Companion Planting Planner
Your companion planting plan
Good neighbors
Keep apart
Bed layout
How the numbers were worked out
Plan the rest of the bed: our Square-Foot Garden Planner lays out plants by the square foot, our Succession Planting Calculator times repeat sowings, our Seed Rate Calculator works out how much seed to buy, and our Garden Watering Calculator works out how much water the bed needs.
Last reviewed: 20 November 2026. Reviewed every 180 days; next review due 19 May 2027.
How to use the Companion Planting Planner
Companion planting is the practice of placing crops next to each other so that each helps the other, or at least does not harm it. Some pairings work because one plant repels the other's pests. Some work because one plant feeds the other, shades it, holds it up, or simply uses soil the other does not reach. And some pairings are best avoided: plants that share a disease, plants that stunt each other, and one plant, fennel, that seems to dislike almost everything. The trouble for a home gardener is that the charts disagree. One chart says corn is a good neighbor for tomatoes, another says it is a bad one, and a third does not mention the pair at all. This planner fixes that by giving every pairing a reason and a source, and by saying plainly where the sources disagree instead of picking a side in silence.
The planner covers 25 crops: tomatoes, peppers, eggplant, potatoes, cucumbers, squash, corn, bush beans, pole beans, peas, carrots, beets, radishes, lettuce, spinach, the cabbage family (broccoli, cabbage, kale, and cauliflower), onions, garlic, basil, dill, rosemary, marigolds, nasturtiums, strawberries, and fennel. For each crop it lists the good neighbors, the crops to keep apart, the reason for each pairing, and the source it came from. It also builds bed-layout suggestions from the crop's growth habit and, if you give it a bed size, works out how many plants fit at UGA Extension spacing.
To get your result, follow these steps:
- Pick your crop. Choose the crop you are planning from the list. The planner looks it up in a table of 101 pairings drawn from Cornell Cooperative Extension, UGA Extension, Rodale, and Washington State University Extension, with University of Minnesota Extension as a cross-check.
- Check a second crop, if you have one in mind. The pair check is optional. Pick any other crop and the planner gives a verdict: good neighbor, bad neighbor, sources disagree, same family (caution), or no pairing recorded. Use it when you already know what is going in the bed and want to know whether two specific crops get along.
- Filter by benefit, if you want. The focus filter narrows the good-neighbor list to one kind of benefit: pest control, nutrients, shade, space, or support. The bad-neighbor list is always shown in full, because a filter should never hide a crop you need to keep apart. For example, tomatoes have four pest-control companions (basil, marigolds, onions, and garlic) and no nutrient companions at all, so filtering tomatoes to nutrients returns an empty list and the planner says so plainly.
- Enter your bed size, if you want a plant count. Give the bed length and width in feet and the planner works out the bed area, how many rows fit across the width, how many plants fit in each row, and the total plant count at UGA Extension spacing. Both dimensions are needed: enter both or leave both blank. If the bed is too small for even one row or one plant, the planner says so and tells you how much bigger the bed needs to be. For eight crops (garlic, basil, dill, rosemary, marigolds, nasturtiums, strawberries, and fennel) UGA Circular 963 gives no row spacing, so no plant count is worked out and the planner tells you to follow the seed packet instead.
- Read the layout steps. Below the neighbor lists, the planner builds layout suggestions for the bed: where the crop sits (tall crops north, low crops south, sprawling crops at the edge), whether flowers should be tucked between the rows, whether a trap crop is worth planting, and the rotation rule for next year. If you entered a bed size, the layout repeats the plant count in plain words.
Three example buttons sit under the form. The first plans tomatoes in a 4 ft by 8 ft bed. The second plans corn with pole beans to check, the Three Sisters pairing. The third plans carrots with an onion check and a pest focus, in a 4 ft by 4 ft bed. Click one to see a full result at once, then change any field to plan your own bed. If you are laying out the whole bed rather than one crop, our Square Foot Garden Planner works out grid spacing for a full bed, and our Succession Planting Calculator tells you when each sowing goes in the ground.
