Skip to content

Beauty Rewards Value Calculator

What you spend on beauty in a year, before tax and shipping, across all three stores. The calculator works out what that same spend would earn at each store. Enter 0 if you only want the value of the points you already hold.

Ulta Beauty Rewards

Platinum needs $500 of spend a year; Diamond needs $1,200.

Whole points, 0 to 100,000. Leave blank for 0.

Sephora Beauty Insider

Every tier earns 1 point per $1. VIB needs $350 of spend a year; Rouge needs $1,000 and unlocks the $100 Rouge Reward and $20 Rouge Cash.

Whole points, 0 to 100,000. Leave blank for 0.

Bath and Body Works Rewards

Whole points, 0 to 100,000. Every 1,000 points is one free product. Leave blank for 0.

A reward covers one item up to $18.95. Enter the price of the item you would actually pick: a $9.95 hand soap is worth less than an $18.95 body cream.

Your beauty rewards

How the numbers were worked out

      This tool estimates the dollar value of your Ulta, Sephora, and Bath and Body Works points from the program rules and the numbers you enter, for general guidance only. It is not financial advice. Program terms change, and the value of a point depends on how you redeem it, so check the current terms on each retailer's own site before acting on a figure here.
      Your beauty points are worth what they redeem for, and the three programs pay back very differently: Bath and Body Works returns 18.95% of your spending as free products, Ulta returns up to 9.38% at Diamond status with points saved to 2,000, and Sephora returns 2.00% as cash, or 4.00% for Rouge members saving to a 2,500-point Rouge Reward. At $600 a year of spending, the three programs pay $113.70, $30.00, and $10.00. Enter your spend and your points balances above for the dollar value of each balance and the best redemption for each.

      Last reviewed: 20 November 2026. Reviewed every 180 days; next review due 19 May 2027.

      How to use the Beauty Rewards Value Calculator

      Three of the biggest beauty retailers in the United States run loyalty programs that look similar on the surface and pay back very differently underneath. Ulta Beauty Rewards gives you points that get more valuable the longer you save them. Sephora Beauty Insider gives you a flat rate that only jumps for Rouge members. Bath and Body Works Rewards gives you a free product every 1,000 points, which works out to the highest return of the three by a wide margin. This calculator puts your own numbers through all three programs at once: the dollar value of the points you already hold, the best way to redeem each balance, what a year of your spending earns at each store, and which program pays back the most.

      To get your result, follow these steps:

      1. Enter your annual beauty spend. This is what you spend on beauty in a year, before tax and shipping, across all three stores. The calculator works out what that same spend would earn if it all went to Ulta, all to Sephora, or all to Bath and Body Works, so the three annual values are directly comparable. Enter 0 if you only want the value of the points you already hold and do not want the yearly comparison.
      2. Pick your Ulta tier and enter your Ulta points balance. Member earns 1 point per $1, Platinum earns 1.25 points per $1, and Diamond earns 1.5 points per $1. Platinum needs $500 of spend in a calendar year; Diamond needs $1,200. Enter your current points balance as a whole number. The calculator finds the combination of redemption increments worth the most for that balance, and tells you how many more points would reach the next step up.
      3. Pick your Sephora tier and enter your Sephora points balance. Every Sephora tier earns 1 point per $1, so the tier does not change how fast you earn. It changes what you can redeem: every member can turn 500 points into $10 of Beauty Insider Cash, and Rouge members can also turn 1,000 points into $20 of Rouge Cash and 2,500 points into a $100 Rouge Reward, which is twice the value per point. VIB needs $350 of spend a year; Rouge needs $1,000.
      4. Enter your Bath and Body Works points balance and the value of the free item you would pick. Every 1,000 points is one free product, and the reward covers one item with a regular price up to $18.95. The value of your points depends on what you pick: a free $18.95 body cream is worth nearly twice a free $9.95 hand soap, so enter the price of the item you would actually choose. The default is $18.95, the current cap.

      The tool updates as you type, so you can try different numbers quickly. Try the example buttons under the form: the defaults show an everyday shopper spending $600 a year as a Platinum member with 1,250 Ulta points, a VIB member with 750 Sephora points, and 1,500 Bath and Body Works points; the second example is a big spender at $1,500 a year with Diamond and Rouge status and large balances; the third is someone just starting out, with small balances that have not reached a redemption yet; and the fourth is a points hoarder who has saved 9,850 Ulta points. The four examples show the four shapes the answer takes: a spread of small balances, a large total, nothing redeemable yet, and a balance that is worth real money.

      Read the full result, not just the headline. The headline leads with the total dollar value of your points and names the program that pays back the most on your spend. The cards show the value of each balance separately. The comparison table puts the three programs side by side for the same spend: points earned in a year, value a year, percent back, value per point, and balance value. The three detail boxes break down each program's best redemption, the next milestone, and the tier picture. The guidance explains the result in plain language, the warnings flag expiry dates and tiers you would not requalify for, and the steps print the full working so you can check every figure.

      How it works

      The calculator runs three calculations, one per program, then compares them. Each program's calculation has the same shape: points earned in a year from your spend, the value of those points at the best redemption, the percent back on your spend, and the value of the balance you already hold at the best redemption. The comparison is honest because the same spend goes through each program: the annual values answer the question "what would this spend earn if it all went to this store", not "what do I earn by splitting it three ways". Your balances are separate and real, so those are added together for the total. The annual values are never added together, because the same dollar cannot be spent at three stores at once.

