Skip to content

Fish Identification Key

Where you caught it. Some fish, such as striped bass and tarpon, move between fresh and salt water.

Look at the fish from the side. A bluegill is deep, a bass is torpedo-shaped, a flounder is flat.

Close the mouth and see where the jaw ends. Whiskers mean a catfish, a carp, a drum, or a croaker.

Trout, salmon, and catfish have a small fleshy adipose fin between the dorsal fin and the tail. Bass and crappie have a spiny front half and a soft back half joined at the base.

Pick the pattern that stands out most. Young fish and spawning fish often look different from the typical adult.

Spread the tail fin flat and look at its back edge. A trout tail is square; a tuna-style fork means a fast open-water fish.

Total length from snout to tail tip, in inches, from 1 to 120. Leave blank if you did not measure it. Length is a typical adult catch size, not a record, so an unusually long fish still counts as a near match.

Identification

    This key is an identification aid, not a legal determination. A key narrows; confirm with your state guide before keeping — misidentification can mean an illegal keep. Size and bag limits vary by state, water, and season: check the current rules for the water you are fishing before you keep anything.
    Answer seven quick questions about the fish in front of you: water type, body shape, mouth, dorsal fin, markings, tail shape, and length. The key scores your answers against 60 common United States freshwater and inshore saltwater game fish and names the most likely species, with the five closest matches and the field mark that settles each one.

    Last reviewed: 20 November 2026. Reviewed every 180 days; next review due 19 May 2027.

    How to use the Fish Identification Key

    "What fish did I catch?" is one of the most common questions in angling, and it is usually asked with a live fish in one hand and a phone in the other. This key answers it without a photo, an app download, or an account. You answer up to seven quick questions about what you can see on the fish in front of you, and the key narrows a list of 60 common United States freshwater and inshore saltwater game fish down to the most likely species. Every question is optional except the first one: you must answer at least one question before the key can start, and water type alone is enough to begin.

    The key is a static dichotomous key, the same kind of tool field biologists have used for two centuries, rebuilt as a scoring key. Each question splits the list, and the species that matches the most of your answers rises to the top. The result shows a headline, the five closest matches with a match percentage for each, the distinguishing field mark of every match, the step-by-step narrowing so you can see exactly how the answer was reached, and a lookalike warning whenever the top match has a close relative that fools anglers. The key never guesses beyond its list: if your answers fit no species, it says so plainly and tells you which trait to re-check.

    To identify your fish, follow these steps:

    1. Pick the water type. Fresh water means a lake, river, pond, or reservoir. Salt water means the ocean, a bay, or the surf. Brackish water means an estuary or tidal creek where fresh and salt water mix. Some fish move between water types: striped bass, tarpon, snook, American shad, and American eels all appear in fresh, brackish, and salt water in this key, so picking the water where you caught the fish never rules them out. If you are unsure, leave the question on "Not sure" and answer the others.
    2. Pick the body shape. Look at the fish from the side. Deep means tall and flattened side to side, like a bluegill, a crappie, a pompano, or a sheepshead. Torpedo means long and round in cross-section, like a bass, a trout, a pike, a redfish, or a mackerel; 34 of the 60 species in this key are torpedo-shaped, so this answer alone narrows the list the least. Eel-like means very long and snakelike, which leaves only three species: longnose gar, alligator gar, and American eel. Flat means flattened top to bottom with both eyes on one side, which leaves only the two flounders. Stout means short and thick-bodied, like a catfish, a drum, a carp, or a grouper.
    3. Pick the mouth. Close the mouth and see where the jaw ends. A small mouth ends before the eye; a large mouth reaches past the eye. The jaw test is the classic way to separate largemouth bass, whose jaw extends past the back of the eye, from smallmouth and spotted bass, whose jaws end at or before the eye. An upturned mouth points upward: only the tarpon in this key has one, so that single answer identifies the fish. An underslung mouth sits on the underside of the head, which points to bottom feeders such as red drum, freshwater drum, smallmouth buffalo, and Atlantic croaker. Long pointed jaws, a beak or bill, mean a pike, a pickerel, or a gar. Whiskers, called barbels, around the mouth mean a catfish, a bullhead, a common carp, a black drum, or an Atlantic croaker.
    4. Pick the dorsal fin. The dorsal fin is the fin on top of the fish. Count how many there are and how they join. One dorsal fin means a single fin, as on a pike, a gar, a tarpon, a snapper, or a sheepshead. Two separate dorsal fins means two fins with a gap between them, as on a walleye, a yellow perch, a striped bass, a mackerel, or a seatrout. Joined means a spiny front half and a soft back half joined at the base into one long fin, as on a bass, a crappie, a bluegill, a red drum, or a croaker. An adipose fin is a small fleshy fin with no rays, sitting between the dorsal fin and the tail: trout, salmon, catfish, and bullheads have one, and nothing else in this key does. One very long dorsal fin, running most of the back, means a bowfin, a cobia, a flounder, or an American eel.
    5. Pick the markings. Choose the pattern that stands out most. Vertical bars run up and down the side, as on a smallmouth bass, a yellow perch, a white crappie, a sheepshead, or a black drum. Horizontal stripes run along the side, as on a striped bass, a white bass, a snook, or a cobia. Spots are round marks, as on a spotted bass, a rainbow trout, a northern pike, a Spanish mackerel, or a spotted seatrout. Mottled blotches are irregular dark patches, as on a largemouth bass, a black crappie, a walleye, a muskellunge, or a gag grouper. Plain means no strong pattern, as on a blue catfish, a king mackerel, or a tarpon. A spot at the tail base is the single most decisive marking in the key: only the red drum, the spot, the pinfish, and the male bowfin carry one.
    6. Pick the tail shape. Spread the tail fin flat and look at its back edge. A forked tail has a deep V, as on a walleye, a catfish, a mackerel, or a tarpon; 26 of the 60 species have one. A rounded tail is curved, as on a bowfin, a gar, a yellow bullhead, or a southern flounder. A square tail is straight across, or has only a slight notch, as on a bass, a crappie, a trout, or a red drum. A pointed tail tapers to a point, or there is no separate tail fin at all: only the American eel in this key has one.
    7. Enter the length, if you measured it. Total length from snout to tail tip, in inches, from 1 to 120. Length is optional, and leaving it blank never hurts the result. When you do enter it, the key treats it as a seventh trait: a species scores a point if your length falls inside its typical adult catch band. The bands are broad, because fish vary: a largemouth bass counts as 12 to 24 inches, a red drum as 16 to 40 inches, an alligator gar as 36 to 72 inches. A fish longer than its band is unusual, not impossible, so the key reports it as a near match with a warning instead of ruling the species out.