How the planner works
The planner is a lookup over a pairing table, not a guess. Every pairing in the table is an undirected edge between two crops: if basil is a good neighbor for tomatoes, then tomatoes are a good neighbor for basil, and the pair check gives the same verdict from either side. The table holds 83 good pairings and 18 bad pairings, plus one generated rule for fennel. Each pairing carries four things: whether it is good or bad, why (the mechanism, in one sentence naming both crops), the type of benefit or harm (pest control, nutrients, shade, space, support, shared disease, allelopathy, or cross-pollination), and the source. Seven pairings are marked studied, meaning a university extension source cites research behind them. The other 94 are marked traditional, meaning they come from extension and Rodale charts with a plausible mechanism but no direct trial behind them. The planner shows the mark on every pairing, so you can tell at a glance which claims rest on studies and which rest on chart tradition.
Fennel is handled by a rule, not by 24 separate table entries. Cornell Cooperative Extension says of fennel: "Plant away from gardens. Most plants dislike it." The planner therefore lists fennel as a bad neighbor for all 24 other crops, with the shared reason that fennel releases chemicals that inhibit most vegetables. Fennel is the only crop with no good neighbors at all, and the planner says so in the headline rather than hiding it.
Five pairings carry a conflict note, because the sources disagree about them. Tomato with corn and tomato with dill are listed as bad pairings, with the disagreement noted alongside. Potato with marigold and the cabbage family with beans have no pairing entry at all, because the evidence points in opposite directions and the honest answer is to say so. The pair check reports these as "Sources disagree." The full list of conflicts and the source that governs each one is in the section on disagreements below.
The bed math uses spacing from UGA Extension Circular 963, Vegetable Gardening in Georgia. Rows run along the length of the bed, so the width decides how many rows fit and the length decides how many plants fit in each row. Both counts are rounded down, because a fraction of a plant is not a plant. Where UGA gives a spacing range, the planner uses the close end, which suits home beds planted in rows. The table below lists the spacing the planner uses for each crop.
| Crop | Between rows | Between plants |
|---|---|---|
| Tomatoes | 48 in | 24 in |
| Peppers | 36 in | 24 in |
| Eggplant | 36 in | 24 in |
| Potatoes | 36 in | 12 in |
| Cucumbers | 60 in | 12 in |
| Squash (summer) | 36 in | 24 in |
| Corn | 36 in | 12 in |
| Bush beans | 36 in | 2 in |
| Pole beans | 36 in | 4 in |
| Peas | 36 in | 2 in |
| Carrots | 18 in | 2 in |
| Beets | 18 in | 2 in |
| Radishes | 24 in | 1 in |
| Lettuce | 18 in | 8 in |
| Spinach | 18 in | 2 in |
| Cabbage family | 36 in | 12 in |
| Onions | 18 in | 3 in |
Winter squash needs wider spacing than the summer figure in the table: UGA gives 60 in between rows and 36 in between plants for winter squash. The planner uses the summer figure, so if you are growing winter squash, treat the plant count as a maximum and give the vines more room.
Three worked examples show the arithmetic. First, tomatoes in a bed 8 ft long and 4 ft wide. The bed area is 8 ft x 4 ft = 32 sq ft. Rows across the 4 ft width: 48 in / 48 in = 1, rounded down to 1 row. Plants per row: 96 in / 24 in = 4. Total: 1 x 4 = 4 tomato plants. Second, carrots in a bed 4 ft by 4 ft. The bed area is 16 sq ft. Rows across the width: 48 in / 18 in = 2.67, rounded down to 2 rows. Plants per row: 48 in / 2 in = 24. Total: 2 x 24 = 48 carrot plants. Third, corn in a bed 8 ft wide and 4 ft long. The bed area is 32 sq ft. Rows across the 8 ft width: 96 in / 36 in = 2.67, rounded down to 2 rows. Plants per row along the 4 ft length: 48 in / 12 in = 4. Total: 2 x 4 = 8 corn plants. The planner shows this working for every bed you enter, so you can check the arithmetic yourself.
