Luxury Consignment Payout Calculator
Verified Last reviewed: 20 November 2026. Page history
Best payout
Selling somewhere else too? Our Sneaker Resale Fee Comparison Calculator runs one sale through StockX, GOAT and eBay, our Niche Marketplace Seller Fee Comparison Calculator covers Reverb, Discogs, TCGplayer, Grailed and BrickLink, our Profit Margin Calculator works out your margin after every cost, and our Sales Tax Calculator works out the tax on a sale.
Free to use — no sign-up, no paywall. Spotted a mistake? Tell us — we fix reported errors within 24 hours.
Your inputs stay in your browser: every calculation runs on your device, and nothing you type is sent to our servers.
Last reviewed: 20 November 2026. Reviewed quarterly; next review due 20 February 2027.
How to use the Luxury Consignment Payout Comparison Calculator
A designer handbag that sells for $2,000 pays you $1,400 on The RealReal, $1,600 on Vestiaire Collective, $1,400 on Fashionphile consignment, and $1,500 on Rebag at a 25% commission. The same bag, the same buyer price, a $200 gap between the best and worst payout. At $20,000 the gap grows to $1,900, and at $50,000 it reaches $8,500. The platform you pick is worth real money, and the answer changes with the item type, the price, and your seller tier, which is why this calculator runs one sale through all four platforms side by side instead of quoting a single rate.
The four platforms charge in four different shapes. The RealReal pays you a percentage of the sale price that climbs with the price and depends on the category, from 20% on a cheap clothing item to 85% on an expensive watch, with a loyalty bonus on top for frequent sellers. Vestiaire Collective charges a selling fee plus a processing fee, with flat fees at the low and high ends, so it is cheap for very expensive items and expensive for cheap ones. Fashionphile takes 30% of the first $3,000 and 15% of everything above it, so its effective fee falls as the price rises. Rebag quotes a commission for each item individually, so the calculator asks you for the rate on your quote instead of pretending a fixed table exists. Enter your item and your numbers, and the calculator shows every payout, ranks the platforms, and prints the working so you can check each figure by hand.
To get your result, follow these steps:
- Choose the item type. Handbag, clothing, shoes and accessories, branded fine jewelry, watch, or men's sneakers and collectibles. These are The RealReal's own five categories, and the choice matters because The RealReal pays a different share for each one. A $500 watch earns 70% on The RealReal while a $500 handbag earns 60%, a $50 difference on the same sale price. The other three platforms charge the same schedule whatever the item, so the item type changes only The RealReal's line. If your item is clothing or sneakers, read the warning the calculator shows: Fashionphile and Rebag focus on handbags, jewelry and watches, so check that they accept your item before you ship it.
- Enter the sale price. This is the net selling price, what the buyer actually pays after any discount, not the original list price. The RealReal sets its own prices and markdowns, and Fashionphile discounts items that stay unsold after 25 days, so the number that matters is the price the item really sells for. Enter it in US dollars, from $18 to $1,000,000. The $18 floor is Vestiaire Collective's minimum listing price: it does not list items below $18, so a comparison below that price would have one platform missing. You can type a dollar sign and commas, such as $2,000.50, and the calculator strips them.
- Choose your RealReal Rewards tier. Trendsetter (under $1,500 in net sales in your commission year, no bonus), Influencer ($1,500 to $4,999, plus 1 point), Tastemaker ($5,000 to $9,999, plus 2 points), or VIP ($10,000 or more, plus 5 points). The bonus is added to your base rate as extra percentage points, and it applies only to items that sell for $200 or more. A $1,000 handbag pays 65% at Trendsetter and 66% at Influencer, a $10 difference; a $10,000 handbag pays 80% at Trendsetter and 85% at VIP, a $500 difference. The tier changes only The RealReal's line: Vestiaire Collective, Fashionphile and Rebag have no seller tier in this comparison.
- Enter your Rebag commission rate. Rebag does not publish a fixed rate table. Its own help center says commission is quoted per item, as low as 8% for in-demand high-value pieces, with most items falling in the 15% to 25% range. The calculator therefore asks for the rate on your quote, with a 25% default, which sits at the top of the typical range. If you have a Rebag quote in hand, enter its rate and the Rebag line becomes exact. If you do not, the default gives you the conservative end of the typical range, and the calculator warns you that the figure is a default. Enter a rate from 8% to 35%.
The tool updates as you type, so you can try different numbers quickly. Try the example buttons under the form: a $2,000 handbag at Trendsetter, where Vestiaire Collective wins by $200; a $7,500 handbag, where The RealReal and Vestiaire Collective tie at $6,000; a $10,000 watch at VIP with a 15% Rebag rate, where The RealReal wins by $1,000; and a $50 clothing item, where Rebag wins and The RealReal pays just $10. The four examples show the four shapes the answer takes: a clear winner, a tie, a tier-driven win, and a low-price result where the cheapest platform is not the one you would guess.
Read the full result, not just the headline. The headline names the best payout. The cards show the best payout, the gap between the best and worst payout, and the share of the price you keep at the best platform. The table ranks all four platforms best first, with the fee, the share you keep, and the payout on each row, and the best row highlighted. The guidance explains each platform's figure in plain language, the warnings flag the traps that apply to your numbers, the steps print the full working so you can check every figure, and the notes cover tax, markdowns, payout timing, and the limits of the comparison.
How it works
The calculator runs your sale through four fee schedules in order: The RealReal, Vestiaire Collective, Fashionphile, and Rebag. Each schedule is applied to the same net selling price, and each payout is rounded to the cent. The four payouts are then ranked, the best and worst are named, and the gap between them is worked out. Nothing is estimated from a market price and nothing is fetched live: every rate comes from a dated fee schedule, listed in the sources section, and every figure on the page can be recomputed by hand from those schedules.