      Ulta: points earned, then the best combination

      Ulta points are earned at your tier rate: 1, 1.25, or 1.5 points per $1 of qualifying spend. The points earned in a year are your spend times your rate, rounded down to whole points, because points only exist as whole numbers. A Platinum member spending $600 a year earns 750 points (600 x 1.25). A Diamond member spending $1,500 earns 2,250 points (1,500 x 1.5). A Member spending $300 earns 300 points.

      The value of a points total comes from Ulta's redemption table, and this is where the calculator does real work. Ulta lets you redeem points in any combination of six increments: 100 points for $3.00, 250 for $8.00, 500 for $17.50, 750 for $30.00, 1,000 for $50.00, and 2,000 for $125.00. Because the value per point rises at every step, the best combination is usually the biggest increments first, but not always. For 3,400 points, the obvious greedy split is 2,000 + 1,000 + 250 + 100, worth $186.00 with 50 points left over. The calculator finds a better one: 2,000 + 1,000 + 100 + 100 + 100 + 100, worth $187.00 with nothing left over, because four $3.00 redemptions beat one $8.00 redemption plus a wasted 50 points. For 300 points, three 100-point redemptions ($9.00) beat one 250-point redemption ($8.00) with 50 points stranded. The calculator solves the full combination problem for every balance, so the value it reports is the maximum, not an approximation.

      The calculator also reports the next milestone: the next redemption step above your balance, how many more points it needs, and how much more the balance would be worth there. That number is often the most useful one on the page. A balance of 1,999 points is worth $86.00 (1,000 + 750 + 100 + 100). One more point reaches 2,000, worth $125.00: a single point is worth $39.00 at that boundary, because it unlocks the top tier. A balance of 1,250 points is worth $58.00 (1,000 + 250), and 750 more points would reach 2,000, worth $125.00, a gain of $67.00.

      Sephora: flat rate, with one big exception

      Sephora is simpler. Every tier earns 1 point per $1, so a year of spending earns exactly your spend in points, rounded down. The cash redemption is 500 points for $10.00 of Beauty Insider Cash, which is 2 cents a point, for every member. Rouge members get two extra options: 1,000 points for $20.00 of Rouge Cash, which is the same 2 cents a point in a single redemption instead of two, and 2,500 points for a $100 Rouge Reward, which is 4 cents a point, twice the rate. The calculator takes as many Rouge Rewards as fit for Rouge members, then fills the rest with $20 Rouge Cash redemptions, falling back to $10 cash for a leftover 500 points. A Rouge member with 2,500 points holds $100.00. The same 2,500 points for an Insider or VIB member are five $10 cash redemptions, $50.00. The tier is worth $50.00 on that balance alone.

      Two Sephora details matter for the value. First, Beauty Insider Cash can be redeemed only once per transaction, so for an Insider or VIB member a balance of 5,000 points is ten $10 redemptions across ten separate purchases, not $100 off one purchase. A Rouge member with 5,000 points takes two $100 Rouge Rewards instead, and even Rouge Cash is one redemption per transaction, so two $20 Rouge Cash redemptions still need two purchases. Second, the Rewards Bazaar, where points buy deluxe samples, full-size products, and experiences, has no cash value in this calculator. A 750-point sample set might be worth more to you than $10 off, but Sephora does not publish a cash value for Bazaar rewards, so the calculator values only the cash options and says so. If you mainly redeem for Bazaar samples, your real return is higher than the figure here, by an amount that depends on what you pick.

      Bath and Body Works: the simplest math, the highest return

      Bath and Body Works has no tiers and one rule: 10 points per $1, and every 1,000 points is one Reward, a free product with a regular price up to $18.95. A year of $600 spending earns 6,000 points, six rewards, worth $113.70 at the $18.95 cap. That is 18.95% back on the spend, before any sale or coupon. The same $600 at Ulta as a Platinum member earns $30.00 (5.00% back), and at Sephora as a VIB member earns $10.00 (1.67% back). The gap is not close, and it is not a trick of the calculator: the program genuinely returns nearly a fifth of what you spend, in free products, as long as you pick items near the $18.95 cap.

      The item you pick is the whole ballgame at Bath and Body Works, which is why the calculator asks for it. Six rewards spent on $18.95 body creams are worth $113.70. Six rewards spent on $9.95 hand soaps are worth $59.70, which is 9.95% back: still the best of the three programs, but barely half the headline rate. A reward cannot be applied as a credit toward a more expensive item, so a $26.95 three-wick candle cannot be bought with a reward plus cash: the reward only covers items priced at $18.95 or less. Pick the most expensive eligible item you actually want, and the return follows.

      Worked example 1: the defaults, an everyday shopper

      Annual spend $600, Ulta Platinum, 1,250 Ulta points, Sephora VIB, 750 Sephora points, 1,500 Bath and Body Works points, free item value $18.95.

      • Ulta: 600 x 1.25 = 750 points a year, worth $30.00 at the 750-point step, 5.00% back. The 1,250-point balance is worth $58.00 (1,000 + 250). Next step: 2,000 points, worth $125.00, 750 points away, a gain of $67.00.
      • Sephora: 600 x 1 = 600 points a year, worth $10.00 as one Beauty Insider Cash, 1.67% back. The 750-point balance is worth $10.00, with 250 points left over. Next step: 1,000 points, worth $20.00, 250 points away, a gain of $10.00.
      • Bath and Body Works: 600 x 10 = 6,000 points a year, six free products at $18.95, worth $113.70, 18.95% back. The 1,500-point balance is one free product, $18.95, with 500 points left over. Next reward: 500 more points, about $50.00 of spending.
      • Total value of the points held: $58.00 + $10.00 + $18.95 = $86.95. Best payback on the spend: Bath and Body Works, $113.70 a year.
      • Tier picture: $600 of spend earns Ulta Platinum (needs $500) and Sephora VIB (needs $350). Another $600.00 a year of Ulta spending would reach Diamond; another $400.00 a year of Sephora spending would reach Rouge.