    The tool updates as you answer, so you can try different combinations quickly. Try the example buttons under the form: a largemouth bass at 18 inches, a red drum at 24 inches, a summer flounder at 18 inches, and a walleye at 20 inches. Each example shows a different shape of answer, and each one lands on a single species. Read the full result, not just the headline. The headline names the most likely species. The cards show how many traits you answered, the top score, how many species share it, and the size of the key. The matches table shows the five closest species with a match percentage and the traits each one matched. The distinguishing notes give one field mark per match. The guidance explains the result in plain language and tells you which question to answer next when the list is still long. The warnings flag the lookalike to check and any length that runs past the usual band. The steps print the full narrowing so you can check every count.

    How it works

    The key holds 60 species, each described by the same seven traits: water type, body shape, mouth, dorsal fin, markings, tail shape, and typical adult length. Some species carry more than one value for a trait. A striped bass lives in fresh, salt, and brackish water. A black drum has barbels and an underslung mouth. A bowfin is plain in markings, but a male bowfin also carries a spot at the tail base. A species scores a point for a trait if the answer you picked is one of its values. Your score for a species is the number of answered traits it matches, out of the number of traits you answered. Species are ranked by score, highest first, with ties broken alphabetically so the order is always the same for the same answers.

    The result falls into one of five shapes, depending on the top score and how many species share it:

    • Single. One species matches every trait you answered, and no other species does. The headline reads "Most likely" followed by the name, and the guidance names the species with its scientific name and its distinguishing field mark.
    • Shortlist. Two, three, or four species match every trait you answered. The guidance names them all and tells you which question separates them, naming what each species shows for that trait. If no remaining question separates them, it says so and points you to the distinguishing marks in the list.
    • Broad. Five or more species match every trait you answered. This happens when you answer only one or two questions. The guidance names the question that splits the group the most and asks you to answer it next.
    • Near. No species matches every trait, but the best matches miss only one. The guidance names the closest matches and tells you which trait to re-check first, starting with the trait the top match misses.
    • No match. The best match misses two or more traits. The traits may be misread, or the fish may not be one of the 60 species in this key. The guidance says so and suggests re-checking body shape and mouth first, because those two traits narrow the key the most.

    The length trait works differently from the other six. The other traits are either-or: a fish either has a forked tail or it does not. Length is a band, and bands overlap. A 20-inch fish falls inside the typical band of a largemouth bass, a smallmouth bass, a walleye, a rainbow trout, a red drum, a spotted seatrout, and many more. Length rarely identifies a fish on its own, but it breaks ties well: a 12-inch fish with a deep silver body and two dorsal fins is a Florida pompano, while the same fish at 20 inches is a permit, because the pompano band tops out at 16 inches and the permit band starts at 16.

    The steps section shows the narrowing as a chain of counts. It starts with all 60 species and applies your answers in a fixed order: water, body shape, mouth, dorsal fin, markings, tail shape, length. Each step counts the species that match every answer so far. The counts only ever stay the same or fall, and the final count is the number of species that match everything you answered, or zero when nothing matches everything. The worked examples below show the chain for four real answers, with every count taken from the key itself.

    Worked example 1: largemouth bass, 18 inches

    Fresh water, torpedo body, large mouth, joined dorsal fin, mottled blotches, square tail, 18 inches long.

    • After Water (fresh water): 39 species remain.
    • After Body shape (long and torpedo-shaped): 22 species remain.
    • After Mouth (a large mouth): 9 species remain.
    • After Dorsal fin (spiny and soft dorsal joined): 3 species remain.
    • After Markings (mottled blotches): 1 species remains.
    • After Tail shape (a square tail): 1 species remains.
    • After Length (18 inches): 1 species remains.
    • One species matches all 7 traits: Largemouth Bass.