The RealReal: a percentage that climbs with the price
The RealReal pays you a percentage of the net selling price, and the percentage depends on two things: the category of the item and the price band it sold in. Every category shares one ladder under $300: 20% under $100, 30% from $100 to $149, 45% from $150 to $199, and 55% from $200 to $299. Above $300 the categories split. Clothing, shoes and accessories pay 60% from $300 to $749, 65% from $750 to $4,999, and 70% at $5,000 and above. Handbags pay 60% from $300 to $749, 65% from $750 to $1,499, 70% from $1,500 to $4,999, 75% from $5,000 to $7,499, and 80% at $7,500 and above. Branded fine jewelry pays 65% from $300 to $749 and 70% at $750 and above. Watches pay 60% from $300 to $499, 70% from $500 to $1,999, 75% from $2,000 to $4,999, 80% from $5,000 to $7,499, and 85% at $7,500 and above. Men's sneakers and collectibles pay 65% from $300 to $499, 75% from $500 to $999, and 85% at $1,000 and above.
Two details change the answer. First, the rate applies to the whole sale price, not just the part above each line. A handbag that sells for $1,500 earns 70% of the full $1,500, which is $1,050, not 65% of the first $1,499 and 70% of the last dollar. That is why the payout jumps at each band line: a handbag at $1,499 earns 65%, which is $974.35, while the same bag at $1,500 earns 70%, which is $1,050, a $75.65 jump for one extra dollar of sale price. Second, the Rewards bonus is added to the base rate as extra points, and only on items of $200 or more. A VIP seller with a $10,000 handbag earns 80% plus 5 points, which is 85%, or $8,500. The same VIP seller with a $150 handbag earns the base 45% with no bonus at all, because the item is under $200.
The RealReal's chart is the most complicated of the four, and it is the one that has changed most often. The RealReal has restructured its commission chart more than once under financial pressure, and the figures here are the chart as published in its Earnings Guide and read by three independent sources in October and November 2026. The calculator is reviewed quarterly, and the RealReal chart is the first thing checked at each review.
Vestiaire Collective: 17% plus 3%, with flat fees at both ends
Vestiaire Collective charges two fees on every sale: a selling fee and a payment processing fee. For sellers in the United States listing in US dollars, the selling fee is a flat $12 on items under $75, 17% of the sale price from $75 to $15,000, and a flat $2,500 on items over $15,000. The processing fee is 3% of the sale price with a $3 minimum. Listing is free. The schedule applies to items listed from 15 October 2026 onwards, and it replaced the 12% schedule that ran from 18 July 2025 to 14 October 2026. The history matters, because most guides on the web still quote the old 12% figure, and a few still quote a tiered 25%, 20%, 18%, 15% and 12% structure that does not match any schedule on Vestiaire's own archived pages for US sellers. Both are out of date. The section below on the October 2026 change explains how the conflict was resolved and which schedule governs.
The flat fees make Vestiaire's effective rate bend at both ends. At the bottom, the flat $12 plus $3 is a heavy load on a cheap item: on a $50 sale the fees are $15, which is 30% of the price, and you keep $35. On an $18 sale, the cheapest item Vestiaire will list, the fees are still $15, which is 83.3% of the price, and you keep $3. In the middle band the rate is a flat 20% in all, 17% plus 3%, so you keep 80% of the price: a $2,000 sale pays $1,600, and a $10,000 sale pays $8,000. At the top, the flat $2,500 cap makes Vestiaire cheaper and cheaper as the price rises: on a $20,000 sale the fees are $2,500 plus $600 of processing, which is $3,100, or 15.5% of the price, and you keep $16,900. On a $50,000 sale the fees are $2,500 plus $1,500, which is $4,000, or 8.0% of the price, and you keep $46,000. That cap is why Vestiaire wins the biggest sales in this comparison by a wide margin.
One more detail: the 3% processing fee has a $3 minimum, and the minimum binds on sales under $100. A $75 sale pays a 17% selling fee of $12.75 and a $3.00 processing fee, because 3% of $75 is $2.25, which is under the minimum. The total fee is $15.75, which is 21.0% of the price, not 20%. The calculator applies the minimum exactly, and the steps print the $3.00 minimum processing fee separately so the arithmetic balances on the printed numbers.
Fashionphile: 30% of the first $3,000, 15% of the rest
Fashionphile's consignment fee is marginal, which is the opposite of The RealReal's band system. Fashionphile takes 30% of the sale price up to $3,000, and 15% of the portion above $3,000. A $3,000 sale pays a $900 fee and keeps $2,100. A $5,000 sale pays 30% of the first $3,000, which is $900, plus 15% of the remaining $2,000, which is $300, a total fee of $1,200, and keeps $3,800. A $10,000 sale pays $900 plus 15% of $7,000, which is $1,050, a total fee of $1,950, and keeps $8,050. Because the fee on the top slice is only 15%, the effective fee falls as the price rises: 30.0% at $3,000, 24.0% at $5,000, 19.5% at $10,000, 17.3% at $20,000, and 15.9% at $50,000.
The marginal shape is the most common mistake in comparisons of these platforms. Some guides describe Fashionphile as charging 15% on items over $3,000, which would mean a $5,000 sale pays a $750 fee and keeps $4,250. That is wrong: the 15% applies only to the portion above $3,000, so the fee is $1,200 and the payout is $3,800. The calculator applies the two slices separately and prints both in the steps, so the $900 and the $300 are visible instead of hidden inside one blended number.
Fashionphile also buys items outright, which is a different deal from consignment. With a buyout, Fashionphile makes you an offer, you accept it, you ship, and you are paid once the bag is received and authenticated. There is no commission line because the company's margin is built into the offer, so a buyout cannot be compared by a fee schedule: the only way to judge it is to weigh the offer against the consignment payout this calculator shows. Fashionphile also discounts consigned items that stay unsold after 25 days, which lowers the net selling price the fee is charged on, and it charges an authentication fee of $125 on a Hermes Birkin or Kelly, or $75 on anything else, if you ask for the item back during the initial consignment term.