What companion planting can and cannot do
Companion planting has a reputation problem, and it is partly deserved. Washington State University Extension, in its Home Garden Series publication on gardening with companion plants, warns that most popular companion planting charts have no scientific basis. The charts were built by copying each other for decades, and many of their claims have never been tested. That does not mean companion planting is worthless. It means the honest way to use it is to know which claims have evidence behind them and which are tradition, and to treat the two differently. That is why this planner marks every pairing studied or traditional and names the source.
Seven pairings in the planner rest on research cited by a university extension source. Basil and marigolds both reduced thrip populations on tomatoes in field and greenhouse studies, and basil may promote tomato growth. Nasturtiums reduced squash bug populations in research trials, and an Iowa study found nasturtium and marigolds both reduced squash bug and cucumber beetle damage on squash. In brassicas, onions, nasturtiums, and marigolds helped reduce cabbage looper and imported cabbageworm damage in broccoli and cabbage trials, with an Iowa study behind the onion and nasturtium findings. These are real results, but they are narrow: they show that a particular plant reduced a particular pest on a particular crop in a trial. They do not prove that the pairing works in every garden, in every climate, at every planting density.
Some popular claims fail when they are tested. Aromatic herbs are often said to repel pests by smell, but Washington State University Extension reports that field research found aromatic plants ineffective as pest repellents: the volatile chemicals that carry the scent dissipate outdoors before they can protect a neighboring crop. French marigolds, the workhorse of companion planting charts, discourage beneficial insects as well as pests, so a marigold border can cost you the predators that would have eaten your aphids. And the famous claim that basil improves the flavor of tomatoes is folklore. The University of Minnesota Extension notes that basil may promote tomato growth, but no study shows it changes the taste. The planner lists basil as a tomato companion on the thrips evidence, not on the flavor story.
Nitrogen is another claim that needs a timing correction. Legumes (beans and peas) do fix nitrogen, but Washington State University Extension points out that most of the fixed nitrogen reaches the next crop only after the legume dies and decomposes. A bean plant growing next to a corn plant this summer is not feeding that corn much nitrogen this summer. The benefit is real but mostly deferred, which is one more reason to rotate legumes through a bed rather than relying on them as a live fertilizer. The planner still lists legume pairings as nutrient benefits, because the fixed nitrogen does enter the soil and because the pairing has other benefits (beans climb corn, for example), but the honest version of the claim is about the season after, not this one.
Two mechanisms do have good support. The first is the disruptive-crop idea: a bed with different crops mixed together confuses pests more than a bed of one crop, because pests find their host by sight and smell and a mixed planting breaks up the signal. Washington State University Extension notes that intercropped rows beat perimeter plantings: flowers tucked between the rows help more than flowers planted only around the edge. The planner's layout steps follow this directly, telling you to tuck marigolds and nasturtiums between the rows rather than only around the edge. The second is root stratification: crops with different root depths share a bed without competing hard. Taprooted carrots and radishes use deep soil that shallow-rooted corn, onions, and lettuces do not reach. Many of the planner's space pairings rest on this: carrots with lettuce, radishes with peas, beets with cabbage family crops.
Finally, some pairings work by shade and timing rather than by chemistry. Lettuce and spinach grow in the light shade under tomatoes, peppers, and corn, and finish before the tall crop's canopy closes. Radishes mark a slow carrot row and are harvested before the carrots need the space. These are not mysterious effects. They are scheduling and geometry, and they are the most reliable part of companion planting, because they do not depend on a pest behaving a certain way. When you plan a bed, start with the geometry (tall north, low south, fast crops between slow ones) and treat the pest claims as a bonus, not a guarantee.
The pairings that matter most
Tomatoes. Tomatoes have eight good neighbors in the planner: basil, marigolds, carrots, onions, lettuce, garlic, spinach, and peppers. The two studied pairings are basil and marigolds, both against thrips. The shade pairings (lettuce and spinach under the tomato canopy) are the most reliable in practice, because they depend on geometry rather than on pest behavior. Tomatoes have six crops to keep apart: potatoes, corn, cabbage family crops, dill, strawberries, and fennel. Potatoes share late blight and other nightshade diseases with tomatoes, so blight spreads fast when the two grow together. Strawberries share verticillium wilt with tomatoes. Corn is the conflict case, covered below. Dill can stunt tomatoes once it flowers.
