Skip to content

Subscription Box Value Calculator

Stitch Fix works differently from a box you keep whole: you pay a styling fee, keep some items, and return the rest. Pick Stitch Fix for its own calculation.

The price per box, before shipping and tax. For an annual plan, use the per-box price: $64.99 for FabFitFun Annual, not the $259.96 yearly bill.

Add up the retail price of each item in the box, using prices you can check on the brand's own site. This is your number, not the box's claim: the value ratio is only as honest as the retail values you enter.

Leave blank to count everything. If some items will sit in a drawer, add up only the ones you will use: that is the honest value of the box to you, and it cannot be more than the retail value above.

Whole number, 1 to 52. Monthly boxes are 12 a year, seasonal boxes are 4, quarterly boxes are 4.

Enter 0 when shipping is free. Ipsy charges $1.99 shipping per bag in the US.

Enter 0 when no tax is charged. Use the tax on your last box if your state charges it.

Whole number, 0 to 100. Leave blank if you do not want a per-item cost. FabFitFun sends 6 items a box, BarkBox sends 5, Ipsy sends 5.

Presets (prices checked 20 November 2026)

Presets fill in the price and schedule. The retail value is yours to enter: it is the number the answer depends on. Preset prices were checked on 20 November 2026 on each retailer's own pricing page; box prices change quarterly, so check your checkout and overwrite any preset.

Worked examples

Your box, valued honestly

How the numbers were worked out

      This tool estimates whether a subscription box is worth it from the program prices and the numbers you enter, for general guidance only. It is not financial advice. Box prices change quarterly, and the value ratio is only as honest as the retail values you enter, so check the current price on the retailer's own site and price the items yourself before acting on a figure here.
      A subscription box is worth it when the items you will actually use are worth more than the full cost of the box, shipping and tax included. Divide the usable value by the cost: 2.00 or more is excellent, 1.00 about breaks even, and below 0.75 is poor. A FabFitFun Seasonal box at $79.99 with $214.99 of items used returns 2.69 times its cost, while a BarkBox at $24 with $28 of items used returns 1.17. For Stitch Fix, the saving is the 20 percent discount for keeping 5 or more items on a Women's or Men's Fix, or the whole Fix on a Kids Fix: keeping fewer saves nothing against full price, and keeping 4 can cost more than keeping 5. Enter your box above for the honest ratio and the annual cost.

      Last reviewed: 20 November 2026. Presets reviewed quarterly; next review due 19 February 2027.

      How to use the Subscription Box Value Calculator

      Every subscription box makes the same promise: pay one price, get back much more in products. FabFitFun says each seasonal box is worth up to $350. Ipsy says its Extra bag holds up to $200 of full-size beauty products. BarkBox fills a box with toys and treats every month. The promise is easy to print and hard to check, because the number that matters is not the value the box claims: it is the value of the items you will actually use, divided by the money that actually leaves your account, shipping and tax included. This calculator does that division for you, for any box, and it does a separate calculation for Stitch Fix, where the mechanics are different: a styling fee, 5 to 8 items to try, and a 20% discount when you keep 5 or more of them, or the whole Fix on a Kids account.

      The calculator has two modes. Pick the one that matches your box before you enter anything.

      1. Regular subscription box. Use this for FabFitFun, BarkBox, Ipsy, and any other box you keep whole: you pay per box and everything inside is yours. Enter the price you pay for one box, the total retail value of the items inside it, and the value of the items you will actually use. Add shipping and tax per box if they apply, the number of boxes you get in a year, and the number of items in the box if you want a per-item cost.
      2. Stitch Fix. Use this for a Fix. Enter how many items the Fix holds (5 to 8), whether it is a Women's, Men's, or Kids Fix, how many items you kept, the total price of the items you kept, the styling fee for the Fix, and how many Fixes you get in a year. Tick the waived-fee box if Stitch Fix waived the fee on your first Fix. If you kept 4 items, enter the price of the next item as well: the calculator shows whether keeping 5 would have cost less than keeping 4, because the 20% discount applies to the whole kept total.

      To get your result in box mode, follow these steps:

      1. Enter the price you pay for one box. This is the per-box price, before shipping and tax. For an annual plan, divide the yearly bill by the number of boxes: FabFitFun Annual is $259.96 a year for four boxes, which is $64.99 a box, and that is the number to enter. For a monthly box, the price per box is the monthly price.
      2. Enter the total retail value of the items in one box. Add up the retail price of each item, using prices you can check on the brand's own site. This is your number, not the box's claim. If FabFitFun says a box is worth up to $350, that figure is the top of a range across many possible boxes, and your box may be worth less. Use the prices of the items you actually received.
      3. Enter the value of the items you will actually use. This is the field that makes the answer honest. A $38 body butter you will never open is worth $0 to you, whatever its price tag says. Add up only the items you will use, and leave the field blank if you will use everything: the calculator then counts the full retail value. The usable value cannot be more than the retail value.
      4. Enter shipping and tax per box, and boxes a year. Shipping and tax are part of the cost, and they change the answer more than people expect: Ipsy charges $1.99 shipping per bag in the US, which adds $23.88 to a year of monthly bags. Monthly boxes are 12 a year, seasonal and quarterly boxes are 4.
      5. Enter the number of items if you want a per-item cost. This is optional. It turns the answer into a cost per item, which is the easiest way to compare a box with buying the same things one by one.