    The headline reads "Most likely: Largemouth Bass." The matches table shows Largemouth Bass at 100 percent (7 of 7), then Smallmouth Bass and Spotted Bass at 86 percent (6 of 7), then Black Crappie and Black Sea Bass at 71 percent (5 of 7). The warning names the lookalike: check against Spotted Bass, which has a smaller jaw that ends at the eye and rows of small dark spots below the lateral line.

    Worked example 2: three trout tie

    Fresh water, torpedo body, small mouth, adipose fin, spots, square tail, no length entered.

    • After Water (fresh water): 39 species remain.
    • After Body shape (long and torpedo-shaped): 22 species remain.
    • After Mouth (a small mouth): 9 species remain.
    • After Dorsal fin (a small adipose fin behind the dorsal): 7 species remain.
    • After Markings (spots): 6 species remain.
    • After Tail shape (a square tail): 3 species remain.
    • 3 species match all 6 traits: Brown Trout, Cutthroat Trout, and Rainbow Trout.

    The headline reads "3 possible species match every trait." The guidance tells you what separates them: check the length, because a brown trout is typically 10 to 20 inches, a cutthroat trout is typically 10 to 18 inches, and a rainbow trout is typically 10 to 20 inches. A 19-inch fish breaks the tie toward brown and rainbow trout. The field marks break it further: a rainbow trout has a pink or red stripe along the side and spots on the tail, a brown trout has red-orange spots ringed in pale blue and no spots on the tail, and a cutthroat trout has a red or orange slash under each side of the jaw.

    Worked example 3: red drum, 24 inches

    Salt water, torpedo body, underslung mouth, joined dorsal fin, spot at the tail base, square tail, 24 inches long.

    • After Water (salt water): 26 species remain.
    • After Body shape (long and torpedo-shaped): 16 species remain.
    • After Mouth (a mouth on the underside): 2 species remain.
    • After Dorsal fin (spiny and soft dorsal joined): 2 species remain.
    • After Markings (a spot at the tail base): 1 species remains.
    • After Tail shape (a square tail): 1 species remains.
    • After Length (24 inches): 1 species remains.
    • One species matches all 7 traits: Red Drum.

    The mouth answer does the heavy work here: only two saltwater torpedo-shaped species in the key have an underslung mouth, and the tail spot settles it. The warning names the lookalike: check against Black Drum, which has chin barbels and no spot at the tail base. The red drum's tail spot is its most famous field mark: one large black spot on the upper part of the tail base, with multiple spots not uncommon and no spots extremely rare, according to Texas Parks and Wildlife.

    Worked example 4: a near miss

    Fresh water, torpedo body, small mouth, adipose fin, mottled blotches, forked tail, no length entered.

    • After Water (fresh water): 39 species remain.
    • After Body shape (long and torpedo-shaped): 22 species remain.
    • After Mouth (a small mouth): 9 species remain.
    • After Dorsal fin (a small adipose fin behind the dorsal): 7 species remain.
    • After Markings (mottled blotches): 1 species remains.
    • After Tail shape (a forked tail): 0 species remain.
    • No species matches all 6 traits. The closest matches each miss one trait.

    The headline reads "No exact match. Closest: Brook Trout." The closest matches, Brook Trout, Chinook Salmon, Coho Salmon, and Lake Trout, each score 5 of 6, or 83 percent. The guidance tells you to re-check the trait that does not fit, starting with the tail shape: the brook trout that matches everything else has a square tail, not a forked one. Either the tail was misread, or the fish is a lake trout or salmon whose blotchy back was read as mottled blotches. This is the honest answer a key should give when the traits do not line up, and it is more useful than a forced guess.

    The seven questions, in detail

    Water type: 39 fresh, 26 salt, 21 brackish

    Of the 60 species, 39 live in fresh water, 26 in salt water, and 21 in brackish water. The counts add up to more than 60 because 21 species appear in more than one water type. Striped bass, tarpon, snook, American shad, and American eels move between all three. Most of the inshore saltwater species also use brackish estuaries. Only five species in the key are salt water only: Spanish mackerel, king mackerel, red snapper, black sea bass, and gag grouper. Water type is the best first question because it is the one you always know: you know where you were standing when you caught the fish. It is also the question most likely to be answered wrong on a tidal river, where fresh water at the surface can hide salt water below. If you fish a tidal creek and are unsure, answer brackish, or leave the question blank and let the body do the work.

    Body shape: the torpedo problem

    Body shape is the weakest single question in the key, because 34 of the 60 species are torpedo-shaped. A torpedo body tells you the fish is built for open-water swimming, and not much else. The other shapes are far more decisive. A deep body leaves 12 species. A stout body leaves 9. An eel-like body leaves 3. A flat body leaves 2. The lesson for the angler is to answer the body question honestly rather than hopefully: a bluegill held at an angle can look torpedo-shaped in a photo, but from the side it is unmistakably deep, taller than it is long in the front half. If the fish looks deep from the side and narrow from the front, it is deep. If it looks round in cross-section, like a torpedo, it is torpedo-shaped. If it looks like a snake, it is eel-like. If it looks like a pancake with both eyes on top, it is flat.