Beans and onions. The clearest bad pairing in the whole table is beans with alliums. Onions stunt bean growth, and garlic does the same. The rule covers bush beans, pole beans, and peas against both onions and garlic: six bad pairings from one mechanism. It is also one of the most often broken rules in home gardens, because beans and onions are both staple crops and the harm is not obvious until the beans underperform. If your beans have ever looked stunted for no clear reason, check what was growing next to them.
The cabbage family. Broccoli, cabbage, kale, and cauliflower are treated as one crop in the planner, because they share pests, diseases, and companions. They have ten good neighbors, more than any crop except bush beans, and three of them are studied: onions, nasturtiums, and marigolds all helped reduce cabbage looper and imported cabbageworm damage in trials. Rosemary deters cabbage moth, dill is a traditional companion, and garlic deters cabbage pests. The cabbage family has four crops to keep apart: tomatoes, peppers, strawberries, and fennel. Strawberries are the disease risk: cabbage family crops can carry verticillium wilt, which attacks strawberries. The beans question is a genuine conflict, covered below.
The Three Sisters. Corn, pole beans, and squash grown together is the oldest companion planting system in North America, and the planner treats it as a layout rather than just three pairings. Corn gives the beans a stalk to climb and the squash light shade. The beans fix nitrogen. The squash vines carpet the soil as a living mulch that keeps the soil cool and moist. The planting order matters: plant the corn first, add pole beans once the corn is 6 to 12 inches tall, and add squash about a week after the beans. That order comes from Ask Extension, and UGA Extension publishes a Three Sisters garden guide. Washington State University Extension adds a caution: there is no compelling published evidence that the Three Sisters system increases total productivity or improves the soil, and in polyculture trials the bean and squash yields were reduced even though the land-equivalent ratio was higher. The system is worth growing for its structure and its history, but it is not a free lunch.
Marigolds. Marigolds are the most recommended flower in companion planting, and the evidence is mixed. They are studied companions for tomatoes (thrips), squash (squash bugs and cucumber beetles, in the Iowa study), and cabbage (cabbage looper and imported cabbageworm). They discourage nematodes around peppers and eggplant, and they discourage Mexican bean beetles. But they are not a cure-all. Multiple studies found marigolds do not deter Colorado potato beetle, which is why the planner does not list marigolds as a potato companion even though many charts do. And French marigolds discourage beneficial insects as well as pests. Use marigolds between the rows of tomatoes, squash, and cabbage, where the evidence is strongest, and do not expect them to protect potatoes.
Fennel. Fennel is the exception that proves the rule. Cornell Cooperative Extension says to plant it away from gardens, because most plants dislike it. The planner lists it as a bad neighbor for all 24 other crops and gives it its own warning and its own layout step: give fennel its own bed or a pot and keep it away from the vegetable beds. Fennel is also in the carrot family, so it shares pests with carrots and dill, which is one more reason to keep it separate. If you want fennel in the garden, grow it in a pot at the edge, where its chemicals cannot reach the beds.
Where the sources disagree
Five pairings in the planner carry a conflict note, because honest sources point in opposite directions. The planner shows the disagreement rather than hiding it, and in each case the note says which source governs and why.
Tomato with corn. Some charts list corn as a good tomato neighbor, for shade and wind protection. The shared-pest reason governs here: corn earworm and tomato fruitworm are the same insect, so corn next to tomatoes feeds the pest that eats both. The planner lists corn as a bad neighbor for tomatoes and notes the disagreement. If your garden has no history of earworm or fruitworm, the shade benefit may be worth more to you than the pest risk, but that is a judgment call, and the planner gives you the facts to make it.
Tomato with dill. Charts disagree on dill with tomatoes. Some allow young dill and warn only once it flowers, while others list dill as a tomato antagonist outright. The planner lists dill as a bad neighbor for tomatoes and notes the disagreement. If you want both in the garden, keep the dill in a pot and harvest it before it flowers, or plant it at the far end of the bed.