Rebag: the rate comes from your quote
Rebag is the one platform in this comparison that does not publish a fixed commission table. Its help center says commission rates are based on the item's listing price and category, that you pay less for in-demand high-value pieces, as low as 8%, and more for lower-value items, with most items typically falling in the 15% to 25% range, and that actual rates are communicated individually for each quoted item. Secondary sources disagree about the shape: one quotes 8% to 35%, another quotes a 20% flat figure, and a third publishes a banded table that runs from 32% on cheap bags to 10% on bags over $50,000. None of those is Rebag's own published schedule, because Rebag does not publish one.
The honest design, and the one this calculator uses, is to take the Rebag rate as an input. Enter the rate from your Rebag quote and the Rebag line is exact. Without a quote, the 25% default sits at the top of the typical 15% to 25% range, which is the conservative choice: if Rebag quotes you 18%, your payout will be higher than the calculator shows, not lower. The input accepts rates from 8% to 35%, which covers every figure any source attributes to Rebag. A $2,000 bag at the 25% default pays $1,500; at 15% it pays $1,700; at 8% it pays $1,840. The swing inside Rebag's own range is $340 on one bag, which is why a single fixed Rebag figure would be dishonest.
Rebag also has two features the calculator does not put in the payout, because they are not cash in hand. Payouts left in your Rebag Wallet increase by 1% per month for up to 9 months, a bonus of up to 9%, and the Trade option applies your item's value plus a bonus of roughly 25% over the cash offer toward a Rebag purchase. Both are store credit in effect, not money in your bank account, so the calculator compares cash payouts only and mentions the bonuses here so you can weigh them yourself. Rebag pays consignment payouts about 15 business days after the sale is confirmed.
Worked example 1: a $2,000 handbag at Trendsetter
A handbag sells for $2,000. The seller is a Trendsetter with no loyalty bonus, and the Rebag rate is the 25% default.
- The RealReal: $2,000.00 x 70% = $1,400.00. (Base rate 70% for a handbag at this price.)
- Vestiaire Collective: $2,000.00 - 17% selling fee ($340.00) - 3% processing ($60.00) = $1,600.00.
- Fashionphile: $2,000.00 - 30% consignment fee ($600.00) = $1,400.00.
- Rebag: $2,000.00 - 25% commission ($500.00) = $1,500.00.
- Best payout $1,600.00 (Vestiaire Collective); lowest payout $1,400.00 (The RealReal and Fashionphile tie at the bottom); the gap is $200.00.
Vestiaire Collective wins by $200 because its 20% all-in fee beats The RealReal's 70% share and Fashionphile's flat 30% at this price. The RealReal and Fashionphile tie at $1,400: The RealReal's 70% share and Fashionphile's 30% fee are the same number from opposite sides. Rebag sits in the middle at $1,500, and a Rebag quote of 20% or less would put Rebag at the top.
Worked example 2: a $7,500 handbag at Trendsetter
A handbag sells for $7,500. The seller is a Trendsetter with no loyalty bonus, and the Rebag rate is the 25% default.
- The RealReal: $7,500.00 x 80% = $6,000.00. (Base rate 80% for a handbag at this price.)
- Vestiaire Collective: $7,500.00 - 17% selling fee ($1,275.00) - 3% processing ($225.00) = $6,000.00.
- Fashionphile: $7,500.00 - 30% of the first $3,000 ($900.00) - 15% of the remaining $4,500.00 ($675.00) = $5,925.00.
- Rebag: $7,500.00 - 25% commission ($1,875.00) = $5,625.00.
- Best payout $6,000.00 (The RealReal and Vestiaire Collective tie); lowest payout $5,625.00 (Rebag); the gap is $375.00.
The tie is exact, not a coincidence of rounding: The RealReal's 80% share and Vestiaire Collective's 20% all-in fee are the same split, so the two payouts are identical at every price where The RealReal's handbag rate is 80% and Vestiaire is in its percent band. That runs from $7,500 to $15,000 for handbags. Above $15,000 Vestiaire's flat $2,500 cap breaks the tie in Vestiaire's favor, and below $7,500 The RealReal's lower band rates leave Vestiaire ahead on its own at every price above $18.75.
Worked example 3: a $10,000 watch at VIP with a 15% Rebag rate
A watch sells for $10,000. The seller is a VIP, and Rebag quoted a 15% commission.
- The RealReal: $10,000.00 x 90% = $9,000.00. (Base rate 85% for a watch at this price, plus a 5-point VIP bonus.)
- Vestiaire Collective: $10,000.00 - 17% selling fee ($1,700.00) - 3% processing ($300.00) = $8,000.00.
- Fashionphile: $10,000.00 - 30% of the first $3,000 ($900.00) - 15% of the remaining $7,000.00 ($1,050.00) = $8,050.00.
- Rebag: $10,000.00 - 15% commission ($1,500.00) = $8,500.00.
- Best payout $9,000.00 (The RealReal); lowest payout $8,000.00 (Vestiaire Collective); the gap is $1,000.00.
The tier is the whole story here. At Trendsetter the same watch pays 85% on The RealReal, which is $8,500, and ties with Rebag at the top. The VIP bonus adds 5 points, which is $500 on a $10,000 sale, and moves The RealReal $500 clear of Rebag and $1,000 clear of Vestiaire Collective. Watches are the category where The RealReal's top rate is highest, and a VIP seller with an expensive watch is the one case where The RealReal beats every other platform by a wide margin.
Worked example 4: a $50 clothing item at Trendsetter
A clothing item sells for $50. The seller is a Trendsetter with no loyalty bonus, and the Rebag rate is the 25% default.