      The preset buttons fill in the price and schedule for the four best-known boxes: FabFitFun Annual and Seasonal, FabFitFun Beauty Edit, BarkBox Classic on the 12-month and month-to-month plans, Super Chewer on the 12-month plan, Ipsy Original, Extra, and Ultimate, and Stitch Fix. Every preset price was checked on 20 November 2026 on the retailer's own pricing page, and the note under the buttons says so. Presets never fill in the retail value: that is your number, and it is the number the answer depends on. Box prices change quarterly, so check your checkout and overwrite any preset that no longer matches what you pay.

      Try the example buttons under the form. The first is a FabFitFun Seasonal box at $79.99 with $214.99 of items, all of them used: the value ratio is 2.69 and the box saves $135.00. The second is a BarkBox at $24 a box with $40 of retail value, of which the dog will use $28: the claimed ratio is 1.67, the honest ratio is 1.17, and the box barely breaks even. The third is an Ipsy Extra bag at $32 plus $1.99 shipping with $152 of retail value, of which $95 will be used: the honest ratio is 2.79. The fourth is a Stitch Fix keep-5: five items worth $320, a $20 fee, $256 paid in total. The fifth is a Stitch Fix keep-4: four items worth $260, with a $60 next item that turns out to be cheaper to keep than to send back. The sixth is a Stitch Fix 5-of-8: an 8-item Fix where keeping 5 items worth $400 earns the discount and costs $320 in total.

      Read the full result, not just the headline. The headline leads with the cost per box and the usable value, and the honest ratio between them. The cards show the value ratio, the honest ratio, the honest saving per box, the verdict, the cost per box, the annual cost, the honest saving a year, and the discount on usable value. The table puts the same figures per box and per year side by side. The detail box explains the two ratios and, for Stitch Fix, the line-by-line cost of the Fix. The guidance explains the result in plain language, the warnings flag the traps (a box that looks like a deal at claimed value but loses on usable value, a styling fee partly wasted), and the steps print the full working so you can check every figure.

      How it works

      The calculator runs one of two calculations, depending on the mode. The box calculation answers three questions: how much does one box really cost, how much value does it really hold, and how do those two numbers compare over a year. The Stitch Fix calculation answers a different set: what did the Fix actually cost once the fee and the discount are counted, how much did you save against the full price of the clothes, and was keeping one more item the cheaper move.

      The box calculation: cost, value, and two ratios

      The cost of one box is the price plus shipping plus tax. That sounds obvious, but most box marketing quotes the price alone, and the gap matters: a $15 Ipsy Original bag is $16.99 once the $1.99 shipping is added, and a $32 Extra bag is $33.99. Over a year, the shipping alone on a monthly Ipsy bag is $23.88. The calculator counts the full cost, because the full cost is what leaves your account.

      The value of one box is counted twice. The first count is the retail value: the sum of the retail prices of everything in the box. The second count is the usable value: the sum of the retail prices of only the items you will actually use. The value ratio is the retail value divided by the cost. The honest ratio is the usable value divided by the cost. A box with a value ratio of 2.69 gives back $2.69 of retail value for every dollar you pay. A box with an honest ratio of 1.17 gives back $1.17 of value you will use for every dollar you pay. The honest ratio is the one to judge the box by, because the rest of the retail value never reaches you: it sits in a drawer.

      The saving per box is the value minus the cost, counted both ways: saved against retail, and saved on the items you will use. The discount percent is the saving divided by the value, as a percent. A box that costs $79.99 and holds $214.99 of items saves $135.00, which is 62.79% off the retail price. The same box counted honestly, with $214.99 of usable value, saves the same $135.00. But a box that costs $24, holds $40 of retail value, and holds $28 of usable value saves $16.00 against retail (40.00% off) and only $4.00 honestly (14.29% off). The two discounts tell different stories, and the honest one is the true one.

      The annual figures multiply the per-box figures by the number of boxes a year: annual cost, annual retail value, annual usable value, annual saving against retail, and annual honest saving. The per-item figures divide by the number of items: cost per item, retail value per item, usable value per item. The break-even retail value is the cost itself: a box breaks even when its usable value equals what you paid. The shortfall is how much more usable value a losing box would need in each box to break even.

      The verdict follows the honest ratio, tested on the unrounded value, never on the rounded display: 2.00 or more is excellent, 1.50 to 1.99 is good, 1.00 to 1.49 breaks even, 0.75 to 0.99 is weak, and below 0.75 is poor. A box with no usable value at all gets its own verdict, because no ratio can rescue it. The threshold is tested on the raw ratio on purpose: a box with a raw honest ratio of 1.4998 shows as 1.50 on screen but still breaks even rather than rating good, because it has not actually crossed the line.

      The Stitch Fix calculation: fee, discount, and one more item

      Stitch Fix is not a box you keep whole. You pay a $20 styling fee per Fix, a stylist sends 5 to 8 items, you try them at home, you keep what you want and return the rest in a prepaid bag. The fee is credited against anything you keep. If you keep 5 or more items on a Women's or Men's Fix, or the whole Fix on a Kids Fix, you get 20% off the clothes you keep. Shipping, returns, and exchanges are free. The calculator follows that exact sequence. The discount used to be 25%: it was still 25% in August 2026, when a published review kept 6 items and saw the total fall from $336.47 to $252.35, and Stitch Fix cut it to 20% between August and November 2026. The calculator follows the current 20% from Stitch Fix's own support article, and the old 25% figure survives only on stale coupon pages and in the first-order promotion on Stitch Fix's own offer page, which is a different offer and is not modeled here.