Potato with marigold. Marigolds are often recommended against Colorado potato beetle, but multiple studies found no benefit, as reported by University of Minnesota Extension. The studies govern: marigolds are not listed as a potato companion in this planner. This is the clearest case in the table of a popular chart claim failing in trials, and it is why the planner marks evidence on every pairing. If a chart tells you marigolds protect potatoes, it is repeating a claim the studies do not support.
Cabbage family with beans. Charts disagree on beans with the cabbage family. Some list beans as good neighbors, but UGA Extension (Newton County) lists beans as incompatible with broccoli. The planner leaves beans out of the cabbage list entirely rather than picking a side, and the pair check reports the pair as "Sources disagree." The same applies to both bush beans and pole beans. If you have grown beans and cabbage together without trouble, your experience is valid data, and the planner's honest answer is that the sources do not agree.
Basil and tomato flavor. This is not a pairing conflict but a claim conflict, and it is worth naming. The popular story is that basil improves the flavor of tomatoes grown next to it. No study supports that. What the studies support is that basil reduces thrips on tomatoes and may promote tomato growth. The planner lists the pairing on the evidence, not on the story, and says so here so the flavor claim is not repeated as fact.
Bed layout: putting the plan on the ground
A list of good neighbors is not a bed plan until the plants are placed. The planner's layout steps follow four rules, and each one comes from an extension source.
Height first. Tall crops go on the north side of the bed so they do not shade lower crops. UGA Extension Circular 963 gives the same rule: plant tall-growing plants together on the north or west side. Medium crops take the middle. Low crops go on the south side, clear of tall crops to the north, so they get full sun. Sprawling crops (cucumbers and squash) go at the edge of the bed with room to sprawl outward, or on a trellis to save space. The planner builds the height step from the crop's growth habit: tomatoes, corn, pole beans, and fennel are tall; peppers, eggplant, peas, and dill are medium; potatoes, bush beans, carrots, beets, radishes, lettuce, spinach, cabbage family crops, onions, garlic, basil, rosemary, marigolds, nasturtiums, and strawberries are low; cucumbers and squash sprawl.
Flowers between the rows, not just around the edge. If marigolds or nasturtiums are in the crop's good-neighbor list, the planner tells you to tuck them between the rows rather than only around the edge. Intercropped rows confuse pests better than a perimeter planting, because the pest meets the confusing plant at every row instead of only at the border. This follows the disruptive-crop finding reported by Washington State University Extension and the interplanting advice from University of Minnesota Extension.
Trap crops need watching. Nasturtiums draw aphids, squash bugs, and other pests away from the crop, which is why they are listed as companions for cucumbers, squash, and cabbage family crops. But a trap crop only works if you check it often and pull plants that fill up with pests. A nasturtium left to fill with aphids becomes a breeding ground next to the crop it was meant to protect. The planner adds a trap-crop step whenever nasturtiums are in the good-neighbor list for squash, cucumbers, or cabbage.
Rotate next year. Companion planting does not replace crop rotation. The planner ends every layout with the same rule: next year, do not plant another crop from the same family in the same bed. Plant families matter because pests and diseases are usually family-specific. Late blight hits the nightshade family (tomatoes, peppers, eggplant, potatoes). Clubroot hits the cabbage family. The planner shows the plant family on every result and warns in the pair check when two crops share a family, even if no direct pairing is recorded. Rotation is the single most effective thing a home gardener can do against soil-borne disease, and no companion pairing substitutes for it.
Use cases
Planning your first raised bed. Start with the crop you most want to grow, usually tomatoes, and let the planner build the bed around it. Tomatoes with basil, marigolds, lettuce, and spinach fill a 4 ft by 8 ft bed with four tomato plants and a fast lettuce and spinach understory that finishes before the tomato canopy closes. Keep potatoes, corn, and strawberries out of that bed. Our Square Foot Garden Planner works out the grid for the whole bed once you know which crops go in it.
