Skip to content

Marketplace Profit Comparison Calculator

What the buyer pays for the item itself, before shipping and tax. $0.01 to $1,000,000.

Your cost of goods: what you paid for the item, including any sourcing cost. Enter 0 if it cost nothing. $0 to $1,000,000.

The shipping amount on the order. Enter 0 for free shipping. Most platforms charge their fee on this too. Poshmark ignores it: the buyer pays Poshmark for the label.

What the label and postage actually cost you. It comes out of the payout on every platform except Poshmark, where the label is included. Leave blank for 0.

Tax collected from the buyer. It is passed through, not kept, but eBay, Etsy, Facebook, and Depop charge fees on it. Leave blank for 0.

Best net profit

How the numbers were worked out

      This tool estimates the profit you would keep after marketplace fees, postage, and item cost on eBay, Etsy, Poshmark, Mercari, Facebook Marketplace, Depop, and Vinted, for general guidance only. It is not financial advice. Fee schedules change, and Poshmark's row uses the item price only because the buyer pays Poshmark for the label. Check the current fee schedule on the platform's own fee page before a high-value sale.
      Run one item through eBay, Etsy, Poshmark, Mercari, Facebook Marketplace, Depop, and Vinted at once: enter the sale price, what the item cost you, shipping charged, shipping cost, and tax collected, and the calculator ranks all seven by net profit. On a $100 item that cost $40 with free shipping, Vinted pays $60.00 profit, Depop $56.25, Etsy $50.05, Mercari and Facebook $50.00 each, eBay $46.00, and Poshmark $40.00, while on an $800 camera the spread grows to $163.00.

      Last reviewed: 20 November 2026. Reviewed every 90 days; next review due 19 February 2027.

      How to use the Marketplace Profit Comparison Calculator

      Sell the same item on seven marketplaces and you will keep up to seven different amounts. The headline rates look close, 10% here, 13.6% there, 20% somewhere else, but the rates are charged on different bases, some platforms add a processing fee and some do not, one platform charges nothing at all, and caps, minimums, and tier cliffs bend the arithmetic at both ends of the price range. On top of that, the fee is only half the question: what you keep also depends on what the item cost you and what the postage costs. This calculator runs one item through eBay, Etsy, Poshmark, Mercari, Facebook Marketplace, Depop, and Vinted at the same time and ranks all seven by net profit, so you can see where to list before you list.

      Enter the item sale price, what the item cost you, the shipping you charge the buyer, the shipping cost you actually pay, and any sales tax you collect. The calculator works out every fee line on every platform, subtracts your postage and your item cost, and shows a ranked table: platform fee, processing fee, total fees, payout, profit, and margin. The most profitable platform is highlighted, and the working is shown line by line underneath so you can check it by hand.

      To get your result, follow these steps:

      1. Enter the item sale price. This is what the buyer pays for the item itself, before shipping and tax. It is a required field, from $0.01 to $1,000,000.
      2. Enter what the item cost you. This is your cost of goods: what you paid for the item, including any sourcing cost. It is a required field, from $0 to $1,000,000. Enter 0 if the item cost nothing, for example a gift or a free pickup. Profit is payout minus this number, so leaving it out would overstate every result.
      3. Enter the shipping you charge the buyer. Leave it at 0 for free shipping. Most platforms charge their fee on this amount too, so it changes the ranking, not just the total. Poshmark ignores it: the buyer pays Poshmark for the label, so the shipping fields never touch the Poshmark row.
      4. Enter the shipping cost you pay. This is what the label and postage actually cost you. It comes out of the payout on every platform except Poshmark, where the label is included, so a sale that looks profitable before postage can lose money after it.
      5. Enter the sales tax you collect, if any. Tax is passed through to the tax authority and is never part of your payout, but eBay, Etsy, Facebook, and Depop charge fees on it, so it still costs you money on those four platforms.
      6. Read the ranked table. The platforms are ordered by net profit, highest first. The fee base is printed under each platform name, so you can see at a glance what each percentage is charged on. Tied platforms share a rank, so the next rank skips: 1, 1, 3.
      7. Read the warnings. The calculator flags a shipping shortfall, a loss on some or all platforms, the Poshmark $15 cliff, where a one-cent price rise costs you profit, and the Facebook $500 shipped-item limit.

      The four example buttons fill in common sales: a $25 thrift find that cost $5 with $5 shipping, a $100 item that cost $40 with free shipping, a $250 collectible with $15 shipping and $20 tax, and an $800 camera that cost $500 with $25 shipping and $64 tax. Tap one and the table updates at once.