      First, the discount: if you kept 5 or more items on a Women's or Men's Fix, or the whole Fix on a Kids Fix, 20% comes off the total price of the kept items. On $320 of clothes, the discount is $64.00 and the clothes cost $256.00 after the discount. If you kept fewer, no discount applies at all: there is no partial discount for keeping 4. Keeping 5 of an 8-item Fix earns the discount too: 5 items worth $400 from an 8-item Fix take $80.00 off, leaving $320.00. A Kids Fix is different: keeping 5 of an 8-item Kids Fix earns no discount, because the Kids rule needs the whole Fix kept.

      Second, the fee credit: the $20 styling fee you already paid is credited against the discounted total, up to the amount of that total. If the discounted total is $256.00, the full $20 is credited and $236.00 is due at checkout. If the discounted total is only $12.00, because you kept a single $12 kids item, only $12.00 of the fee can be credited and $8.00 of the fee is lost: you paid $20.00 in total for a $12.00 item. The fee is never refunded beyond the price of what you keep, and it is not refunded at all when you keep nothing.

      Third, the total: the fee plus the checkout amount. When the fee is fully credited, the total equals the discounted price of the clothes: $256.00 on a $320 keep-5 Fix, $110.00 on a $110 keep-2 Fix. That is why keeping fewer than 5 items without the discount saves exactly nothing against buying the same clothes at full price: the fee comes back as credit, so the service costs nothing, but the clothes cost their full price. The saving exists in only one place: the 20% discount. It cannot also come from the fee credit covering more than the discounted total leaves to pay, because the credit is capped at that total.

      Fourth, the next item: if you kept 4 items, the calculator prices the alternative of keeping 5. It adds the next item's price to the kept total, takes 20% off the new total, credits the fee, and compares the new total with what you actually paid. The comparison usually surprises people, because the 20% discount applies to the four items you already kept as well as the fifth: keeping a $60 fifth item on a $260 keep-4 Fix brings the Fix total from $260.00 down to $256.00, which is $4.00 less than keeping 4, and you get the fifth item as well. The calculator reports the extra cost (negative when keeping 5 is cheaper), the saving against buying the next item separately at full price, and whether keeping 5 is the cheaper move. For a Kids Fix of more than 5 items, keeping a fifth item does not earn the discount, and the calculator says so: it prices the item at full price against keeping 4.

      Worked example 1: FabFitFun Seasonal, everything used

      A FabFitFun Seasonal box at $79.99, with $214.99 of items at retail, all of them used, 4 boxes a year, 6 items a box. The retail figure is from a published Spring 2026 unboxing, where the box held $214.99 of products for its $79.99 cost.

      • Cost of one box: $79.99 price, no shipping, no tax, so $79.99.
      • Value ratio: $214.99 / $79.99 = 2.69. Honest ratio: the same 2.69, because all of it will be used.
      • Saved per box: $214.99 - $79.99 = $135.00, which is 62.79% off retail.
      • Over a year: 4 boxes cost $319.96 and hold $859.96 of items, saving $540.00.
      • Per item: $13.33 cost against $35.83 of retail value, across 6 items.
      • Verdict: excellent. The box returns more than twice what it costs in items the subscriber will use.

      The same box on the Annual plan, at $64.99 a box with $250.00 of items, is stronger still: a ratio of 3.85, $185.01 saved per box, $259.96 a year for $1,000.00 of items, saving $740.04 a year, at $10.83 per item. The annual plan saves $60.00 a year against four seasonal boxes ($319.96 against $259.96) before any difference in box contents.

      Worked example 2: BarkBox, the dog ignores a toy

      A BarkBox Classic on the 12-month plan at $24.00 a box, with $40.00 of retail value in the box, of which $28.00 will be used: the dog ignores one toy and a bag of treats it does not like. Twelve boxes a year, 5 items a box.

      • Cost of one box: $24.00 price, free shipping, no tax, so $24.00.
      • Value ratio: $40.00 / $24.00 = 1.67. Honest ratio: $28.00 / $24.00 = 1.17.
      • Saved per box: $16.00 against retail (40.00% off), but only $4.00 honestly (14.29% off).
      • Over a year: 12 boxes cost $288.00 and hold $480.00 of retail value, but only $336.00 of usable value, saving $48.00 honestly against $192.00 at claimed value.
      • Per item: $4.80 cost against $8.00 of retail value and $5.60 of usable value.
      • Verdict: breaks even. The box is worth keeping only if the owner would buy those toys and treats anyway.

      This example is the reason the calculator asks what you will use. At claimed value the box looks like a 40% saving. Honestly, it is a $4.00 saving per box, and one more ignored toy would push it under water: at $24.00 of usable value the honest ratio is exactly 1.00, and below that the box loses money.

      Worked example 3: Ipsy Extra, shipping counted

      An Ipsy Extra bag at $32.00 plus $1.99 shipping, with $152.00 of retail value, of which $95.00 will be used. Twelve bags a year, 5 full-size products a bag. The $152.00 figure is the reported value of a December 2026 Extra bag.