    Mouth: the jaw test and the whisker test

    The mouth question carries two of the sharpest tests in fish identification. The jaw test separates the black basses: on a largemouth bass the upper jaw extends past the back of the eye, while on a smallmouth bass it ends at the middle of the eye and on a spotted bass it ends at the eye. The same test separates a walleye, with its large mouth and canine teeth, from a yellow perch, with its small mouth. The whisker test is even sharper: only eight species in the key have barbels, and they fall into two groups that never overlap in water type. In fresh water, barbels mean a catfish, a bullhead, or a common carp. In salt water, barbels mean a black drum or an Atlantic croaker. The upturned mouth is the single most decisive answer in the whole key: only the tarpon has one, so that answer alone identifies the fish.

    Dorsal fin: the adipose fin is the giveaway

    The dorsal fin question has five answers, and they split the key nearly evenly: 15 species have one dorsal fin, 14 have two separate dorsals, 14 have a joined spiny and soft dorsal, 12 have an adipose fin, and 5 have one very long dorsal fin. The adipose fin is the most useful of the five, because it appears in only two families: the trout and salmon family, and the catfish family. If the fish has a small fleshy fin with no rays between the dorsal fin and the tail, it is a trout, a salmon, a catfish, or a bullhead, and nothing else in the key. The joined dorsal is the sunfish signature: bass, crappie, bluegill, and their relatives all have a spiny front half and a soft back half joined at the base, with a notch between the two halves that is deep in a largemouth bass and shallow in a bluegill. Two separate dorsals mark the perch family and the mackerel family. One very long dorsal fin marks the bowfin, the cobia, the flounders, and the American eel.

    Markings: the tail spot wins

    Markings are the most variable trait in the key, because color and pattern change with age, sex, season, water clarity, and stress. A largemouth bass from clear water shows a bold dark stripe; the same species from muddy water can look almost plain. A male bluegill in spawning colors looks nothing like a female. That is why the key asks for the pattern that stands out most, and why it treats markings as one vote among seven rather than a final verdict. Even so, some markings are close to decisive. A spot at the tail base appears on only four species: red drum, spot, pinfish, and male bowfin. Horizontal stripes appear on only four: striped bass, white bass, snook, and cobia. Vertical bars appear on nine, spots on seventeen, mottled blotches on eleven, and plain on eighteen. When the markings are unclear, leave the question on "Not sure": a wrong marking answer costs a point and can push the right species out of first place, while a skipped question costs nothing.

    Tail shape: forked means fast

    The tail is the simplest question in the key, and one of the most honest. A deeply forked tail belongs to a fast open-water swimmer: mackerel, bluefish, tarpon, salmon, and walleye all have one. A square tail belongs to a fish that accelerates in short bursts: bass, crappie, trout, and red drum. A rounded tail belongs to a fish that maneuvers in cover: bowfin, gar, bullheads, and flounders. The tail also carries two of the key's best field marks. The walleye has a white tip on the lower lobe of its tail, which the sauger lacks: the Minnesota Department of Natural Resources calls the white tip and the dark blotch on the spiny dorsal fin the two marks that confirm a walleye. The summer flounder has a wedge-shaped tail with its tip in the middle, while the southern flounder has a rounded tail.

    Length: a band, not a ruler

    Length bands in this key run from 5 inches for a pinfish to 72 inches for an alligator gar and a tarpon. The bands are typical adult catch sizes, drawn from state agency guides and field guides, and they are deliberately broad: a band that is too narrow would punish every fish that is a little large or a little small for its species. A 24-inch largemouth bass is a very good fish, but it is inside the 12 to 24 inch band. A 30-inch largemouth bass is outside it, and the key says so with a warning rather than with silence. The warning matters because length is the trait anglers overestimate most: a fish held at arm's length toward the camera looks longer than it is, and a fish measured against a rod handle is rarely measured at all. If you did not measure the fish, leave the length blank. The key identifies most fish on the other six traits alone.

    How to tell the lookalikes apart

    Fifty-five of the 60 species in this key carry a lookalike warning, because the species anglers confuse most are the ones that share the most traits. The table below lists the pairs that cause the most trouble, with the single check that settles each one. Every check here is drawn from a state agency guide or a NOAA Fisheries profile, and every one of them is also printed in the tool result whenever the top match has a lookalike.