      The lesson of this example is the spread. The same $600 a year is worth $113.70 at one store, $30.00 at the second, and $10.00 at the third. The balances tell a different story from the yearly rates: the Ulta balance is worth the most of the three ($58.00), because Ulta points grow in value as they pile up, while the Sephora balance is worth the least ($10.00) even though the shopper holds 750 points there. Points are not interchangeable, and counting them is not the same as valuing them.

      Worked example 2: a big spender with Diamond and Rouge status

      Annual spend $1,500, Ulta Diamond, 3,400 Ulta points, Sephora Rouge, 2,800 Sephora points, 4,200 Bath and Body Works points, free item value $18.95.

      • Ulta: 1,500 x 1.5 = 2,250 points a year, worth $133.00 (2,000 + 250), 8.87% back. The 3,400-point balance is worth $187.00 (2,000 + 1,000 + 100 + 100 + 100 + 100), 5.50 cents a point on the points spent.
      • Sephora: 1,500 x 1 = 1,500 points a year, worth $30.00 as one $20 Rouge Cash Reward and one $10 Beauty Insider Cash, 2.00% back. The 2,800-point balance is worth $100.00 as one Rouge Reward, with 300 points left over. The next Rouge Reward is 2,200 points away, at 5,000 points.
      • Bath and Body Works: 1,500 x 10 = 15,000 points a year, 15 free products, worth $284.25, 18.95% back. The 4,200-point balance is four free products, $75.80, with 200 points left over.
      • Total value of the points held: $187.00 + $100.00 + $75.80 = $362.80. Best payback on the spend: Bath and Body Works, $284.25 a year.

      Even at the top tier of both beauty programs, Bath and Body Works pays back more than twice as much in a year ($284.25 against $133.00 at Ulta and $30.00 at Sephora). The Ulta balance is the most valuable single holding ($187.00), because 3,400 points saved to the top redemption step are worth 5.50 cents each. The Sephora balance shows the Rouge effect clearly: 2,800 points are worth $100.00 as a Rouge Reward, where the same points for a VIB member would be five $10 cash redemptions, $50.00, with 300 points left over.

      Worked example 3: just starting out, nothing redeemable yet

      Annual spend $150, Ulta Member, 80 Ulta points, Sephora Insider, 120 Sephora points, 300 Bath and Body Works points, free item value $18.95.

      • Ulta: 150 x 1 = 150 points a year, worth $3.00 (one 100-point redemption, 50 points left over), 2.00% back. The 80-point balance is worth $0.00: 20 more points reach the first redemption.
      • Sephora: 150 points a year, worth $0.00: below the 500-point first redemption. The 120-point balance is worth $0.00: 380 more points reach the first $10.
      • Bath and Body Works: 1,500 points a year, one free product, worth $18.95, 12.63% back. The 300-point balance is worth $0.00: 700 more points, about $70.00 of spending, reach the first reward.
      • Total value of the points held: $0.00. Best payback on the spend: Bath and Body Works, $18.95 a year.

      This example shows why the first redemption threshold matters more than the earn rate. Sephora earns points at the same rate as Ulta for a Member, but its first redemption is five times further away, so a light spender can go a whole year at Sephora and hold nothing spendable. Bath and Body Works pays back fastest at low spend because the first reward arrives after $100, and a $150 year already clears it.

      Worked example 4: a points hoarder

      Annual spend $300, Ulta Member, 9,850 Ulta points, Sephora VIB, 4,900 Sephora points, 8,750 Bath and Body Works points, free item value $18.95.

      • Ulta: 300 points a year, worth $9.00 (three 100-point redemptions), 3.00% back. The 9,850-point balance is worth $583.00: four 2,000-point redemptions ($500.00), one 1,000-point redemption ($50.00), one 750-point redemption ($30.00), and one 100-point redemption ($3.00). Another 150 points would reach 10,000 points, worth $625.00, a gain of $42.00.
      • Sephora: 300 points a year, worth $0.00. The 4,900-point balance is worth $90.00 as nine $10 Beauty Insider Cash redemptions, with 400 points left over. Another 100 points would reach 5,000 points, worth $100.00.
      • Bath and Body Works: 3,000 points a year, three free products, worth $56.85, 18.95% back. The 8,750-point balance is eight free products, $151.60, with 750 points left over. Another 250 points, about $25.00 of spending, would earn the ninth.
      • Total value of the points held: $583.00 + $90.00 + $151.60 = $824.60. Best payback on the spend: Bath and Body Works, $56.85 a year.

      The hoarder's Ulta balance is the star: 9,850 points saved to the top steps are worth $583.00, which is 5.92 cents a point, nearly double the 3 cents a point they would be worth redeemed 100 at a time ($294.00 for 98 redemptions, with 50 points left over). Saving paid off by $289.00. The same hoarding at Sephora did nothing: 4,900 points are worth $90.00 whether they were saved up or spent as they came, because the cash rate is flat. The calculator also warns this shopper about two practical limits: Ulta caps online redemptions at 4,000 points per purchase, so the 9,850-point balance needs at least three online orders (or one in-store visit, where the cap is 10,000), and the nine $10 Beauty Insider Cash redemptions need nine separate transactions.

