income tax brackets and the bracket formula: IRS Revenue Procedure 2025-32, section 4.01, irs.gov/pub/irs-drop/rp-25-32.pdf. 2026 Medicare Part B standard premium of $202.90 a month and the 2026 IRMAA tiers and surcharges: Centers for Medicare and Medicaid Services, "2026 Medicare Parts A and B Premiums and Deductibles" fact sheet, 14 November 2025, cms.gov/newsroom/fact-sheets/2026-medicare-parts-b-premiums-deductibles. Roth conversion rules, including that converted amounts are taxed as ordinary income and reported on Form 8606, and that recharacterization of conversions was eliminated from 1 January 2018: IRS, "Retirement plans FAQs regarding IRAs", irs.gov/retirement-plans/retirement-plans-faqs-regarding-iras. Roth IRA rules, including the 5-year rules and qualified distributions: IRS Publication 590-B, Distributions from Individual Retirement Arrangements, irs.gov/publications/p590b. Required minimum distribution ages under SECURE 2.0: IRS, "Retirement plan and IRA required minimum distributions FAQs", irs.gov/retirement-plans/retirement-plan-and-ira-required-minimum-distributions-faqs. All sources checked 20 November 2026.

      See also: Tax Calculator, Retirement Calculator, Compound Interest Calculator, 401k Calculator, Social Security Calculator, Investment Calculator.