    PairThe check that settles it
    Largemouth bass vs spotted bassThe largemouth jaw extends past the eye; the spotted bass jaw ends at the eye, and it has rows of small dark spots below the lateral line.
    Largemouth bass vs smallmouth bassThe smallmouth jaw ends at the middle of the eye, and it has dark vertical bars instead of a blotchy stripe.
    Black crappie vs white crappieCount the dorsal spines: black crappie have 7 or 8, white crappie have 5 or 6. Black crappie have scattered blotches; white crappie have vertical bars.
    Walleye vs saugerA walleye has a white tip on the lower lobe of the tail and a dark blotch on the spiny dorsal fin. A sauger has rows of dark spots on the spiny dorsal fin and no white tail tip.
    Northern pike vs muskellungeA pike has light spots on a dark body and fully scaled cheeks. A muskellunge has dark bars or blotches on a light body, and the cheek and gill cover are scaled only on the upper half.
    Channel catfish vs blue catfishA channel catfish has dark spots and a rounded anal fin with 24 to 29 rays. A blue catfish has no spots and a straight-edged anal fin with 30 to 36 rays.
    Brown bullhead vs yellow bullheadA brown bullhead has a square tail and dark barbels. A yellow bullhead has a rounded tail and pale yellow-white barbels under the chin.
    Rainbow trout vs brown troutA rainbow trout has a pink or red side stripe and spots on the tail. A brown trout has red-orange spots ringed in pale blue and no spots on the tail.
    Chinook salmon vs coho salmonA chinook has black spots on both lobes of the tail and black gums. A coho has spots on the upper lobe only and white gums.
    Common carp vs smallmouth buffaloA common carp has two barbels at the corners of the mouth. A smallmouth buffalo has no barbels and a sucker mouth on the underside of a blunt head.
    White bass vs striped bassA striped bass has seven or eight unbroken horizontal stripes. A white bass has faint stripes with the lower ones broken or irregular, and it seldom passes 16 inches.
    Longnose gar vs alligator garA longnose gar has a very narrow snout with one row of teeth. An alligator gar has a broad snout with two rows of teeth in the upper jaw.
    Red drum vs black drumA red drum has a black spot at the tail base and no chin barbels. A black drum has chin barbels and no tail spot.
    Spotted seatrout vs weakfishA spotted seatrout has round black spots on the tail fin and two large canine teeth. A weakfish has small spots in wavy rows and no spots on the tail fin.
    Southern flounder vs summer flounderA summer flounder has five eye-like spots arranged in an X pattern on the back. A southern flounder has faint blotches and no distinct eye-like spots.
    Spanish mackerel vs king mackerelA Spanish mackerel has golden spots on the sides. A king mackerel has no spots as an adult, and its lateral line drops sharply below the second dorsal fin.
    Florida pompano vs permitA permit is larger, with a longer, sickle-shaped dorsal fin and orange patches on the fins. A pompano is smaller with a shorter dorsal fin.
    Mangrove snapper vs red snapperA red snapper is bright red all over with red eyes. A mangrove snapper is gray-green with a dark stripe through the eye.

    Three of these pairs deserve a longer word, because the confusion has legal consequences. Walleye and sauger are regulated separately in several states, and a sauger kept as a walleye can mean a ticket where the walleye limit is higher. Red drum and black drum have different size and bag limits on the Gulf Coast, and young black drum lose their bars as they grow, which makes a large black drum look more like a red drum every year. Striped bass and white bass hybridize in stocked reservoirs, and the hybrid, often called a wiper, has broken stripes like a white bass on a body shaped like a striped bass; this key does not list the hybrid, because its traits vary fish by fish, and a hybrid will usually land as a near match with striped bass and white bass at the top.

    The 60 species in the key

    The key covers 60 common United States freshwater and inshore saltwater game fish: 34 that live in fresh water only, 5 that live in salt water only, and 21 that move between water types. The table below lists every species with its scientific name, the water types it appears in, and its typical adult catch length band in inches. Length bands are broad typical ranges from state agency guides and field guides, not records: a fish outside its band is unusual, not impossible. Scientific names follow the American Fisheries Society 7th edition. The 2023 8th edition renamed the largemouth bass to Micropterus nigricans, but the American Fisheries Society held that decision in abeyance in a 2026 leadership comment and reverted to the 7th edition name, Micropterus salmoides, pending further review, so this key uses Micropterus salmoides.