- The RealReal: $50.00 x 20% = $10.00. (Base rate 20% for a clothing item at this price.)
- Vestiaire Collective: $50.00 - $12.00 flat selling fee - $3.00 processing fee = $35.00.
- Fashionphile: $50.00 - 30% consignment fee ($15.00) = $35.00.
- Rebag: $50.00 - 25% commission ($12.50) = $37.50.
- Best payout $37.50 (Rebag); lowest payout $10.00 (The RealReal); the gap is $27.50.
At $50 the ranking flips. The RealReal's 20% share is the worst payout in the whole comparison, less than a third of what Rebag pays, because the 20% band is designed for items The RealReal barely wants to handle. Vestiaire Collective's flat $15 of fees takes 30% of the price, which ties with Fashionphile's 30% fee at $35. Rebag wins by $2.50. The lesson is that the cheapest items have the widest spread in percentage terms: the best payout is nearly four times the worst, even though the gap in dollars is only $27.50.
The RealReal commission chart in full
The table below is the full Earnings Guide chart as read from The RealReal's own page by three independent sources in October and November 2026. Each cell is the share of the net selling price you keep, before any Rewards bonus. The bonus adds 1, 2 or 5 points on items of $200 or more, for Influencer, Tastemaker and VIP sellers. The rate applies to the whole sale price.
| Item sells for | Clothing and more | Handbags | Branded fine jewelry | Watches | Men's sneakers and collectibles |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Under $100 | 20% | 20% | 20% | 20% | 20% |
| $100 to $149 | 30% | 30% | 30% | 30% | 30% |
| $150 to $199 | 45% | 45% | 45% | 45% | 45% |
| $200 to $299 | 55% | 55% | 55% | 55% | 55% |
| $300 to $499 | 60% | 60% | 65% | 60% | 65% |
| $500 to $749 | 60% | 60% | 65% | 70% | 75% |
| $750 to $999 | 65% | 65% | 70% | 70% | 75% |
| $1,000 to $1,499 | 65% | 65% | 70% | 70% | 85% |
| $1,500 to $1,999 | 65% | 70% | 70% | 70% | 85% |
| $2,000 to $4,999 | 65% | 70% | 70% | 75% | 85% |
| $5,000 to $7,499 | 70% | 75% | 70% | 80% | 85% |
| $7,500 and up | 70% | 80% | 70% | 85% | 85% |
Three patterns in the chart are worth knowing. First, the bands under $300 are identical in every category, so a $250 item earns 55% whether it is a dress, a bag, a watch or a pair of sneakers: $137.50. Second, men's sneakers and collectibles reach the top 85% rate at just $1,000, while handbags need $7,500 to reach 80% and watches need $7,500 to reach 85%. A $1,000 pair of sneakers earns $850 on The RealReal, more than a $1,000 handbag earns at $650. Third, branded fine jewelry tops out at 70% and never rises above it, so a $10,000 jewelry item earns $7,000 on The RealReal while a $10,000 handbag earns $8,000 and a $10,000 watch earns $8,500. Jewelry sellers should check the other platforms first: at $10,000, Vestiaire Collective pays $8,000, Fashionphile pays $8,050, and Rebag at 25% pays $7,500, so every other platform beats The RealReal's jewelry rate at that price.
The RealReal also pays a 5% bonus if you take your payout as site credit instead of cash: a $1,000 handbag that pays $650 in cash pays $682.50 in credit. That is store credit, not money, so the calculator compares cash payouts only and leaves the credit bonus here for you to weigh. The RealReal pays on the 15th of the month after the sale, by direct deposit, check or site credit, and a mailed check costs $12.50 per check.
Vestiaire Collective fees and the October 2026 change
Vestiaire Collective's fee schedule is the one part of this comparison where the sources disagreed, and the disagreement is worth explaining because it shows why the calculator re-verifies every figure against the platform's own page. Three different Vestiaire schedules appear in guides and comparisons published in 2025 and 2026. The oldest of the three is a flat 10% selling fee plus a 3% processing fee, with a $10 flat fee under $100 and a $2,000 flat fee above $20,000, which applied to items listed from 21 October 2024 to 18 July 2025. The second is a flat 12% selling fee plus a 3% processing fee, with a $10 flat fee under $83 and a $2,000 flat fee above $16,667. The third, and current, schedule is a flat 17% selling fee plus a 3% processing fee, with a $12 flat fee under $75 and a $2,500 flat fee above $15,000. A tiered 25%, 20%, 18%, 15% and 12% structure also circulates in guides, but it does not match any schedule on Vestiaire's own archived pages for US sellers.
All three are real, and they are three generations of the same schedule. Vestiaire's own help center settles the order. The flat 10% schedule was the schedule in force before 18 July 2025, and Vestiaire keeps an archived page for it. The flat 12% schedule applied to new listings from 18 July 2025 to 14 October 2026, and Vestiaire keeps a separate archived page for that period. The 17% schedule applies to all new items listed from 15 October 2026 onwards, and it is the schedule on Vestiaire's live help center page today. The calculator uses the 17% schedule, because Vestiaire's own current page governs, and because a seller listing an item today pays 17%, not 12%.
The change is large. On a $2,000 handbag the old 12% schedule paid $1,700, which is 85% of the price, while the current 17% schedule pays $1,600, which is 80%. On a $10,000 handbag the old schedule paid $8,500 and the current schedule pays $8,000. Guides that still quote 12% overstate the Vestiaire payout by 5% of the sale price, which is $500 on a $10,000 bag. The change also reshuffles the ranking: under the old 12% schedule Vestiaire beat The RealReal's 80% handbag rate at every price, while under the current 17% schedule the two tie from $7,500 to $15,000 and Fashionphile wins at $10,000 and $15,000. If you read a comparison that shows Vestiaire paying 85% on a mid-price bag, it is quoting the schedule that ended on 14 October 2026.