      • Cost of one bag: $32.00 price plus $1.99 shipping, so $33.99.
      • Value ratio: $152.00 / $33.99 = 4.47. Honest ratio: $95.00 / $33.99 = 2.79.
      • Saved per bag: $118.01 against retail (77.64% off), and $61.01 honestly (64.22% off).
      • Over a year: 12 bags cost $407.88 and hold $1,824.00 of retail value, $1,140.00 of it usable, saving $732.12 honestly.
      • Per item: $6.80 cost against $30.40 of retail value and $19.00 of usable value.
      • Verdict: excellent. Even after shipping and after discarding $57.00 of products, the bag returns nearly three times its cost in products the subscriber will use.

      The shipping matters here in a way it does not for FabFitFun or BarkBox, because both of those ship free in the contiguous US. On Ipsy, the $1.99 per bag is $23.88 a year, and the calculator counts it. A member who forgets the shipping overstates the ratio: $152.00 / $32.00 is 4.75, not 4.47.

      Worked example 4: a box that loses money

      A monthly box at $35.00, with $30.00 of retail value, of which $18.00 will be used. Twelve boxes a year, 5 items a box.

      • Cost of one box: $35.00.
      • Value ratio: $30.00 / $35.00 = 0.86. Honest ratio: $18.00 / $35.00 = 0.51.
      • Saved per box: -$5.00 against retail, and -$17.00 honestly. The box costs more than the value inside it, before the drawer is even counted.
      • Over a year: 12 boxes cost $420.00 and hold $216.00 of usable value, which is $204.00 less value than the money paid.
      • Per item: $7.00 cost against $6.00 of retail value and $3.60 of usable value.
      • Shortfall: each box would need $17.00 more of usable value to break even.
      • Verdict: poor. Less than three quarters of what is paid comes back as items the subscriber will use.

      Boxes like this exist, and they survive because the subscriber never does the arithmetic. The monthly charge is small enough to ignore, the box is fun to open, and the retail values are never added up. The calculator exists for exactly this box.

      Worked example 5: Stitch Fix, keep 5 of 5

      A Fix with 5 items kept, worth $320.00 in total, a $20.00 styling fee, 4 Fixes a year.

      • Fix discount: 20% of $320.00 is $64.00, so the clothes cost $256.00 after the discount.
      • Fee credit: the $20.00 fee is fully credited against the $256.00, so $236.00 is due at checkout and none of the fee is lost.
      • Total paid: $20.00 fee plus $236.00 at checkout, which is $256.00.
      • Saved against the full price: $320.00 - $256.00 = $64.00, which is 20.00% off.
      • Cost per kept item: $256.00 / 5 = $51.20.
      • Over a year: 4 Fixes cost $1,024.00 and save $256.00 against the full price of the clothes.
      • Verdict: Fix discount earned.

      This is the only Stitch Fix outcome where the service pays you back. The 20% discount is the whole saving: the fee credit only returns your own money. The same Fix at the old 25% rate would have cost $240.00 and saved $80.00: the cut from 25% to 20% costs $16.00 on a Fix like this one.

      Worked example 6: Stitch Fix, keep 2 of 5

      A Fix with 2 items kept, worth $110.00 in total, a $20.00 styling fee, 4 Fixes a year.

      • Fix discount: none, because only 2 items were kept, and the discount needs 5 or more. The clothes cost $110.00.
      • Fee credit: the $20.00 fee is fully credited against the $110.00, so $90.00 is due at checkout and none of the fee is lost.
      • Total paid: $20.00 fee plus $90.00 at checkout, which is $110.00.
      • Saved against the full price: $0.00. The effective discount is 0.00%.
      • Cost per kept item: $110.00 / 2 = $55.00, exactly the average price tag.
      • Over a year: 4 Fixes cost $440.00, the same as buying the same clothes at full price.
      • Verdict: paid full price.

      This is the normal Stitch Fix outcome, and it surprises most people. Keeping some items is not a bad deal: the styling costs nothing, because the fee comes back as credit. But it is not a saving either. The clothes cost what they cost. The only way Stitch Fix beats buying the same clothes yourself is the 20% discount for keeping 5 or more items, or the whole Fix on a Kids account.

      Worked example 7: Stitch Fix, keep 4, and the next item

      A Fix with 4 items kept, worth $260.00 in total, a $20.00 styling fee, and a fifth item worth $60.00 that was sent back. Four Fixes a year.

      • Keeping 4: no discount, the $20.00 fee fully credited, $240.00 due at checkout, $260.00 paid in total, $0.00 saved.
      • Keeping 5: the kept total becomes $320.00, the 20% discount is $64.00, the clothes cost $256.00 after the discount, the $20.00 fee is credited, $236.00 is due at checkout, and the total paid is $256.00.
      • Extra cost of keeping 5: $256.00 - $260.00 = -$4.00. Keeping the fifth item costs $4.00 less than sending it back.
      • Saving against buying the fifth item separately at full price: $60.00 - (-$4.00) = $64.00.
      • Verdict: keeping 5 is the cheaper move.

      The arithmetic feels wrong until you see it: the 20% discount applies to the four items you already kept, not just the fifth. On the $320.00 total, the discount is $64.00, which pays for the $60.00 fifth item and leaves $4.00 over. The same logic holds when the fifth item is expensive: with a $200.00 fifth item on the same $260.00 keep-4 Fix, keeping 5 costs $368.00 against $260.00, which is $108.00 more for a $200.00 item, saving $92.00 against buying it separately at full price. At the old 25% rate the $60.00 fifth item would have saved $20.00 rather than $4.00: the discount cut narrowed the win, but it is still a win.