    SpeciesScientific nameWaterTypical length
    Alligator GarAtractosteus spatulaFresh36 to 72 inches
    American EelAnguilla rostrataFresh, Salt, Brackish18 to 36 inches
    American ShadAlosa sapidissimaFresh, Salt, Brackish16 to 24 inches
    Atlantic CroakerMicropogonias undulatusSalt, Brackish8 to 14 inches
    Black CrappiePomoxis nigromaculatusFresh8 to 14 inches
    Black DrumPogonias cromisSalt, Brackish16 to 40 inches
    Black Sea BassCentropristis striataSalt10 to 18 inches
    Blue CatfishIctalurus furcatusFresh18 to 40 inches
    BluefishPomatomus saltatrixSalt, Brackish14 to 28 inches
    BluegillLepomis macrochirusFresh6 to 10 inches
    BowfinAmia calvaFresh16 to 28 inches
    Brook TroutSalvelinus fontinalisFresh7 to 14 inches
    Brown BullheadAmeiurus nebulosusFresh8 to 14 inches
    Brown TroutSalmo truttaFresh10 to 20 inches
    Chain PickerelEsox nigerFresh14 to 24 inches
    Channel CatfishIctalurus punctatusFresh14 to 30 inches
    Chinook SalmonOncorhynchus tshawytschaFresh24 to 40 inches
    CobiaRachycentron canadumSalt, Brackish24 to 48 inches
    Coho SalmonOncorhynchus kisutchFresh18 to 30 inches
    Common CarpCyprinus carpioFresh14 to 30 inches
    Cutthroat TroutOncorhynchus clarkiiFresh10 to 18 inches
    Flathead CatfishPylodictis olivarisFresh18 to 40 inches
    Florida PompanoTrachinotus carolinusSalt, Brackish10 to 16 inches
    Freshwater DrumAplodinotus grunniensFresh14 to 24 inches
    Gag GrouperMycteroperca microlepisSalt18 to 32 inches
    Green SunfishLepomis cyanellusFresh6 to 10 inches
    Jack CrevalleCaranx hipposSalt, Brackish18 to 30 inches
    King MackerelScomberomorus cavallaSalt24 to 48 inches
    Lake TroutSalvelinus namaycushFresh16 to 30 inches
    Largemouth BassMicropterus salmoidesFresh12 to 24 inches
    Longnose GarLepisosteus osseusFresh24 to 48 inches
    Mangrove SnapperLutjanus griseusSalt, Brackish10 to 18 inches
    MuskellungeEsox masquinongyFresh28 to 48 inches
    Northern PikeEsox luciusFresh20 to 36 inches
    PermitTrachinotus falcatusSalt, Brackish16 to 28 inches
    PinfishLagodon rhomboidesSalt, Brackish5 to 10 inches
    PumpkinseedLepomis gibbosusFresh5 to 9 inches
    Rainbow TroutOncorhynchus mykissFresh10 to 20 inches
    Red DrumSciaenops ocellatusSalt, Brackish16 to 40 inches
    Red SnapperLutjanus campechanusSalt14 to 28 inches
    Redear SunfishLepomis microlophusFresh7 to 11 inches
    SaugerSander canadensisFresh12 to 18 inches
    SheepsheadArchosargus probatocephalusSalt, Brackish12 to 20 inches
    Smallmouth BassMicropterus dolomieuFresh10 to 20 inches
    Smallmouth BuffaloIctiobus bubalusFresh16 to 28 inches
    SnookCentropomus undecimalisSalt, Brackish, Fresh18 to 32 inches
    Southern FlounderParalichthys lethostigmaSalt, Brackish12 to 20 inches
    Spanish MackerelScomberomorus maculatusSalt14 to 24 inches
    SpotLeiostomus xanthurusSalt, Brackish7 to 12 inches
    Spotted BassMicropterus punctulatusFresh10 to 18 inches
    Spotted SeatroutCynoscion nebulosusSalt, Brackish14 to 24 inches
    Striped BassMorone saxatilisFresh, Salt, Brackish16 to 40 inches
    Summer FlounderParalichthys dentatusSalt, Brackish14 to 30 inches
    TarponMegalops atlanticusSalt, Brackish, Fresh36 to 72 inches
    WalleyeSander vitreusFresh14 to 24 inches
    WeakfishCynoscion regalisSalt, Brackish12 to 20 inches
    White BassMorone chrysopsFresh10 to 16 inches
    White CrappiePomoxis annularisFresh8 to 14 inches
    Yellow BullheadAmeiurus natalisFresh8 to 13 inches
    Yellow PerchPerca flavescensFresh7 to 12 inches

    Features

    Seven questions, all optional but one. Answer as many or as few as you like. Water type alone starts the key. Every question you answer sharpens the result, and every question you skip costs nothing. The key never invents an answer for a question you left blank.

    Five matches, not one guess. The result shows the five closest species with a match percentage for each, so you can see how close the race was. A 100 percent match with the next species at 71 percent is a confident answer. A 100 percent match with three species tied at 100 percent is a shortlist, and the guidance tells you what separates them.

    The full working, printed. The steps section shows the narrowing as a chain of counts, one per answered trait, so you can check every number. If the chain goes from 39 species to 22 to 9 to 3 to 1, you can see exactly which answer did the work. If the chain hits zero, you can see exactly which answer broke it.

    A distinguishing mark for every match. Each of the five matches carries one field mark in plain language: the jaw test for the basses, the spine count for the crappies, the white tail tip for the walleye, the tail spot for the red drum, the eye-like spots for the summer flounder. The marks are the ones state agency guides print, not the ones that sound good in a caption.

    Lookalike warnings on 55 species. Whenever the top match has a close relative that fools anglers, the result warns you and names the check that settles it. The warning appears for single results and shortlists, where it matters most, and it names the exact feature to look at rather than telling you to be careful in general.

    Length as a soft trait. Length scores a point when it falls inside a species' typical band, and it never rules a species out on its own. A fish longer than its band earns a warning that names the usual band, so you can decide whether the length or the traits need a second look.

    Honest no-match answers. When the traits do not line up with any species, the key says so and tells you which trait to re-check first. A key that forces a guess on contradictory traits is worse than no key at all, because a wrong identification can mean an illegal keep.

    No photo, no account, no upload. The key runs entirely on the traits you pick. Nothing leaves your browser, and the tool works on a boat with one bar of signal, which is where most fish identification actually happens.

    Use cases

    At the water, fish in hand. This is the main use. You have just caught a fish, you are not sure what it is, and you need to know whether it is legal to keep. Answer the water and body questions first, then the mouth and fins, and the key will usually land on one species or a shortlist before you run out of questions. Check the lookalike warning before you decide, and confirm the size and bag limit against your state guide. Our Fishing Regulations and Catch Limits Checker covers size and bag limits for popular species by state.

    Settling an argument on the dock. Two anglers, one fish, two names. Run the key together and let the steps settle it: the chain of counts shows which traits each name matches and which one it misses. The lookalike table above covers the eighteen pairs that cause the most arguments.

    Teaching a new angler. The seven questions are the seven things an experienced angler looks at first, in the order they look at them. Walking a beginner through the key teaches the habit of looking at the mouth, the fins, and the tail before reaching for a name. The species table below the tool doubles as a study list: sixty species, each with its water type and typical size.