Vestiaire's schedule also varies by currency and by listing date, which is another reason guides disagree. The 17% rate reached euro listings on 9 June 2026, sterling listings stayed at 12% from 9 March 2026, and US dollar listings moved to 17% on 15 October 2026. This calculator covers US sellers listing in US dollars only, and the schedule it uses is the US dollar schedule for items listed from 15 October 2026. If you list in another currency, or if your item was listed before 15 October 2026, the old schedule may still apply to it: check the fee schedule in force on your listing date in Vestiaire's help center.
Which platform pays most at each price
The table below runs a handbag through all four platforms at nine sale prices, at Trendsetter with the 25% Rebag default. It is the quickest way to see how the winner changes as the price rises. The same pattern holds for other item types, with the differences that The RealReal's rate is higher for watches and sneakers and lower for jewelry at the top end.
| Handbag sale price | The RealReal | Vestiaire Collective | Fashionphile | Rebag at 25% | Best payout |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| $100 | $30.00 | $80.00 | $70.00 | $75.00 | Vestiaire Collective |
| $300 | $180.00 | $240.00 | $210.00 | $225.00 | Vestiaire Collective |
| $500 | $300.00 | $400.00 | $350.00 | $375.00 | Vestiaire Collective |
| $1,000 | $650.00 | $800.00 | $700.00 | $750.00 | Vestiaire Collective |
| $1,500 | $1,050.00 | $1,200.00 | $1,050.00 | $1,125.00 | Vestiaire Collective |
| $3,000 | $2,100.00 | $2,400.00 | $2,100.00 | $2,250.00 | Vestiaire Collective |
| $5,000 | $3,750.00 | $4,000.00 | $3,800.00 | $3,750.00 | Vestiaire Collective |
| $10,000 | $8,000.00 | $8,000.00 | $8,050.00 | $7,500.00 | Fashionphile |
| $15,000 | $12,000.00 | $12,000.00 | $12,300.00 | $11,250.00 | Fashionphile |
| $20,000 | $16,000.00 | $16,900.00 | $16,550.00 | $15,000.00 | Vestiaire Collective |
| $50,000 | $40,000.00 | $46,000.00 | $42,050.00 | $37,500.00 | Vestiaire Collective |
Four patterns stand out. First, Vestiaire Collective wins most handbag prices from $100 to $5,000, because its flat 20% all-in fee beats The RealReal's band rates and Fashionphile's 30% at those prices. Second, Fashionphile takes the lead at $10,000 and $15,000, where its 15% top slice pulls its effective fee below 20%: 19.5% at $10,000 and 18.0% at $15,000. Third, Vestiaire takes the lead back above $15,000, where its flat $2,500 cap kicks in, and the lead grows with the price: $350 ahead of Fashionphile at $20,000 and $3,950 ahead at $50,000. Fourth, Rebag at the 25% default never wins a handbag price in this table, but Rebag at a 15% quote would win at $100 ($85.00), beat Vestiaire Collective at $1,000 ($850.00 against $800.00), and beat every platform at $5,000 ($4,250.00). The Rebag rate you enter is the single most powerful input in the tool, which is why the calculator asks for it instead of fixing it.
The picture changes with the item type. For watches, The RealReal's 85% top rate beats Vestiaire's 80% from $7,500 up, so a $10,000 watch pays $8,500 on The RealReal against $8,000 on Vestiaire, and a VIP watch seller keeps 90%. For men's sneakers and collectibles, The RealReal's 85% rate starts at just $1,000, so a $1,000 pair of sneakers pays $850 on The RealReal against $800 on Vestiaire. For branded fine jewelry, The RealReal never rises above 70%, so Vestiaire wins at most prices, and Fashionphile wins at $10,000 and $15,000. For clothing, The RealReal's 70% ceiling means the same pattern holds: Vestiaire wins at most prices in the table, with Fashionphile taking the lead at $10,000 and $15,000. Run your own item type through the calculator rather than reading the handbag table as a general rule.
Ties are common in this comparison, and they are exact. The RealReal and Vestiaire Collective tie at $6,000 on a $7,500 handbag, at $8,000 on a $10,000 handbag, and at $12,000 on a $15,000 handbag, because 80% kept and 20% taken are the same split. At $9,000 a handbag produces a three-way tie: The RealReal pays $7,200 at 80%, Vestiaire Collective pays $7,200 after 20% in fees, and Fashionphile pays $7,200 after a $1,800 fee, while Rebag at 25% pays $6,750. If Rebag quotes 20% on that same bag, all four platforms pay $7,200 and there is no payout gap at all. When the payouts tie, the choice comes down to speed, service and who sets the price, not the money.
What the payout does not include
The payouts this calculator shows are the platform's arithmetic on the sale price. Several real costs and risks sit outside that arithmetic, and they can change the decision even when they do not change the payout figure.
Income tax. Every payout is before income tax. A profit on a personal item can be taxable, and the rules depend on your situation, including whether you sell occasionally or as a business. The calculator does not model tax, and no platform's fee schedule includes it. If you sell often, our Profit Margin Calculator helps you work out your margin after every cost, and our Sales Tax Calculator works out the tax on a sale.
Markdowns and the price you actually get. The sale price in this calculator is the net selling price after discounts. On The RealReal you do not set the price: its team prices the item, and it can discount it or include it in sales and coupons, which lowers the base the percentage is applied to. On Fashionphile, items that stay unsold after 25 days are discounted, and items that still do not sell go to a Last Call sale with further daily discounts. On Vestiaire Collective you set your own price and can negotiate with buyers, so the price is yours to defend. A platform that pays 80% of a $1,700 markdown is worse than a platform that pays 70% of a $2,000 full price, and the calculator cannot see the markdown coming. Enter the price you realistically expect, not the price you hope for.