      Worked example 8: Stitch Fix, the fee eats the saving

      A kids Fix with 1 item kept, worth $12.00, a $20.00 styling fee, 4 Fixes a year. Kids items at Stitch Fix start at about $12.00, so this is a real case, not a corner case.

      • Fix discount: none, because only 1 item was kept, and a Kids Fix needs the whole Fix kept.
      • Fee credit: only $12.00 of the $20.00 fee can be credited against a $12.00 total, so $8.00 of the fee is lost and $0.00 is due at checkout.
      • Total paid: $20.00, for $12.00 of clothes.
      • Saved against the full price: $12.00 - $20.00 = -$8.00, which is -66.67%.
      • Cost per kept item: $20.00.
      • Over a year: 4 Fixes cost $80.00, which is $32.00 more than the full price of the clothes.
      • Verdict: paid over full price.

      The lesson is about small Fixes. The styling fee is a flat $20.00, so it bites hardest when the kept total is small. A $12.00 kids item is the worst case: the fee is bigger than the purchase. Keep at least $20.00 of clothes in every Fix, or the fee stops being a credit and starts being a charge.

      The four preset boxes, priced and compared

      All prices below were checked on 20 November 2026 on each retailer's own pricing page, or on the retailer's published terms where the pricing page sits behind a sign-up wall. Box prices change quarterly, and some retailers show different prices to different visitors during promotions, so treat every figure as a dated starting point and check your checkout. The next preset review is 19 February 2027.

      FabFitFun: seasonal, four boxes a year

      FabFitFun ships four times a year, one box a season, with six full-size products the member chooses from a menu of more than 100 options. The regular prices in FabFitFun's Membership Terms, last updated 15 July 2026, are $79.99 a box on the Seasonal plan, billed each season, and $259.96 a year on the Annual plan, which is $64.99 a box prepaid. The Annual plan saves $60.00 a year against four seasonal boxes. The Beauty Edit Box is a separate monthly box at $29.99 a month with four full-size beauty products, and the PupBox Edit is $34.99 a month. Shipping is free in the contiguous US. FabFitFun says each seasonal box is worth up to $350 at retail; the Spring 2026 box reviewed by My Subscription Addiction held $214.99 of products. First-box offers run below the regular rates for one season, and a Black Friday bonus box is offered with new Annual memberships in November 2026, so the price at checkout can sit below the regular rates for one season. The calculator's presets use the regular rates, not the offers.

      FabFitFun planPriceBoxes a yearAnnual costItems a box
      Seasonal$79.99 a box4$319.966
      Annual$64.99 a box4$259.966
      Beauty Edit Box$29.99 a month12$359.884
      PupBox Edit$34.99 a month12$419.88Not published

      BarkBox: monthly, cheaper on longer plans

      BarkBox is a monthly box of two toys, two bags of treats, and a chew, with a theme each month. Super Chewer is the version for dogs that destroy soft toys, with rubber and nylon toys and two chews. Pricing depends on plan length, and BarkBox's own FAQ puts the starting price at $24 a month for Classic and $29 a month for Super Chewer, on the 12-month plan. Current listings checked in October 2026 show $24 a box on the 12-month Classic plan and $27 on the 6-month plan, and $29 and $35 for Super Chewer. The month-to-month rate is $35 for Classic and $39 for Super Chewer. Shipping is included. Some secondary sources still quote $22 to $23 for the 12-month Classic plan from earlier in 2026, and BarkBox shows different prices to different visitors during promotions, so the FAQ figure governs the presets and the calculator says so. Prepaid gift subscriptions cost more per box than the subscription itself: $294 for 12 months of Classic, which is $24.50 a box, and $360 for Super Chewer, which is $30.00 a box. A BarkBox Lite plan starts at $19.99 a month for Classic and $24.99 for Super Chewer, with fewer items. BarkBox does not publish a claimed retail value per box; reviewers estimate a typical Classic box at $35 to $40 of toys and treats at retail.

      BarkBox planClassic per boxSuper Chewer per boxClassic annual cost
      Month to month$35$39$420
      6-month plan$27$35$324
      12-month plan$24$29$288
      12-month gift, prepaid$24.50$30.00$294

      Ipsy: renamed tiers, shipping on top

      Ipsy renamed its plans in 2026, and the old names still float around. The Glam Bag is now Ipsy Original: five deluxe-size samples in a makeup bag, $15 a month plus $1.99 US shipping, or $171 a year prepaid with shipping included. BoxyCharm is now Ipsy Extra: five full-size products, $32 a month plus $1.99 shipping. The Icon Box, formerly Glam Bag X, is now Ipsy Ultimate: eight full-size products for $65 a quarter, an upgrade for existing members that replaces the regular bag in February, May, August, and November. Ipsy Wellness is a quarterly box of four products for $65. Ipsy puts the stated value at up to $70 for Original, up to $200 for Extra, and up to $400 for Ultimate. The annual prepaid Original at $171 saves $32.88 against twelve monthly bags at $16.99, which is $203.88. A member on Extra who adds Ultimate pays eight months of Extra at $33.99, which is $271.92, plus four quarters of Ultimate at $65.00, which is $260.00, for $531.92 a year before any shipping on the Ultimate quarters.