    Planning a trip. Before you fish a new water, check which species in the key live there and what they look like. A tidal river holds striped bass, white perch relatives, catfish, and shad. A Gulf Coast flat holds red drum, spotted seatrout, flounder, and snook. A mountain stream holds rainbow, brown, brook, and cutthroat trout. Knowing the shortlist before you go makes the key faster when you are there. Our Tide Height Calculator helps plan the timing for saltwater trips, and our Boat Fuel Cost and Range Calculator plans the run.

    Checking a catch before cooking. Identification comes before the fillet knife. Once you know the species, our Fish Fillet and Seafood Yield Calculator works out how much fillet a fish gives, and our Seafood Cooking Time Calculator gives times and temperatures. Our Sustainable Seafood Checker covers the sustainability of the species you keep.

    Matching tackle to the species. A fish identified is a fish you can rig for. Our Fishing Rod and Reel Finder matches rod and reel to the species you are after, and our Fly Fishing Leader and Tippet Calculator covers leader and tippet for trout and salmon.

    Identifying other wildlife. The same trait-based approach works beyond fish. Our Bird Identification Key narrows birds by size, color, beak, and habitat, and our Animal Track Identifier works from tracks and signs.

    What this key cannot do

    It covers 60 species, not every fish. The United States has hundreds of freshwater fish species and hundreds more inshore saltwater species. This key covers the 60 most commonly caught game fish. A fish outside that list will not match, even with every trait answered, and the key will say so rather than force a wrong name. Young fish of a listed species can also look different enough to miss: juvenile striped bass have faint vertical bars and stripes that may be faint or absent, and juvenile black drum lose their bars as they grow.

    It does not identify hybrids. Stocked waters hold hybrids that mix the traits of two species: the wiper, a striped bass crossed with a white bass, has broken stripes on a striped-bass body, and the saugeye, a walleye crossed with a sauger, has spots and bars in the dorsal fin and a variable tail tip. A hybrid usually lands as a near match with both parents at the top. If the key gives you a near match with two close relatives tied, a hybrid is worth considering.

    It does not replace your state guide. A key narrows; confirm with your state guide before keeping. Misidentification can mean an illegal keep, and size and bag limits change by state, by water, and by season. This key carries no limits, no seasons, and no regulations. Check the current rules for the water you are fishing before you keep anything.

    It does not work from color alone. Color is the least reliable trait in fish identification. The same species can look dark in clear water and pale in muddy water, and spawning males can change color in days. That is why this key asks about shape, mouth, fins, markings, and tail, and never about color. If the only thing you noticed was the color, answer the shape and fin questions and let the key work from those.

    It does not judge edibility or safety. Identification is not a food safety decision. Some waters carry consumption advisories for mercury or other contaminants, and some species are protected or catch-and-release only in some waters. Check your state health advisory and your state fishing regulations before eating a catch.

    Sources

    Trait values in this key were compiled from the Peterson Field Guide to Freshwater Fishes, state fish and wildlife agency identification guides, and NOAA Fisheries species profiles. The spot checks below were re-verified against the publisher's own page on 20 November 2026. Where sources disagreed, the resolution is recorded here and in the page register.

    • NOAA Fisheries: Atlantic Striped Bass (profile last updated 2 September 2026): seven to eight continuous horizontal stripes, two separated dorsal fins, large mouth, up to 5 feet long. Anadromous: lives in salt water and spawns in fresh water.
    • NOAA Fisheries: Summer Flounder (profile last updated 18 August 2026): flat body, at least five dark spots arranged in an X pattern, left-eyed flatfish with both eyes on the left side.
    • Texas Parks and Wildlife: Red Drum: the most distinguishing mark is one large black spot on the upper part of the tail base; multiple spots are not uncommon, no spots extremely rare.
    • Florida Museum: Red Drum: elongated body, blunt snout, sub-terminal mouth, two dorsal fins, maximum reported length 61 inches, more typically about 39 inches.
    • Chesapeake Bay Program: Red Drum: usually grows 20 to 30 inches, squared tail fin, one or more large black spots at the base of the tail.
    • Minnesota DNR: Walleye biology and identification: the walleye lacks spots on its dusky dorsal fin except for a dark splotch at the rear base, and the lower tip of its tail is white, unlike the all-dark lower lobe of the sauger; the sauger dorsal fin is marked by rows of dark spots.
    • Minnesota DNR: Crappie biology and identification: the black crappie has seven or eight spines in its dorsal fin; the white crappie often has markings arranged in vertical bars and usually has five or six dorsal spines.
    • Florida Fish and Wildlife: Summer Flounder: both eyes on the left side, several eye-like spots with at least five in an X pattern, wedge-shaped tail; southern flounder may have five or more spots but they are not eye-like.
    • Florida Fish and Wildlife: Largemouth bass are now Florida bass (17 July 2024): the American Fisheries Society established the Florida bass as a separate species; largemouth bass, previously Micropterus salmoides, became Micropterus nigricans.
    • Maryland DNR: Largemouth Bass Scientific Renaming: the 2023 American Fisheries Society list changed largemouth bass from Micropterus salmoides to Micropterus nigricans and Florida bass to Micropterus salmoides.