      The three programs side by side

      All three programs are free to join, and all three pay points on qualifying purchases only: gift cards, taxes, shipping, and fees do not earn points at any of them. Beyond that, they differ in almost every way that matters: how fast points arrive, how much a point is worth, whether saving helps, and how long points last.

      FeatureUlta Beauty RewardsSephora Beauty InsiderBath and Body Works Rewards
      Earn rate1, 1.25, or 1.5 points per $1 by tier1 point per $1 at every tier10 points per $1, no tiers
      TiersMember, Platinum ($500 a year), Diamond ($1,200 a year)Insider, VIB ($350 a year), Rouge ($1,000 a year)None
      First redemption100 points, $3.00 off500 points, $10 Beauty Insider Cash1,000 points, one free product up to $18.95
      Best value per point6.25 cents (2,000 points for $125.00)4 cents (Rouge Reward, 2,500 points for $100)1.895 cents (1,000 points for an $18.95 item)
      Best return on spend9.38% (Diamond, saved to 2,000 points)4.00% (Rouge, saved to 2,500 points)18.95% (any member, $18.95 item)
      Does saving points help?Yes, a lot: 3 cents a point at 100 points, 6.25 cents at 2,000Only for Rouge members saving to 2,500No: every 1,000 points is one reward
      Points expiryMembers: end of the quarter one year after earning. Platinum and Diamond: never, while the tier is kept12 months with no point activity12 months with no purchase; rewards expire 90 days after issue
      Redemption limits4,000 points per online purchase, 10,000 in storeBeauty Insider Cash once per transactionUp to 8 rewards per transaction

      The "best return on spend" row is the one that surprises people, and it is worth reading carefully. Ulta's best return, 9.38%, needs Diamond status (1.5 points per $1) and a balance saved all the way to 2,000 points (6.25 cents a point): 1.5 x 6.25 cents is 9.375 cents back per dollar, rounded to 9.38%. A Platinum member saving to 2,000 points gets 7.81% (1.25 x 6.25). A Member saving to 2,000 points gets 6.25%. Redeem at the 100-point step instead and those figures fall to 4.50%, 3.75%, and 3.00%. Sephora's best return, 4.00%, needs Rouge status and a 2,500-point Rouge Reward; every other Sephora redemption is 2.00%. Bath and Body Works needs nothing but the $18.95 item pick: 10 points per $1, and each 1,000 points is $18.95, so every $100 of spend returns $18.95, which is 18.95% back for any member at any spend level.

      Value per point and return on spend are different measures, and the table shows why both matter. Bath and Body Works has the lowest value per point of the three (1.895 cents) and the highest return on spend (18.95%), because it hands out ten points per dollar. Ulta has the highest value per point (6.25 cents) but only a middle return, because it hands out one to one and a half points per dollar. Comparing points across programs without converting to dollars is meaningless: 1,000 Ulta points are worth $50.00, 1,000 Sephora points are worth $20.00, and 1,000 Bath and Body Works points are worth $18.95. The calculator converts everything to dollars for exactly this reason.

      Ulta Beauty Rewards in detail

      Ulta Beauty Rewards is the only one of the three programs where the earn rate and the redemption value both rise with loyalty. Members earn 1 point per $1, Platinum members earn 1.25 points per $1, and Diamond members earn 1.5 points per $1. Platinum needs $500 of qualifying spend in a calendar year; Diamond needs $1,200. Status, once earned, lasts for the rest of that year and through December 31 of the following year, and you requalify each year to keep it. The calculator checks your spend against those thresholds and warns you when the tier you picked is one your spend would not requalify for.

      The redemption table is the heart of the program, and it rewards patience more than any other beauty program in the country:

      Points redeemedDiscountValue per pointReturn on $1 of spend (Member)
      100$3.003.00 cents3.00%
      250$8.003.20 cents3.20%
      500$17.503.50 cents3.50%
      750$30.004.00 cents4.00%
      1,000$50.005.00 cents5.00%
      2,000$125.006.25 cents6.25%

      The jump from 1,000 to 2,000 points is the biggest single step in the table: the second thousand points are worth $75.00, against $50.00 for the first thousand. That is why the calculator's next-milestone figure matters so much at Ulta, and why a balance sitting just below 2,000 points is the worst place to stop. A balance of 1,999 points is worth $86.00; one more point makes it $125.00. A balance of 1,000 points is worth $50.00; another 1,000 points more than doubles it.

      Three practical rules govern Ulta redemptions. First, points can be redeemed in any combination of the six increments, in store or online, which is what makes the calculator's combination search possible. Second, redemptions are capped at 4,000 points per online purchase and 10,000 points in store, so a very large balance takes more than one order to spend online. Third, points cannot be redeemed toward gift cards, taxes, tips, shipping, or fees, and cannot be earned on those either. Points also cannot be earned or redeemed on third-party marketplace purchases, such as DoorDash or Instacart orders.