A small space with a pest problem. If aphids or squash bugs have beaten you before, filter by pest control and build the bed from the studied pairings: nasturtiums with squash and cucumbers, marigolds with tomatoes, onions with carrots against carrot fly. Tuck the flowers between the rows, not around the edge, and check trap crops weekly. Companion planting will not eliminate pests, but the studied pairings reduce pest pressure enough to matter, and they cost nothing but seed.
A school or community garden. The Three Sisters bed is the classic teaching bed: corn first, pole beans at 6 to 12 inches, squash a week later. It shows children how three plants share a bed, and it produces a real harvest. The planner's layout step gives the order and the spacing, and the pair check settles arguments about what else can go in the bed. Keep fennel out entirely, and keep a pot of it at the edge if anyone wants to grow it.
Planning the season, not just one bed. Companion planting answers where crops go, not when. Pair the planner with our Succession Planting Calculator for sowing dates and repeat sowings through the season, and our Seed Rate Calculator for how much seed to buy. A bed that is well planned in space and badly planned in time still fails: lettuce planted in July bolts whatever its neighbors are.
Fixing a bed that underperformed. If a crop did badly last year, run it through the planner with the crops that were actually next to it. Beans next to onions, tomatoes next to potatoes, and cabbage next to strawberries are the three most common hidden causes of a poor bed, and all three are easy to miss because the harm is gradual rather than dramatic. The pair check is the fastest way to test a suspicion: two crops in, one verdict out.
Sources
The planner's pairing table was built from four named sources, verified from the publishers' own pages on 20 November 2026, with a fifth source used as a cross-check.
- Cornell Cooperative Extension — "Companion Planting with Herbs" (Schenectady County, compiled by Virginia McCarthy, Master Gardener). Pest-by-pest herb list and the fennel rule ("Plant away from gardens. Most plants dislike it."). The document itself says its listing is based on scientific evidence as well as folklore.
- UGA Extension — Circular 963, "Vegetable Gardening in Georgia" (June 2009), for the spacing table and the tall-plants-north rule; the Newton County Extension blog broccoli companion list, for the beans and cabbage conflict; and the UGA Extension Three Sisters garden guide, for the Three Sisters planting order.
- Rodale — Rodale's Successful Organic Gardening: Companion Planting (McClure and Roth, Rodale Press, 1994) and Rodale's Ultimate Encyclopedia of Organic Gardening, as compiled in the ATTRA technical note Companion Planting: Basic Concepts and Resources (Kuepper and Dodson, 2001). Rodale is a print source; the traditional-chart pairings in the planner are attributed to it.
- Washington State University Extension — "Gardening with Companion Plants" (Home Garden Series). The evidence warning behind this planner's studied and traditional marks, the aromatic-repellent finding, the nitrogen timing correction, the disruptive-crop finding, and the Three Sisters caution.
- University of Minnesota Extension (cross-check) — "Companion planting in home gardens." The source of the studied pairings for tomatoes, squash, and brassicas, the marigold and potato finding, and the radish and carrot space pairing.
Spacing figures come from UGA Extension Circular 963. Where UGA gives a range, the planner uses the close end. The Three Sisters planting order (corn first, beans at 6 to 12 inches, squash about a week later) comes from Ask Extension, with UGA Extension's Three Sisters garden guide as the companion source. All sources were re-verified on 20 November 2026. Companion planting tables change slowly, so the next review is 19 May 2027.
Frequently asked questions
What is companion planting?
Companion planting is placing crops next to each other so that each helps the other, or at least does not harm it. A good neighbor may repel the crop's pests, fix nitrogen in the soil, provide shade, hold up a climbing crop, or simply use soil the crop does not reach. A bad neighbor may share a disease, stunt the crop's growth, or release chemicals that inhibit it. The idea is old, but the charts gardeners use were built by copying each other for decades, so they often disagree. This planner gives every pairing a reason and a source, and says plainly where the sources disagree.
Does companion planting actually work?