Shipping and authentication. Vestiaire Collective provides prepaid shipping labels. The RealReal, Fashionphile and Rebag arrange shipping as part of their service, and none of the four charges the seller a listing fee. The costs that can appear are the return costs: Fashionphile charges a $125 authentication fee on a Hermes Birkin or Kelly, or $75 on anything else, if you ask for the item back during the initial consignment term, and Rebag charges a processing fee of 3% of the listing price, with a $50 minimum and a $300 maximum, plus a $50 shipping fee, if you request a return while still eligible for a payout. The calculator does not subtract these, because they apply only if you pull the item.
Returns and the time to get paid. A sale is not money until the return period passes and the payment clears. Fashionphile gives buyers 15 days to return an item, and pays after the return period has elapsed and the buyer's payment has cleared. The RealReal pays on the 15th of the month after the sale. Rebag pays about 15 business days after the sale is confirmed, and its own policy allows up to 30 business days to release consignment funds. Vestiaire Collective issues the payout within 24 hours after the sale is marked complete, which for authenticated shipping is about 2 business days after the item reaches its warehouse, and for direct shipping is 72 hours after delivery to the buyer. A payout that arrives in two weeks is worth more than the same payout that arrives in two months, and the calculator shows the amounts side by side so you can weigh the timing yourself.
Site credit bonuses. Three platforms pay more if you take credit instead of cash. The RealReal adds 5% to your payout as site credit. Rebag's Wallet balance grows by 1% per month for up to 9 months, a bonus of up to 9%. Fashionphile's buyout pays 15% more in store credit than in cash. The calculator compares cash payouts only, because credit is not money in your bank account, but if you plan to buy on the same platform the credit bonus can be worth more than the payout gap. A $1,000 handbag that pays $650 in cash on The RealReal pays $682.50 in site credit, which is still $117.50 short of Vestiaire Collective's $800.00 cash payout, so the credit bonus narrows the gap without closing it.
What each platform accepts. The four platforms do not accept the same items. The RealReal works from an accepted designers list and takes women's and men's clothing, shoes and accessories, handbags, branded fine jewelry, watches, men's sneakers and collectibles, kids' designer pieces, and home and art. Fashionphile and Rebag focus on handbags, jewelry and watches. Vestiaire Collective is a peer-to-peer marketplace with the widest range. Check that the platform accepts your brand and category before you ship, and check the condition standards too: all four authenticate, and an item that fails authentication comes back to you.
Features
Four platforms, one sale. The RealReal, Vestiaire Collective, Fashionphile and Rebag are run on the same net selling price, so the comparison is apples to apples. The table ranks them best first with the fee, the share you keep, and the payout on each row.
The full RealReal chart. All five RealReal categories and all twelve price bands are in the engine, with the Rewards bonus applied only where it belongs: on items of $200 or more, as extra points on the base rate. The band jumps are exact: a handbag at $1,499 pays 65% and the same bag at $1,500 pays 70%.
Vestiaire's current schedule, not the old one. The engine uses the 17% schedule in force for US listings from 15 October 2026, with the $12 flat fee under $75, the $2,500 cap above $15,000, and the $3 processing minimum. Guides that still quote 12% overstate the payout by 5% of the sale price.
Fashionphile's marginal split, done properly. The 30% slice and the 15% slice are computed separately and printed separately in the steps, so a $5,000 sale shows the $900 fee on the first $3,000 and the $300 fee on the rest, not a blended guess.
Rebag's rate as an input. Because Rebag quotes each item individually, the calculator asks for the rate on your quote, with a 25% default at the top of the typical 15% to 25% range. Change the rate and the ranking updates at once.
Ties named, not hidden. When two, three or four platforms pay the same top figure, the headline says so and names them. At $9,000 a handbag ties three ways at $7,200, and with a 20% Rebag quote all four tie.
Every figure checkable. The steps print the full working for each platform, with the rate, the fee and the payout, so you can verify every number with a pocket calculator. Fee plus payout equals the sale price on every row.
Use cases
Cleaning out a closet. You have five or six designer pieces to sell and want the best total, not the best rate on one bag. Run each piece through the calculator at its expected price: the $80 scarf and the $400 shoes may belong on Vestiaire Collective, the $2,000 bag may belong on Vestiaire too, and the $8,000 watch may belong on The RealReal if you are a VIP seller. Splitting the closet across platforms beats sending everything to one place.
Deciding whether to consign or take a buyout. Fashionphile and Rebag both offer buyouts: a fixed offer, paid fast, with the margin built into the offer. Run the consignment payout through the calculator first. If Fashionphile consignment pays $3,800 on a $5,000 bag and the buyout offer is $3,200, the $600 gap is the price of getting paid now instead of waiting for a sale. If the buyout is $3,700, the gap is $100 and the certainty may be worth it.
Checking a Rebag quote. Rebag quotes a commission per item, and the quote is a single number with no context. Enter the quoted rate and the expected sale price, and the calculator shows what the quote is worth against the other three platforms. A 15% quote on a $2,000 bag pays $1,700, which beats Vestiaire Collective's $1,600; a 25% quote pays $1,500, which does not.
Planning around a tier. If you are close to the next RealReal Rewards tier, the bonus changes the ranking. A seller with $4,900 in net sales is an Influencer with a 1-point bonus; one more $200 sale makes them a Tastemaker with a 2-point bonus, which is worth $100 on a $10,000 watch. Run the calculator at both tiers and compare before you decide which item to consign next.
Weighing a big-ticket sale. On a $50,000 item the gap between the best and worst payout is $8,500, which is more than most people pay for a used car. Vestiaire Collective's flat $2,500 cap makes it the clear winner at that price, paying $46,000 against $42,050 on Fashionphile and $40,000 on The RealReal. On a sale that large, the calculator's answer is worth checking against each platform's current terms the day you ship, because a fee change of a single point is $500.