      How the comparison works

      The calculator treats a sale as one order: an item price, an item cost, a shipping charge, a shipping cost, and a tax amount. The order total is the item price plus the shipping charge. Every platform fee is worked out from that order, each platform fee line is rounded to the cent, the payout is the order total minus total fees minus the shipping cost you pay, except on Poshmark, where the payout is the item price minus the commission because the buyer pays Poshmark for the label, and the profit is the payout minus the item cost. Tax is never added to the payout, because it belongs to the tax authority, but it enters the fee base on eBay, Etsy processing, Facebook, and Depop, which is where it costs you money.

      Two definitions matter, because sellers mix them up. Payout is what lands in your account before your item cost: revenue minus fees minus postage. Profit is what you actually made: payout minus what the item cost you. Payout and profit rank the platforms in the same order in this calculator, because your item cost is the same on every row: profit is payout minus that one cost, so the highest payout is always the highest profit. The margin is profit divided by what you collect, as a percent. Read the margin with care on Poshmark: Poshmark collects the item price only, so its margin is measured against a smaller base than the other six, and a high Poshmark margin can sit next to the lowest profit in dollars. Rank by profit dollars, not by margin percent.

      The seven platforms do not charge their percentages on the same thing, and that is the whole point of the comparison. eBay and Facebook charge on the item price plus shipping plus tax. Etsy charges its transaction fee on the item plus shipping and its processing fee on the item plus shipping plus tax. Mercari charges on the item plus shipping. Depop charges processing on the item plus shipping plus tax. Poshmark charges on the item price only. Vinted charges nothing at all. So charging $12 for shipping raises a fee on five of the seven platforms — eBay, Etsy, Mercari, Facebook, and Depop — and leaves Poshmark and Vinted untouched.

      PlatformPlatform feeCharged onProcessingProcessing charged on
      eBay13.6% to $7,500, 2.35% above, plus $0.30 or $0.40 per orderItem, shipping, and taxFolded into the final value feeNot applicable
      Etsy$0.20 listing plus 6.5% transaction feeItem plus shipping3% + $0.25 (US)Item, shipping, and tax
      Poshmark$2.95 under $15, 20% at $15 and aboveItem price onlyNoneNot applicable
      Mercari10%Item plus shippingNone since 6 January 2025Not applicable
      Facebook Marketplace10%, $0.80 minimumItem, shipping, and taxIncluded in the 10%Not applicable
      Depop0% for US sellersNot applicable3.3% + $0.45 (US)Item, shipping, and tax
      Vinted0%Not applicable$0, buyer pays itNot applicable

      All seven schedules are the published US domestic rates as checked on 20 November 2026. They change: Mercari alone has restructured twice in two years, Depop removed its selling fee in 2024, and Facebook doubled its rate in 2024. The review date on this page tells you when the rates were last checked, and the sources section at the bottom names the page each rate came from.

      Worked example: a $100 item that cost $40

      Take a $100 item that cost you $40, sold with free shipping, no postage cost, and no tax. This is the simplest possible comparison, and it already shows the full spread of the market: $20.00 separates the best platform from the worst on a single $100 sale.

      RankPlatformTotal feesPayoutProfitMargin
      1Vinted$0.00$100.00$60.0060.00%
      2Depop$3.75$96.25$56.2556.25%
      3Etsy$9.95$90.05$50.0550.05%
      4Facebook Marketplace$10.00$90.00$50.0050.00%
      4Mercari$10.00$90.00$50.0050.00%
      6eBay$14.00$86.00$46.0046.00%
      7Poshmark$20.00$80.00$40.0040.00%

      Check the arithmetic line by line. Vinted charges nothing, so the payout is the full $100.00 and the profit is $100.00 minus the $40.00 cost, $60.00. Depop charges processing only: 3.3% of $100.00 is $3.30, plus $0.45, which is $3.75, so the payout is $96.25 and the profit is $56.25. Etsy charges a $0.20 listing fee, a 6.5% transaction fee of $6.50, and processing of 3% of $100.00 plus $0.25, which is $3.25, for a total of $9.95, so the payout is $90.05 and the profit is $50.05. Mercari charges 10% of $100.00, which is $10.00, and Facebook charges 10% of $100.00, which is also $10.00, so both pay $90.00 and both profit $50.00: a tie, sharing rank 4, which is why the next rank is 6 and not 5. eBay charges a 13.6% final value fee of $13.60 plus the $0.40 per-order fee, $14.00 in total, so the payout is $86.00 and the profit is $46.00. Poshmark charges 20% of $100.00, which is $20.00, so the payout is $80.00 and the profit is $40.00.