      Ipsy planFormerlyPriceStated valueItems
      OriginalGlam Bag$15 a month plus $1.99 shippingUp to $705 deluxe samples
      Original, annual prepayGlam Bag$171 a year, shipping includedUp to $70 a bag5 deluxe samples
      ExtraBoxyCharm$32 a month plus $1.99 shippingUp to $2005 full-size products
      UltimateIcon Box, Glam Bag X$65 a quarterUp to $4008 full-size products
      WellnessNew in 2026$65 a quarterNot published4 products

      Stitch Fix: a fee, not a box price

      Stitch Fix has no box price. Each Fix costs a $20 styling fee, credited against anything you keep, and the clothes cost their price tags, less 20% if you keep 5 or more items on a Women's or Men's Fix, or the whole Fix on a Kids Fix. Fixes hold 5 to 8 items, and you choose the size before your stylist picks. Women's and men's items start at around $32 and run to about $500; kids items start at about $12. Shipping, returns, and exchanges are always free, and there is no subscription required: Fixes can be scheduled every two to three weeks, monthly, every other month, or every three months, or ordered on demand. The try-on window is three days after delivery. First-Fix offers waive the styling fee and add a discount, so the calculator lets the fee be waived with a checkbox. Stitch Fix's own offer page currently advertises 25% off the first order with a promo code and a waived styling fee: that is a first-order promotion, limited in time and not combinable with other offers, not the keep discount, and the calculator does not model it. The keep discount itself was 25% as recently as August 2026 and Stitch Fix cut it to 20% between August and November 2026; the calculator follows the current 20% from Stitch Fix's own support article. Some coupon pages still headline 25% off for keeping items: those pages are stale, and Stitch Fix's own pages govern.

      How to value the items in your box honestly

      The calculator is only as honest as the retail values you enter, so this section is the most important one on the page. A value ratio built on inflated retail prices is a comforting fiction, and subscription boxes are very good at supplying inflated retail prices.

      Use the price you would actually pay. If a brand lists a serum at $68 but sells it at $48 on its own site most of the year, the honest retail value is $48, not $68. If a product is only ever sold as part of a set, use the set price divided by the number of items, not a made-up single-item price. If you would never buy the item at any price, its value to you is $0, whatever the tag says: put it in the retail total if you want the claimed ratio, and leave it out of the usable value.

      Price samples by size, not by the full-size price. Ipsy Original sends deluxe samples, not full sizes. A deluxe sample that is a third of a full-size bottle is worth a third of the full-size price, not the full price. This is the single biggest source of inflated box values in beauty boxes: counting five samples at five full-size prices. The calculator does not know your sample sizes, so do the division yourself before you enter the retail value.

      Count the bag, the box, and the packaging at $0. Ipsy sends a new makeup bag every month. FabFitFun boxes arrive in branded packaging. Neither is worth anything unless you would buy it separately, and you would not. Box companies sometimes list a value for the bag; the calculator has no field for it, and that is deliberate.

      Value pet items at what the dog uses. A BarkBox toy the dog ignores for a week is worth $0, even if the same toy sells for $14 in a pet store. Treats the dog will not eat are worth $0. The usable value of a BarkBox is the toys the dog plays with plus the treats the dog eats, priced at the pet-store price. Our Dog Food Portion Cost Calculator works out the other side of the same budget: what the dog costs to feed each month.

      Do not count resale value unless you actually resell. Some subscribers sell unwanted box items, and resale is real money when it happens. But most unwanted items sit in a drawer, and listing, packing, and shipping a $15 item for $8 after fees is a hobby, not a saving. If you do resell regularly, count the net amount you receive, after fees and postage, as usable value. If you do not, count the item at $0.

      Re-check every quarter. Box contents vary by season, and a box that was excellent value in the spring can be poor value in the fall. Run the box through the calculator each time it arrives, with that box's actual contents, and cancel the quarter the honest ratio drops below 1.00 and stays there. A subscription is a habit, and habits are what the annual cost column is for: a $24 box is $288 a year, and $288 a year deserves a yearly check.

      Features

      The calculator is built around the two numbers that decide whether a box is worth it, and it keeps them separate: the claimed value and the honest value. The value ratio uses the retail value you enter. The honest ratio uses only the items you will use. The verdict follows the honest ratio, on the unrounded value, so a box that shows 1.50 but computes to 1.4998 still breaks even rather than rating good.

      Both modes carry their own full calculation. Box mode counts shipping and tax in the cost, works out the saving per box and per year, the discount percent on claimed and usable value, the cost per item, the break-even value, and the shortfall to break even. Stitch Fix mode follows the real sequence of a Fix: the 20% discount first, then the fee credit capped at the discounted total, then the checkout amount, then the total paid, then the saving against full price, and finally the keep-5 comparison for anyone who kept 4 items. The comparison is the feature most Stitch Fix customers need and no other calculator offers: it prices the next item honestly, including the cases where keeping it costs less than sending it back, and it knows the Kids rule, where keeping a fifth item of a larger Fix earns no discount at all.

      Presets cover the four best-known boxes with prices checked on 20 November 2026: FabFitFun Annual, Seasonal, and Beauty Edit; BarkBox Classic and Super Chewer; Ipsy Original, Extra, and Ultimate; and Stitch Fix. Presets fill in the price and schedule, never the retail value, and every preset carries its verification date in the note under the buttons. The worked examples fill in complete scenarios, including the two Stitch Fix cases, so the shape of each answer is one click away.