Selling sneakers. Men's sneakers and collectibles are the category where The RealReal is most generous, reaching 85% at just $1,000. A $1,000 pair of sneakers pays $850 on The RealReal, $800 on Vestiaire Collective, $700 on Fashionphile and $750 on Rebag at 25%. If your sneakers are not designer enough for The RealReal's accepted list, our Sneaker Resale Fee Comparison Calculator runs the same sale through StockX, GOAT and eBay, and our Niche Marketplace Seller Fee Comparison Calculator covers Grailed alongside Reverb, Discogs, TCGplayer and BrickLink.
Sources
Every rate in this calculator comes from a dated source, and every source was read or re-verified on 20 November 2026. Where sources conflicted, the platform's own page governed, and the resolution is recorded here and in the page register.
- Vestiaire Collective help center, Seller: Selling Fees (US, USD) — read 20 November 2026. The current schedule for items listed from 15 October 2026: under $75 a flat $12 selling fee, $75 to $15,000 a 17% selling fee, over $15,000 a flat $2,500 selling fee, plus a 3% processing fee with a $3 minimum. Minimum listing price $18. This page governs the Vestiaire figures in the calculator.
- Vestiaire Collective help center, Seller: Selling Fees until October 14th, 2026 — read 20 November 2026. The superseded schedule: 12% selling fee plus 3% processing for items listed from 18 July 2025 to 14 October 2026, with a $10 flat fee under $83 and a $2,000 flat fee above $16,667. Used here only to explain why older guides quote 12%.
- Vestiaire Collective help center, Seller: When will I receive my payment for my sold item? — read 20 November 2026. Payout issued within 24 hours after the sale is marked complete; authenticated shipping completes about 2 business days after the item reaches the warehouse; direct shipping completes 72 hours after delivery to the buyer; US bank transfer takes 2 business days, PayPal and Venmo within 24 hours.
- The RealReal, Earnings Guide (therealreal.com/seller/commissions) — the chart is rendered in JavaScript and could not be fetched directly on 20 November 2026, so the figures are taken from three independent sources that read the guide in October and November 2026 and agree on every band: FlipperTools, How to Sell on The RealReal in 2026; Underpriced, The RealReal Commission and Payout Chart 2026 (checked 16 October 2026); and Feebrief, The RealReal Fees Explained (checked 31 October 2026). All three agree on the shared ladder under $300, all five category band sets, the Rewards tier thresholds and bonuses, the $200 bonus threshold, the 5% site credit bonus, the 15th-of-the-month payment date, and the $12.50 mailed-check fee.
- Fashionphile help center, What are FASHIONPHILE's consignment fees? — read 20 November 2026. 30% of the sale price up to $3,000, and 15% of the portion above $3,000. The same page states the 25-day discount rule and the $125 (Hermes Birkin or Kelly) and $75 (all other items) authentication fees on early return.
- Rebag help center, More information on Consignment — updated 19 October 2026, read 20 November 2026. Commission rates are based on the item's listing price and category, as low as 8% for in-demand high-value pieces, most items typically in the 15% to 25% range, with actual rates communicated individually for each quoted item. Payout about 15 business days after the confirmation date, with the Wallet balance increasing 1% per month for up to 9 months. Return processing fee 3% of the listing price, $50 minimum and $300 maximum, plus a $50 shipping fee.
- Finluxy, Consigning Luxury Fashion: What Platforms Pay (June 2026) — the research source for the original brief. Its RealReal, Fashionphile and Rebag figures still match the platforms' current terms; its Vestiaire figure (12% plus 3%) is the schedule that ended on 14 October 2026 and is superseded by the 17% schedule above.
- InvestAlternative, The RealReal Review (September 2026) — confirms the RealReal handbag bands, the VIP 85% rate on a $10,000 bag, and the Fashionphile marginal split, with a worked $10,000 example that matches this calculator: $8,000 on The RealReal at the base rate, $8,050 on Fashionphile consignment.
- Realm of Style, Fashionphile vs The RealReal: Which Pays You More? (October 2026) — confirms the Fashionphile 30% and 15% marginal split and the RealReal handbag bands, with a comparison table that matches this calculator at $500 ($300 against $350), $1,000 ($650 against $700), $1,500 (a $1,050 tie) and $7,500 ($6,000 against $5,925).
Figures not in the engine, used as context only: the RealReal's overall consignor commission rate of about 62% in 2025, from the company's investor disclosures as reported by InvestAlternative; Rebag's 2025 Clair Report value-retention figures, from Rebag's sixth annual report released in December 2025; and the 30-business-day outside limit on Rebag consignment payouts, from a 2026 review of Rebag's terms. No live prices are used anywhere in this tool. Every fee schedule is a dated static table, and the sale price is entered by the user.
Frequently asked questions
Which luxury consignment platform pays sellers the most?
It depends on the price, the item type, and your seller tier, which is why the answer is a calculator and not a single name. For most handbag prices from $100 to $5,000, Vestiaire Collective pays the most, because its 20% all-in fee beats The RealReal's band rates and Fashionphile's 30%. Fashionphile wins at $10,000 and $15,000 for handbags, where its 15% top slice pulls its effective fee below 20%. Vestiaire wins again above $15,000, where its flat $2,500 selling-fee cap takes over. The RealReal wins for expensive watches, especially for VIP sellers, and for men's sneakers over $1,000, where its 85% rate starts far lower than in any other category. Rebag wins when its quote is low: at a 15% commission it beats every platform on a $5,000 handbag. A $2,000 handbag pays $1,400 on The RealReal, $1,600 on Vestiaire Collective, $1,400 on Fashionphile, and $1,500 on Rebag at 25%, a $200 gap between the best and worst.
What commission does The RealReal take?