Some of it does, and some of it does not. Washington State University Extension warns that most popular companion planting charts have no scientific basis, and field research has found some famous claims wanting: aromatic herbs do not repel pests outdoors, because the scent chemicals dissipate, and marigolds do not deter Colorado potato beetle. But a smaller set of pairings does have research behind it: basil and marigolds reduced thrips on tomatoes, nasturtiums reduced squash bugs, and onions, nasturtiums, and marigolds reduced cabbage caterpillar damage in trials. The most reliable benefits are not chemical at all: shade, timing, and root depth. Lettuce under tomatoes and radishes between carrot rows work by geometry, and geometry never fails a field trial. This planner marks every pairing studied or traditional so you can tell the two apart.
What should I plant next to tomatoes?
Tomatoes have eight good neighbors in this planner: basil, marigolds, carrots, onions, lettuce, garlic, spinach, and peppers. Basil and marigolds are the two with research behind them, both against thrips. Lettuce and spinach grow in the light shade under the tomato canopy and finish before it closes. Keep potatoes, corn, cabbage family crops, dill, strawberries, and fennel away from tomatoes. Potatoes share late blight with tomatoes, strawberries share verticillium wilt, corn shares the earworm and fruitworm pest, and dill can stunt tomatoes once it flowers.
What should never be planted next to beans?
Onions and garlic. Alliums stunt bean growth, and the rule covers bush beans, pole beans, and peas against both onions and garlic. It is one of the clearest bad pairings in companion planting and one of the most often broken, because the harm is gradual: the beans simply underperform and the gardener blames the soil or the weather. Keep alliums in a different bed from your beans and peas. Pole beans also stunt beets, so keep pole beans away from the beet row as well.
What is the Three Sisters method?
The Three Sisters is corn, pole beans, and squash grown together, the oldest companion planting system in North America. Corn gives the beans a stalk to climb and the squash light shade. The beans fix nitrogen. The squash vines carpet the soil as a living mulch that keeps the soil cool and moist. Plant in order: corn first, pole beans once the corn is 6 to 12 inches tall, and squash about a week after the beans. That order comes from Ask Extension, and UGA Extension publishes a Three Sisters garden guide. One caution from Washington State University Extension: there is no compelling published evidence that the system increases total productivity, and in polyculture trials the bean and squash yields were reduced. Grow it for its structure and its history, not as a guaranteed bigger harvest.
Do marigolds really keep pests away?
Sometimes, for some pests, on some crops. Marigolds reduced thrips on tomatoes and reduced squash bug and cucumber beetle damage on squash in an Iowa study, and they helped reduce cabbage looper and imported cabbageworm damage in cabbage trials. They also discourage nematodes and Mexican bean beetles. But multiple studies found marigolds do not deter Colorado potato beetle, so they are not a potato companion even though many charts say they are. French marigolds also discourage beneficial insects as well as pests. Use marigolds between the rows of tomatoes, squash, and cabbage, where the evidence is strongest, and do not expect them to protect everything.
Why do companion planting charts disagree with each other?
Because most charts were built by copying earlier charts, not by testing pairings, so an error or a local observation can be repeated for decades until it looks like a fact. Different climates, soils, and pest pressures also change which pairings matter: a pairing that helps in Georgia may not help in Minnesota. This planner handles disagreement by showing it. Five pairings carry a conflict note naming the disagreement and the source that governs: tomato with corn, tomato with dill, potato with marigold, and the cabbage family with bush beans and pole beans. Where studies exist, the studies govern. Where they do not, the planner leaves the pairing out rather than picking a side.
How far apart should companion plants be?
Close enough to interact, which in practice means in the same bed and usually in the next row. Cornell Cooperative Extension notes that repellent plants protect nearby crops up to about 3 feet away, so a marigold three rows over is doing nothing for your tomatoes. Intercropped rows beat perimeter plantings: flowers tucked between the rows confuse pests better than flowers planted only around the edge. For spacing within a row, follow the crop's own spacing from the table in this guide (for example, tomatoes 48 inches between rows and 24 inches between plants), and use the planner's bed math to work out how many plants fit. The companion goes in the next row at its own spacing, not squeezed into the same row.