      Every result prints its full working as numbered steps, so any figure can be checked by hand. The warnings flag the three traps that cost subscribers money: a box that looks like a deal at claimed value but loses on usable value, a styling fee partly wasted on a small Fix, and a keep-4 Fix where the next item was never priced. The annual cost is always shown next to the per-box cost, because a small monthly charge is easy to ignore and a $407.88 annual charge is not.

      Use cases

      Deciding whether to keep a box. Run the last box you received through the calculator with its actual contents. If the honest ratio is below 1.00 for two boxes in a row, cancel: you are paying more than the usable value you get back. If it is above 1.50, keep it: the box is earning its place.

      Choosing between plans. FabFitFun Annual at $64.99 a box against Seasonal at $79.99 is a $60.00-a-year question, and the calculator answers it in one run each: same contents, different price, different ratio. BarkBox 12-month at $24 against month-to-month at $35 is a $132.00-a-year question. Ipsy Original annual prepay at $171 against monthly at $203.88 is a $32.88 question. Run both plans with the same retail value and compare the honest ratios.

      Checking an unboxing claim. Unboxing videos and reviews quote a retail value for each box. Enter the box price and the quoted value, then cut the value down to what you would use: the gap between the two ratios is the gap between the video and your life.

      Deciding whether to keep one more Stitch Fix item. Enter the kept total and the next item's price. If the extra cost is negative, keeping 5 is cheaper than keeping 4: take the item. If the extra cost is positive but smaller than the item's price, keeping 5 is still cheaper than buying the item separately later. On a Kids Fix of more than 5 items, keeping a fifth item earns no discount, so the extra cost is the item's full price and the answer is about whether you want the item, not about the discount.

      Budgeting the year. Add up the annual cost of every box you subscribe to. Three boxes at $24, $33.99, and $64.99 a quarter cost $288.00, $407.88, and $259.96 a year: $955.84 in total. The calculator shows the annual figure for each box so the total is one addition away. Our Beauty Rewards Value Calculator prices the loyalty points those same beauty purchases earn, and our Discount Calculator checks a sale price before you buy the same items outside a box.

      Comparing a box with buying direct. The cost per item is the comparison number. A FabFitFun box at $13.33 an item against $35.83 of retail value per item beats buying direct by a wide margin, as long as the items are ones you would buy. A BarkBox at $4.80 an item against $5.60 of usable value per item barely beats buying the same toys and treats one by one, and one more ignored toy would tip it the other way.

      What the calculator does not do

      The calculator values a box on the numbers you enter. It does not check retail prices for you, and it cannot tell whether a claimed retail value is real: that is your judgment, and the honesty section above is the guide. It does not track prices over time, and it does not connect to any retailer: the presets are static figures with a verification date, refreshed quarterly, and the next review is 19 February 2027.

      The box calculation assumes every box in the year holds the same value as the one you entered. Real boxes vary by season, so the annual figures are an estimate built on one box, not a promise about the next three. Run each new box through the calculator when it arrives.

      The Stitch Fix calculation does not model sales tax on kept items, which depends on your state, or referral credits, or first-Fix discounts beyond the styling fee waiver, which you model with the waived-fee checkbox. It does not model the first-order 25% promo code on Stitch Fix's offer page: that is a limited-time promotion, not the keep discount. It does not model exchanges: an exchanged item is treated as kept at its original price. It does not model Freestyle purchases, which are direct shopping without a styling fee.

      The calculator gives general guidance, not financial advice. A value ratio above 1.00 means the box returns more value than it costs on your numbers; it does not mean the spending is wise. A box you do not need is still spending, however good the ratio.

      Sources

      All preset prices were verified on 20 November 2026. FabFitFun prices come from FabFitFun's own Membership Terms, last updated 15 July 2026, which set the Seasonal plan at $79.99 a season, the Annual plan at $259.96 a year, the Beauty Edit Box at $29.99 a month, and the PupBox Edit at $34.99 a month, and from FabFitFun's plans page as checked in November 2026. The Spring 2026 box retail value of $214.99 comes from a published unboxing of that box. BarkBox prices come from BARK's own FAQ, which puts the starting price at $24 a month for Classic and $29 for Super Chewer, and from current listings checked in October 2026 showing $24 and $27 for Classic on the 12-month and 6-month plans and $29 and $35 for Super Chewer; the month-to-month rates of $35 and $39 and the gift prices of $294 and $360 come from the same checks. Ipsy prices come from ipsy.com as listed in November 2026: Original $15 a month plus $1.99 shipping or $171 a year prepaid, Extra $32 a month plus $1.99 shipping, Ultimate $65 a quarter, Wellness $65 a quarter, with stated values up to $70, $200, and $400. Stitch Fix mechanics come from stitchfix.com and Stitch Fix's own support article "How the Fix discount works": a $20 styling fee per Fix, credited against anything you keep, 20% off when you keep 5 or more items on a Women's or Men's Fix or the entire Fix on a Kids Fix, free shipping, returns, and exchanges, women's and men's items from about $32 to about $500, and kids items from about $12. The 25% figure on Stitch Fix's offer page is a first-order promotion with a promo code, not the keep discount; the keep discount itself was 25% in August 2026 and Stitch Fix cut it to 20% between August and November 2026.