    Conflicts resolved at build, 20 November 2026. Largemouth bass scientific name: the 2023 American Fisheries Society 8th edition renamed it Micropterus nigricans, but a 2026 American Fisheries Society leadership comment in Fisheries holds that naming decision in abeyance and reverts to the 7th edition name, Micropterus salmoides, pending review. The 2026 comment governs, because it is the naming authority's own latest statement: this key uses Micropterus salmoides and notes the abeyance. Red drum typical length: the Florida Museum gives about 39 inches as typical, while the Chesapeake Bay Program gives usually 20 to 30 inches. The key uses a broad band, 16 to 40 inches, that covers both figures, and treats length as a soft trait. White crappie dorsal spines: the National Park Service says only 6, while the Minnesota DNR, the Oklahoma Department of Wildlife Conservation, the Washington Department of Fish and Wildlife, and the Kentucky Department of Fish and Wildlife Resources all say 5 or 6. The majority of state agencies governs: 5 or 6. Sauger scientific name: an older Minnesota DNR document uses Sander canadense; the current American Fisheries Society standard is Sander canadensis, which this key uses. Red drum scientific name: the Maryland DNR Fish Facts page spells it Sciaenops ocellatas; Texas Parks and Wildlife, the Florida Museum, and the International Game Fish Association all use Sciaenops ocellatus, which this key uses.

    Frequently asked questions

    What fish did I catch?

    Answer the seven questions in the key above: water type, body shape, mouth, dorsal fin, markings, tail shape, and length if you measured it. The key scores your answers against 60 common United States freshwater and inshore saltwater game fish and shows the five closest matches, with a match percentage and one distinguishing field mark for each. Most fish land on a single species once you answer four or five questions. If the key gives you a shortlist, it tells you which question separates the species left.

    How accurate is a trait-based fish key?

    A trait-based key is accurate when the traits are answered carefully, and honest when they are not. Each question is a real field mark from a state agency guide or a NOAA Fisheries profile, and the key shows its full working so you can check every step. But traits vary with age, sex, season, and water clarity, and some species differ by a single feature, such as the number of dorsal spines or the color of the gums. That is why every result carries a lookalike warning when the top match has a close relative, and why the key says "no exact match" rather than forcing a guess when the traits do not line up. Confirm the answer against your state fish guide before keeping the fish.

    Can I identify a fish from a photo instead?

    Photo identification apps exist, and they work well on a clear side view in good light. A trait-based key is the honest static version: it works without a photo, without an upload, and without a signal, and it shows its reasoning instead of a confidence score you cannot check. The two approaches complement each other. If a photo app names a species, run the key and see whether the traits agree. If they disagree, trust the traits you can see and measure, especially the jaw, the fins, and the tail, and confirm against your state guide.

    What is the difference between a largemouth bass and a spotted bass?

    Close the mouth and look at the jaw. On a largemouth bass, the upper jaw extends past the back of the eye. On a spotted bass, the jaw ends at the eye, and the fish has rows of small dark spots below the lateral line. A smallmouth bass also has a shorter jaw, ending at the middle of the eye, and dark vertical bars instead of a blotchy stripe. The jaw test works on fish of any size and does not depend on color, which is why guides print it first. The scientific name of the largemouth bass is Micropterus salmoides: a 2023 rename to Micropterus nigricans was held in abeyance by the American Fisheries Society in 2026.

    How do I tell a red drum from a black drum?

    Look for two things: the tail spot and the chin barbels. A red drum has one or more black spots at the base of the tail and no chin barbels. A black drum has chin barbels and no spot at the tail base. Young black drum also have vertical bars that fade as they grow, which is why a large black drum fools anglers more often than a small one. The two species share the same waters on the Atlantic and Gulf coasts and have different size and bag limits in several states, so the check matters before you keep one.

    Why does the key ask for length?

    Length breaks ties between species that share every other trait. A Florida pompano and a permit have the same water, body, mouth, dorsal fin, markings, and tail; the pompano is typically 10 to 16 inches and the permit is typically 16 to 28 inches, so a 12-inch fish is a pompano and a 20-inch fish is a permit. Length is optional, and leaving it blank never hurts the result. When you do enter it, the key treats it as a soft trait: a fish longer than its species band earns a warning instead of being ruled out, because the bands are typical adult catch sizes, not records.

    What should I do if the key finds no match?

    Re-check the traits, starting with the body shape and the mouth, which narrow the key the most. The most common misreads are a deep fish called torpedo-shaped, a joined dorsal fin called two separate fins, and a blotchy pattern called spots. The steps section shows exactly where the chain hit zero, which tells you which answer broke it. If the traits are right and the key still finds no match, the fish is probably not one of the 60 species in the key: the United States has hundreds of freshwater fish species, and this key covers the 60 most commonly caught game fish. Check your state fish guide for the full list.

    Do I need a fishing license to keep the fish I identify?

    Almost always, yes. Every state requires a fishing license for anglers above a certain age, with exemptions that vary by state, and most states set size limits, bag limits, and seasons that vary by species and by water. This key carries no limits, seasons, or regulations, and it cannot tell you whether a fish is legal to keep. Confirm the current rules for the water you are fishing with your state fish and wildlife agency before you keep anything. Our Fishing Regulations and Catch Limits Checker covers size and bag limits for popular species by state, as a starting point, not as a substitute for the official rules.