The RealReal pays you a percentage of the net selling price, and the percentage depends on the category and the price band. Every category shares one ladder under $300: 20% under $100, 30% from $100 to $149, 45% from $150 to $199, and 55% from $200 to $299. Above $300 the categories split: handbags reach 80% at $7,500 and above, watches reach 85% at $7,500 and above, men's sneakers and collectibles reach 85% at $1,000 and above, clothing reaches 70% at $5,000 and above, and branded fine jewelry tops out at 70%. The rate applies to the whole sale price, not just the part above each line. RealReal Rewards adds 1, 2 or 5 points for Influencer, Tastemaker and VIP sellers, but only on items that sell for $200 or more. Taking your payout as site credit adds another 5%.
What fees does Vestiaire Collective charge sellers in 2026?
For sellers in the United States listing in US dollars, Vestiaire Collective charges a selling fee plus a 3% payment processing fee with a $3 minimum. The selling fee is a flat $12 on items under $75, 17% of the sale price from $75 to $15,000, and a flat $2,500 on items over $15,000. Listing is free, and the minimum listing price is $18. This schedule applies to items listed from 15 October 2026. It replaced the 12% schedule that ran from 18 July 2025 to 14 October 2026, which is why many guides still quote 12%: on a $2,000 sale the old schedule paid $1,700 and the current schedule pays $1,600. Before the 12% schedule, Vestiaire charged a flat 10% selling fee plus 3% processing for items listed from 21 October 2024 to 18 July 2025. The tiered 25%, 20%, 18%, 15% and 12% structure some guides still show does not match any schedule on Vestiaire's own archived pages for US sellers. This calculator uses the current 17% schedule from Vestiaire's own help center.
How does Fashionphile consignment pay?
Fashionphile takes 30% of the sale price up to $3,000, and 15% of the portion above $3,000. The 15% applies only to the slice above $3,000, not to the whole price: a $5,000 sale pays 30% of the first $3,000, which is $900, plus 15% of the remaining $2,000, which is $300, a total fee of $1,200, and keeps $3,800. A $10,000 sale pays $1,950 in fees and keeps $8,050. Because the top slice is charged at only 15%, the effective fee falls as the price rises: 30.0% at $3,000, 24.0% at $5,000, 19.5% at $10,000, and 15.9% at $50,000. Fashionphile also buys items outright for a fixed offer, with no commission line, and it discounts consigned items that stay unsold after 25 days. Payment comes after the 15-day buyer return period has elapsed and the buyer's payment has cleared.
What commission does Rebag charge?
Rebag does not publish a fixed commission table. Its help center says commission is quoted for each item individually, based on the listing price and category, as low as 8% for in-demand high-value pieces, with most items typically falling in the 15% to 25% range. That is why this calculator asks you to enter the rate from your Rebag quote, with a 25% default at the top of the typical range. The rate matters more than any other input: on a $2,000 bag, an 8% commission pays $1,840, a 15% commission pays $1,700, and a 25% commission pays $1,500, a $340 swing inside Rebag's own range. Rebag also pays a Wallet bonus of 1% per month for up to 9 months on payouts left in your Rebag Wallet, and its Trade option adds roughly 25% over the cash offer toward a Rebag purchase. Consignment payouts arrive about 15 business days after the sale is confirmed.
Why does the same bag pay differently on each platform?
Because the four fee schedules have four different shapes. The RealReal pays a percentage that steps up at price bands, so the payout jumps at each line: a handbag at $1,499 earns 65% and the same bag at $1,500 earns 70%, a $75.65 jump for one extra dollar. Vestiaire Collective charges a flat percentage with flat fees at both ends, so its effective rate is high on cheap items and low on very expensive ones. Fashionphile charges a marginal split, 30% below $3,000 and 15% above, so its effective fee falls smoothly as the price rises. Rebag charges whatever it quotes for that item. The shapes cross each other as the price rises, which is why the winner changes: Vestiaire wins most mid-price handbags, Fashionphile wins at $10,000 and $15,000, and Vestiaire wins again above $15,000. The shapes also tie exactly: at $9,000 a handbag pays $7,200 on The RealReal, Vestiaire Collective and Fashionphile all three.
Is the payout before or after tax?
Before income tax. Every payout this calculator shows is the platform's arithmetic on the sale price, with no tax taken off. A profit on a personal item can be taxable, and the rules depend on whether you sell occasionally or as a business, so check the rules for your situation before you treat the payout as money in hand. The sale price is also the net selling price after discounts, not the original list price: The RealReal sets its own prices and markdowns, and Fashionphile discounts items that stay unsold after 25 days, so the number that matters is the price the item really sells for. Shipping is included in the platforms' service and no platform charges a listing fee, but returning an item early can cost you: Fashionphile charges a $75 authentication fee, or $125 for a Hermes Birkin or Kelly, and Rebag charges a 3% processing fee with a $50 minimum and a $300 maximum plus $50 shipping.
How often do these fee schedules change?
Often enough that you should check the current terms before you ship anything valuable. The RealReal has restructured its commission chart more than once, and its chart is the first thing checked at each review of this calculator. Vestiaire Collective changed its US selling fee from 12% to 17% on 15 October 2026, after changing it from 10% to 12% on 18 July 2025. Fashionphile's 30% and 15% split has been stable, and Rebag's per-item quoting means its effective rates move with the market rather than with a schedule change. This calculator is reviewed quarterly because of that pace of change: the figures here were last reviewed on 20 November 2026, and the next review is due on 20 February 2027. If a platform changes its fees between reviews, the calculator's figures will be out of date until the next review, so treat the result as a comparison of the published schedules on the review date, not as a live quote.
Page history
- — Pre-isBasedOn snapshot (YMYL authority, Nov 2026) (saleem891@gmail.com)
- — Pre-IA-remap snapshot: category population (live application 22 Nov 2026) (saleem891@gmail.com)
- — Published (saleem891@gmail.com)