      Expiry is the one place Ulta punishes casual members. Regular Members lose points at the end of the quarter one year after the points were earned, so points earned in the first quarter of 2026 expire at the end of the first quarter of 2027. Platinum and Diamond points never expire while the tier is kept, which is a real reason to reach Platinum beyond the faster earning: a Member who saves points toward 2,000 risks losing them before getting there, while a Platinum member can save without a clock. The calculator warns Members with a balance about the expiry rule.

      One figure in this article deserves a note, because published sources disagree about it. Some comparisons, including a 2026 USA Today piece, put the Ulta Platinum threshold at $350 a year. Ulta's own rewards page, checked on 20 November 2026, puts it at $500, in both its tier table and its FAQ ("You can reach Platinum status by spending $500 on qualifying purchases between January 1 and December 31 of a calendar year"), and two other sources agree with $500. The retailer's own page governs, so this calculator uses $500. The $350 figure appears to be a confusion with Sephora's VIB threshold, which is $350. If you have seen $350 quoted for Ulta Platinum, that is where it came from.

      Sephora Beauty Insider in detail

      Sephora Beauty Insider is the simplest of the three programs to understand and the weakest on cash value. Every tier earns 1 point per $1 of merchandise spend, online, in Sephora stores, at Sephora at Kohl's, and through Instacart, DoorDash, and Uber Eats with a linked account. There is no faster earning at higher tiers, which is the opposite of Ulta: spending more at Sephora buys you better sale discounts and better gifts, not more points per dollar. VIB status needs $350 of spend in a calendar year; Rouge needs $1,000.

      The cash redemption is Beauty Insider Cash: 500 points for $10 off a purchase of $10 or more, in store or online, once per transaction. That is a flat 2 cents a point, and it is the same for every member. Rouge members have a second cash option, published in Sephora's own Beauty Insider Terms and Conditions: 1,000 points for $20 off, the same 2 cents a point in one redemption instead of two, though it cannot be used at Sephora at Kohl's or on Kohls.com. The one exception to the flat rate is the Rouge Reward: Rouge members can trade 2,500 points for a $100 reward, usable online or in store for merchandise, which is 4 cents a point. A Rouge Reward expires 90 days after the confirmation email, cannot be combined with promotional discounts, and cannot be used on Buy Online, Pick Up In Store or Same Day Delivery orders. Items bought with a Rouge Reward cannot be returned, though unopened items can be exchanged in store for the exact same item.

      The flat rate makes Sephora the program where hoarding points does nothing for cash value. A VIB member with 5,000 points holds ten $10 redemptions, $100.00, and would have held the same $100.00 if the points had been spent 500 at a time as they arrived. Only a Rouge member gains from saving, and only up to each 2,500-point mark: 5,000 points for a Rouge member are two Rouge Rewards, $200.00, against $100.00 in cash redemptions. The calculator takes the Rouge Rewards first for Rouge members and fills the remainder with $20 Rouge Cash, falling back to $10 cash for a leftover 500 points, which is always the best split, because 4 cents a point beats 2 cents a point on every point it covers.

      What the calculator does not value is the Rewards Bazaar, and that is a deliberate limit, not an oversight. The Bazaar offers deluxe samples from 50 points, three 100-point rewards for 250 points online, full-size products for VIB and Rouge members, and experiences up to 100,000 points, with new rewards dropping on Tuesdays and Thursdays. Those rewards have no published cash value, and their worth depends entirely on whether you want the item: a 750-point sample set of products you would buy anyway is worth more than $10 off, and a 750-point sample set of products you would never buy is worth nothing. The calculator values Sephora points as cash only, and says so in its notes. If you redeem mostly in the Bazaar, treat the Sephora figure here as a floor, not a total.

      Sephora points expire after 12 months with no point activity, through a purchase, a redemption, or a Birthday Gift. Points can also go negative: if you return merchandise, all points earned from that purchase are deducted, and a return can push the balance below zero. The calculator does not accept negative balances, because a negative balance is a debt to the program, not a holding to value, and the right move is to earn back to zero before thinking about redemptions.

      Bath and Body Works Rewards in detail

      My Bath and Body Works Rewards, to give it its full name, is the simplest program of the three and the most generous. There are no tiers: every member earns 10 points per $1 of eligible spend, and every 1,000 points becomes one Reward, a free full-size product with a regular price up to $18.95. The program is free to join, open to US residents only, and run through the app and the website. New members get a $10 off $30 welcome coupon, and members get a free birthday item up to $9.95 with any purchase.

      The math is one line: every $100 of eligible spend earns one free product worth up to $18.95, which is 18.95% back. There is no tier to chase, no redemption table to optimize, and no benefit to saving points past 1,000: two rewards are worth exactly twice one reward. The only decision that moves the return is which item you pick for each reward. The reward applies to the most expensive eligible product in the transaction, and up to eight rewards can be used in one transaction, so a shopper with eight rewards can walk out with eight free products in one visit. Sale prices do not count toward the cap: the cap is the regular ticket price, so a product on sale for $9.95 with a regular price of $18.95 still qualifies for a reward — but the reward only saves you the $9.95 sale price, not the full $18.95, so a reward spent on a sale item is worth less than one spent at full price. The reward cannot be used as $18.95 of credit toward a $26.95 three-wick candle.

      Two expiry rules matter, and both are short. Rewards expire 90 days after they are issued, and they are not replaced or reissued once expired. Points, or accrued eligible spend, expire 12 months after they are earned, or after 12 consecutive months with no purchases. A shopper who earns a reward in January and forgets it until May has lost it. The calculator warns about both clocks whenever you hold Bath and Body Works points.