      External sources consulted for this page:

      Frequently asked questions

      How do I work out whether my subscription box is worth it?

      Divide the value of the items by the full cost of the box, shipping and tax included. A FabFitFun Seasonal box at $79.99 holding $214.99 of items has a value ratio of 2.69 and saves $135.00. Then do the same division using only the items you will actually use: that honest ratio is the one that matters, because items that sit in a drawer are worth $0 to you whatever their price tag says. Enter your box price, retail value, and usable value above and the calculator works out both ratios, the saving per box and per year, and a verdict.

      What is a good value ratio for a subscription box?

      On the honest ratio, which counts only the items you will use, 2.00 or more is excellent, 1.50 to 1.99 is good, 1.00 to 1.49 about breaks even, 0.75 to 0.99 is weak, and below 0.75 is poor. A ratio of 1.00 means the box returns exactly what it costs in usable value. Most boxes advertise ratios of 3.00 or more on claimed retail value, but the honest ratio is usually much lower: a BarkBox at $24 with $40 of retail value has a claimed ratio of 1.67, and if the dog only uses $28 of it, the honest ratio is 1.17.

      Why does the calculator ask what I will actually use?

      Because the claimed retail value of a box counts everything inside it, including the items you will never touch. A $38 body butter you will never open is worth $0 to you, and a toy your dog ignores is worth $0. The value ratio uses the full retail value; the honest ratio uses only the items you will use, and the verdict follows the honest ratio. In the BarkBox example on this page, the claimed saving is $16.00 a box and the honest saving is $4.00 a box. The gap between the two is where most subscription boxes lose their shine, and it is the gap the calculator exists to show.

      How much does FabFitFun cost per box in 2026?

      FabFitFun costs $79.99 a box on the Seasonal plan, billed each season, or $64.99 a box on the Annual plan, billed $259.96 once a year for four boxes. The Annual plan saves $60.00 a year against four seasonal boxes. The Beauty Edit Box is $29.99 a month and the PupBox Edit is $34.99 a month. Shipping is free in the contiguous US. FabFitFun says each seasonal box is worth up to $350 at retail; the Spring 2026 box reviewed by My Subscription Addiction held $214.99 of products. Prices checked 20 November 2026 on FabFitFun's own Membership Terms and plans page.

      How much does BarkBox cost per month in 2026?

      BarkBox Classic costs $35 a box month to month, $27 a box on the 6-month plan, and $24 a box on the 12-month plan, with shipping included. Super Chewer costs $39, $35, and $29 a box on the same plans. BARK's own FAQ puts the starting price at $24 a month for Classic and $29 for Super Chewer. Some secondary sources still quote $22 to $23 for the 12-month Classic plan from earlier in 2026, and BarkBox shows different prices to different visitors during promotions, so check your checkout. Prepaid gift subscriptions cost $294 for 12 months of Classic, which is $24.50 a box, and $360 for Super Chewer. Prices checked 20 November 2026.

      How much does Ipsy cost per month in 2026?

      Ipsy Original, formerly the Glam Bag, costs $15 a month plus $1.99 US shipping, or $171 a year prepaid with shipping included. Ipsy Extra, formerly BoxyCharm, costs $32 a month plus $1.99 shipping. Ipsy Ultimate, formerly the Icon Box, costs $65 a quarter and replaces your regular bag in February, May, August, and November. Ipsy Wellness costs $65 a quarter. Ipsy puts the stated value at up to $70 for Original, up to $200 for Extra, and up to $400 for Ultimate. Prices checked 20 November 2026 on ipsy.com.

      How does the Stitch Fix styling fee and 20 percent discount work?

      Stitch Fix charges a $20 styling fee per Fix, which is credited against anything you keep. If you keep 5 or more items on a Women's or Men's Fix, or the whole Fix on a Kids Fix, you get 20 percent off the clothes you keep. On $320 of clothes, the discount is $64.00, the clothes cost $256.00 after the discount, the $20 fee is credited, $236.00 is due at checkout, and you pay $256.00 in total, saving $64.00. If you keep fewer than 5 items, no discount applies, and the fee credit means you pay exactly the price of the clothes you keep: keeping 2 items worth $110 costs $110 in total. If you keep nothing, the $20 fee is lost. If the clothes you keep cost less than $20 after the discount, part of the fee goes unused: keeping a single $12 kids item costs $20 in total. Fixes hold 5 to 8 items, and keeping 5 of an 8-item Fix earns the discount on a Women's or Men's account. Shipping, returns, and exchanges are always free. The discount was 25 percent as recently as August 2026; Stitch Fix cut it to 20 percent between August and November 2026.

      Should I keep 5 items in my Stitch Fix to get the discount?

      Often yes, even when the fifth item is not one you love, because the 20 percent discount applies to the four items you already kept as well as the fifth. Keeping a $60 fifth item on a $260 keep-4 Fix brings the Fix total from $260.00 down to $256.00: keeping it costs $4.00 less than sending it back, and you get the item as well. With a $200 fifth item on the same Fix, keeping 5 costs $368.00 against $260.00, which is $108.00 more for a $200.00 item, saving $92.00 against buying it separately at full price. On a Kids Fix of more than 5 items, keeping a fifth item earns no discount, so the comparison is different: the item costs its full price. Enter the kept total and the next item price above and the calculator prices both options for your Fix.