      One honest caveat: Bath and Body Works' own FAQ says the reward value varies by market and is provided in the welcome email, rather than publishing the $18.95 cap on the FAQ page itself. The $18.95 figure is confirmed by every current independent guide checked in November 2026, and by the brand's own rewards pages as reported by those guides, and it rose from $16.95 to $18.95 in May 2025, which is why older guides still quote $16.95 or even $16.50. Because the value can vary by market, the calculator lets you enter the value of the item you would actually pick, up to $18.95, instead of hard-coding the cap. If your market's cap is lower, enter your real figure and the return adjusts.

      The program's real limit is not in the math but in the shelf. Bath and Body Works sells body care, hand soap, and home fragrance. Its 18.95% return is the best in beauty, but it only applies to spending at Bath and Body Works, and a shopper who wants foundation, serum, or salon hair care cannot spend the return there. The comparison table in the calculator answers the narrow question, what does this spend earn at each store, and the honest answer for most shoppers is a mix: Bath and Body Works for the categories it covers, Ulta or Sephora for the rest.

      Which program pays back the most

      The short answer is Bath and Body Works, at every spend level, by a wide margin. The longer answer is that the ranking depends on what you buy, because the three stores do not sell the same things, and the best program for your money is the best program among the stores that stock what you actually use. The table below runs the same four spend levels through all three programs, at the tier each spend level earns, with the free item valued at $18.95.

      Annual spendUlta (tier earned)Sephora (tier earned)Bath and Body Works
      $100Member: 100 points, $3.00, 3.00% backInsider: 100 points, $0.00, 0.00% back1,000 points, $18.95, 18.95% back
      $300Member: 300 points, $9.00, 3.00% backInsider: 300 points, $0.00, 0.00% back3,000 points, $56.85, 18.95% back
      $600Platinum: 750 points, $30.00, 5.00% backVIB: 600 points, $10.00, 1.67% back6,000 points, $113.70, 18.95% back
      $1,200Diamond: 1,800 points, $80.00, 6.67% backRouge: 1,200 points, $20.00, 1.67% back12,000 points, $227.40, 18.95% back

      The table applies each tier's earn rate to the full year of spending, which slightly overstates the first year you reach a tier, when part of the year's spend earned at the lower rate. The calculator does the same and says so in its notes. Even with that caveat, the pattern is unmistakable: Bath and Body Works returns roughly three to six times what Ulta returns, and more than eleven times what Sephora returns at the spend levels where Sephora pays anything at all. At $100 and $300 a year, Sephora pays nothing, because a year of points does not reach the 500-point first redemption.

      Sephora's weak showing in the table needs the Bazaar caveat again. At $1,200 of spend, a Rouge member's 1,200 points are worth $20.00 in cash, but the same points could buy Bazaar rewards that the member values more: deluxe samples, full-size products, or experiences. The cash comparison is the only one that can be computed exactly, and on cash Sephora is last by a long way. A shopper who loves the Bazaar and never takes cash should read the Sephora column as a floor.

      Ulta's column shows the two levers that move its return: the tier rate and the redemption step. At $600, a Platinum member earns $30.00 (5.00% back), while a Member at the same spend earns $20.50 (3.42% back) from 600 points redeemed as 500 + 100. At $1,200, a Diamond member earns $80.00 (6.67% back) from 1,800 points redeemed as 1,000 + 750, while a Member at the same spend earns $56.00 (4.67% back) from 1,200 points redeemed as 1,000 + 100 + 100. The tier is worth $9.50 a year at $600 of spend and $24.00 a year at $1,200, before counting the birthday coupon, the free shipping, and the points that never expire.

      For most shoppers, the practical answer is not to pick one program but to route spending deliberately. Buy body care, hand soap, and home fragrance at Bath and Body Works, where every $100 returns $18.95. Buy the rest at Ulta if you can reach Platinum, because the 1.25 rate plus the rising redemption table beats Sephora's flat 2 cents a point on cash value, and because Ulta's points never expire at Platinum and above. Keep Sephora for the brands only Sephora carries, for the twice-yearly Savings Event discounts, and for the Bazaar rewards you actually want, and treat its points as a small bonus rather than a return to optimize. If you shop at all three stores, our Budget Calculator helps you set the yearly beauty figure this calculator starts from, and our Discount Calculator checks whether a sale price beats the points you would earn at full price.

      The same comparison logic applies beyond beauty. If you hold points in other programs, our Airline Miles Value Calculator prices frequent-flyer miles, our Hotel Points Value Calculator values hotel points, our Nordstrom Rewards Calculator values Nordstrom Notes, and our REI Membership Value Calculator works out the REI dividend. Points are only worth what they redeem for, in every program, and the habit of converting them to dollars before comparing them is worth more than any single program's rules.

      Common mistakes

      Counting points instead of dollars. A shopper with 5,000 Sephora points and 1,000 Ulta points does not hold five times as much at Sephora: the Sephora balance is worth $100.00 in cash redemptions (or $200.00 for a Rouge member) and the Ulta balance is worth $50.00. A shopper with 5,000 Bath and Body Works points holds five free products, $94.75 at the cap. Points are a currency with three different exchange rates, and the only honest comparison is in dollars.

      Redeeming Ulta points 100 at a time. Every 100-point redemption is worth 3 cents a point. Every 2,000-point redemption is worth 6.25 cents a point. A shopper who redeems 2,000 points as twenty 100-point redemptions gets $60.00; the same 2,000 points in one redemption get $125.00. The difference is $65.00, more than double. Save Ulta points to at least 1,000, and to 2,000 when you can, unless you are a regular Member facing the expiry clock.

      Redeeming Sephora points as cash when you are Rouge. A Rouge member who turns 2,500 points into cash gets $50.00: two $20 Rouge Cash redemptions and one $10 cash redemption, across three separate purchases. The same 2,500 points as a Rouge Reward get $100.00. The cash option is always available, so there is no reason to take it while a Rouge Reward is within reach, unless the 90-day expiry on the Rouge Reward would catch you out. Check the calendar before choosing: a $100 reward that expires unused is worth less than $50.00 in cash you actually spend.

      Picking a cheap item for a Bath and Body Works reward. A reward covers one item up to $18.95, and the unused value does not carry over. Spending a reward on a $9.95 hand soap throws away $9.00 of value. Spending it on a $7.50 travel size throws away $11.45. Pick the most expensive eligible item you will actually use, and if nothing in your basket is near the cap, wait: the reward lasts 90 days, and a better basket will come along.

      Forgetting the expiry clocks. Ulta Member points expire at the end of the quarter one year after they are earned. Sephora points expire after 12 months with no point activity. Bath and Body Works Rewards expire 90 days after issue, and the points behind them expire after 12 months with no purchase. Points you lose are worth $0.00, whatever the earn rate was. Set a reminder when a reward is issued, and redeem Ulta points before the Member expiry if you are not going to reach Platinum.

      Assuming the tier rate applies to the whole year. You earn Platinum only after crossing $500 of spend, so the first $500 of the year earns at the Member rate and only the rest earns at 1.25. The calculator applies your selected tier to the full year and flags the simplification, but your first year at a new tier will come in slightly below the figure shown. From the second year on, with the tier already held, the full-year rate is right.

      Chasing a tier with spending you would not otherwise do. Diamond needs $1,200 a year at Ulta. If your natural spend is $600, the extra $600 buys 900 more points at the Diamond rate, worth $33.00 redeemed on their own as 750 plus 100, plus free shipping and a $25 service credit. That is a poor return on $600 of spending you did not want. Tiers are worth having when your natural spending reaches them; they are not worth buying your way into. The same applies to Rouge at Sephora, where the main cash benefit is the Rouge Reward, worth an extra $50.00 per 2,500 points over cash, and to VIB, where the cash benefit is nothing at all, since every tier earns the same rate.

      Treating the Bazaar as free money. Sephora Bazaar rewards cost points, and the points have a cash value: 750 points spent on a sample set are $10.00 of Beauty Insider Cash given up (plus 250 points left over). If the sample set is worth more than $10.00 to you, take it. If it is a product you would never buy, the $10.00 was the better deal. The same test applies to every non-cash redemption in every program: compare it with the cash option, not with zero.

      Frequently asked questions

      How much are my Ulta points worth?

      It depends on how many you hold and how you redeem them, because Ulta points get more valuable in larger blocks: 100 points are worth $3.00, 250 are worth $8.00, 500 are worth $17.50, 750 are worth $30.00, 1,000 are worth $50.00, and 2,000 are worth $125.00. Points redeem in any combination of those increments, so 1,250 points are worth $58.00 (1,000 plus 250) and 3,400 points are worth $187.00 (2,000 plus 1,000 plus four 100-point redemptions). Enter your balance above and the calculator finds the combination worth the most.

      How much are my Sephora points worth?

      In cash terms, 500 points are worth $10.00 of Beauty Insider Cash, which is 2 cents a point, for every member. Rouge members can also trade 1,000 points for $20 of Rouge Cash, the same 2 cents a point in one redemption instead of two, and 2,500 points for a $100 Rouge Reward, which is 4 cents a point, so 2,500 points are worth $100.00 for a Rouge member and $50.00 for anyone else. Rewards Bazaar samples and experiences have no published cash value, so the calculator values Sephora points as cash only; if you redeem in the Bazaar, your real return may be higher.

      How much are my Bath and Body Works points worth?

      Every 1,000 points is one free product with a regular price up to $18.95, so the value depends on what you pick: 1,000 points are worth $18.95 if you pick an $18.95 item and $9.95 if you pick a $9.95 item. That works out to 18.95% back on your spending at the cap, the highest return of the three programs. Rewards expire 90 days after they are issued, so use them before they lapse.

      Which beauty rewards program pays back the most?

      Bath and Body Works, at every spend level. It returns 18.95% of your spending as free products, against a best case of 9.38% at Ulta (Diamond status, points saved to 2,000) and 4.00% at Sephora (Rouge status, points saved to a 2,500-point Rouge Reward). At $600 of spending a year, the three programs pay $113.70, $30.00, and $10.00. The catch is the shelf: Bath and Body Works only sells body care, hand soap, and home fragrance, so most shoppers need Ulta or Sephora for the rest of their beauty spending.

      Should I save my Ulta points or spend them as I go?

      Save them, unless you are a regular Member facing the expiry clock. Points redeemed 100 at a time are worth 3 cents each, while points redeemed 2,000 at a time are worth 6.25 cents each, so saving 2,000 points more than doubles their value: $125.00 in one redemption against $60.00 as twenty small ones. Aim for at least 1,000 points ($50.00) and for 2,000 when you can. Regular Members lose points at the end of the quarter one year after they are earned, so a Member should redeem before the clock runs out; Platinum and Diamond points never expire while the tier is kept.

      What is the best way to redeem Sephora points?

      For Rouge members, save to 2,500 points and take the $100 Rouge Reward, which is twice the value per point of Beauty Insider Cash. For the points left over after a Rouge Reward, take $20 Rouge Cash at 1,000 points rather than two $10 cash redemptions: the value is the same, but it takes half as many purchases, since cash can be redeemed only once per transaction. For everyone else, take Beauty Insider Cash at 500 points for $10 off, remembering it can be redeemed only once per transaction. Rewards Bazaar samples can beat cash if you would buy the product anyway: compare the sample with the $10.00 of cash the same points would buy, and take whichever is worth more to you.

      Do beauty rewards points expire?

      Yes, all three programs have expiry rules. Ulta points expire for regular Members at the end of the quarter one year after they are earned; Platinum and Diamond points never expire while the tier is kept. Sephora points expire after 12 months with no point activity, through a purchase, a redemption, or a Birthday Gift. Bath and Body Works points expire after 12 months with no purchase, and the free-product Rewards expire 90 days after they are issued. The calculator warns you about each clock when you hold points in that program.

      How much do I need to spend to reach Platinum at Ulta or Rouge at Sephora?

      Ulta Platinum needs $500 of qualifying spend in a calendar year, and Diamond needs $1,200. Sephora VIB needs $350 in a calendar year, and Rouge needs $1,000. Some comparisons quote $350 for Ulta Platinum, but Ulta's own rewards page puts the threshold at $500, and the retailer's own page governs. At Ulta the tier also raises your earn rate, from 1 to 1.25 to 1.5 points per $1; at Sephora every tier earns 1 point per $1, and the tier buys better sale discounts, gifts, and, for Rouge, the $100 Rouge Reward.

      Sources

      • Ulta Beauty, "Ulta Beauty Rewards: Points for Dollars Off and Perks", ulta.com/rewards/all. Tier table (Member free, Platinum $500 a year, Diamond $1,200 a year; 1, 1.25, and 1.5 points per $1); redemption table (100 points $3.00, 250 $8.00, 500 $17.50, 750 $30.00, 1,000 $50.00, 2,000 $125.00); redemption in eligible increments or combinations; 4,000-point online and 10,000-point in-store caps per purchase; Member points expire at the end of the quarter one year after earning, Platinum and Diamond points never expire while status is maintained. Ulta Beauty Rewards. Checked 20 November 2026.
      • Sephora, "About Beauty Insider Loyalty Program", sephora.com/beauty/loyalty-program. 1 point per $1 for Insiders, VIB, and Rouge; VIB at $350 a year, Rouge at $1,000 a year; Beauty Insider Cash 500 points for $10 off, once per transaction, purchase of $10 or more; Rouge Reward 2,500 points for $100, expiring 90 days after the confirmation email; Rewards Bazaar from 50 to 100,000 points; three 100-point rewards for 250 points online; points expire after 12 months with no point activity. Sephora Beauty Insider Loyalty Program. Checked 20 November 2026.
      • Sephora, "Beauty Insider Terms and Conditions", sephora.com/beauty/terms-conditions-beauty-insider, last updated 28 August 2025. Beauty Insider Cash in two amounts: the Standard Cash Reward, 500 points for $10 off, available to all members, and the Rouge Cash Reward, 1,000 points for $20 off, available to Rouge members only; only one Beauty Insider Cash Reward can be applied per transaction; the Rouge Cash Reward cannot be redeemed at Sephora at Kohl's or on Kohls.com. Sephora Beauty Insider Terms and Conditions. Checked 20 November 2026.
      • Bath and Body Works, "My Bath and Body Works Rewards Program: Frequently Asked Questions", customercare.bathandbodyworks.com. Free program; credit toward the next Reward for every $1.00 of eligible purchase after discounts, excluding shipping, taxes, gift cards, and gift wrap; each Reward is one item applied to the most expensive eligible product in the transaction, up to eight Rewards per transaction; Rewards valid 90 days from issue; accrued spend expires 12 months after earning or after 12 months of inactivity; reward value varies by market. My Bath and Body Works Rewards FAQ. Checked 20 November 2026.
      • Bath and Body Works reward value $18.95 and 10 points per $1: confirmed by every current independent guide checked in November 2026, including Coupons.com, Groupon, DealHack (checked against Bath and Body Works' own pages in November 2026), Rivo, and The Krazy Coupon Lady, which records the rise from $16.95 to $18.95 in May 2025. Older guides quoting $16.95 or $16.50 predate that rise. The calculator lets the user enter the free item value up to $18.95 because Bath and Body Works says the value varies by market.
      • Ulta Platinum threshold conflict: USA Today (2026 comparison) quotes $350; Ulta's own rewards page and two other sources quote $500. Resolved in favor of Ulta's own page, which governs: Platinum is $500 a year. The $350 figure matches Sephora's VIB threshold and appears to be a confusion between the two programs.

      Figures in this article were verified against the sources above on 20 November 2026. The "best return on spend" figures are computed from the published earn rates and redemption tables: Ulta Diamond 1.5 points per $1 at 6.25 cents a point is 9.38% back; Ulta Platinum 1.25 points per $1 at 6.25 cents is 7.81%; Sephora Rouge 1 point per $1 at 4 cents a point is 4.00%; Bath and Body Works 10 points per $1 with 1,000 points worth $18.95 is 18.95% back. Program terms change; check the retailer's own page before relying on a figure.