      Two things in this table surprise most sellers. The first is that Etsy beats Mercari and Facebook by five cents on a $100 sale, even though Etsy's headline stack looks heavier: 6.5% plus 3% plus $0.45 in fixed fees comes to $9.95, a nickel under the flat 10%. The second is the size of the gap: Vinted pays $20.00 more profit than Poshmark on the same item at the same price, which is half the item cost again. Sell ten items like this a month and the platform choice alone is worth $200.00.

      Worked example: a $25 thrift find

      Now a cheaper item, where the fixed fees bite harder. A thrifted jacket listed at $25.00, bought for $5.00, with $5.00 shipping charged to the buyer and $5.00 postage paid by you. The order total is $30.00 on every platform except Poshmark, where the buyer pays Poshmark for the label and the seller collects the $25.00 item price only.

      RankPlatformTotal feesPayoutProfitMargin
      1Vinted$0.00$25.00$20.0066.67%
      2Depop$1.44$23.56$18.5661.87%
      3Facebook Marketplace$3.00$22.00$17.0056.67%
      3Mercari$3.00$22.00$17.0056.67%
      5Etsy$3.30$21.70$16.7055.67%
      6eBay$4.48$20.52$15.5251.73%
      7Poshmark$5.00$20.00$15.0060.00%

      The ranking has shifted from the $100 example. Etsy has dropped from third to fifth, because its $0.45 of fixed fees is a bigger share of a $30.00 order than of a $100.00 order: $0.20 listing plus 6.5% of $30.00, which is $1.95, plus processing of 3% of $30.00 plus $0.25, which is $1.15, comes to $3.30, thirty cents more than Mercari and Facebook at $3.00 each. eBay pays $4.48: 13.6% of $30.00 is $4.08, plus the $0.40 per-order fee. Depop pays $1.44: 3.3% of $30.00 is $0.99, plus $0.45. Poshmark pays $5.00, which is 20% of the $25.00 item price, and its payout is $20.00 because it never sees the $5.00 shipping: the buyer paid Poshmark for the label instead.

      Notice the Poshmark margin: 60.00%, higher than eBay, Etsy, Mercari, and Facebook, yet Poshmark pays the lowest profit in dollars, $15.00. That is the margin trap. Poshmark's margin is measured against the $25.00 item price, while the other margins are measured against the $30.00 order total. A percent is only comparable when the base is the same, and here it is not. Rank by profit dollars, and treat the margin as a description of each row, not as a ranking.

      Worked example: an $800 camera with tax

      At higher prices the percentages dominate and the fixed fees fade. A camera listed at $800.00, bought for $500.00, with $25.00 shipping charged, $22.00 postage, and $64.00 sales tax collected. The order total is $825.00, and the fee base for eBay, Facebook, and Depop is $889.00, the order total plus tax.

      RankPlatformTotal feesPayoutProfitMargin
      1Vinted$0.00$803.00$303.0036.73%
      2Depop$29.79$773.21$273.2133.12%
      3Etsy$80.75$722.25$222.2526.94%
      4Mercari$82.50$720.50$220.5026.73%
      5Facebook Marketplace$88.90$714.10$214.1025.95%
      6eBay$121.30$681.70$181.7022.02%
      7Poshmark$160.00$640.00$140.0017.50%

      The spread here is $163.00 between Vinted at $303.00 and Poshmark at $140.00, on one item. eBay's fee is $121.30: 13.6% of the $889.00 fee base is $120.90, plus the $0.40 per-order fee. Etsy's fee is $80.75: a $0.20 listing fee, 6.5% of the $825.00 order total, which is $53.63, and processing of 3% of $889.00 plus $0.25, which is $26.92. Mercari charges 10% of the $825.00 order total, $82.50, while Facebook charges 10% of the $889.00 base including tax, $88.90, which is why the two platforms that tied in the earlier examples now sit $6.40 apart. Depop charges 3.3% of $889.00 plus $0.45, which is $29.79. Poshmark charges 20% of the $800.00 item price, $160.00.

      This example also shows the Facebook $500 limit in action. The camera is listed at $800.00, and Facebook Marketplace ships items up to $500.00 through Checkout, so a shipped Facebook sale is not possible at this price: the calculator warns you, shows the fee math anyway, and notes that local pickup, which is free, is the way to sell it there.

      What each platform charges

      The seven schedules below are the rates this calculator models, as published on 20 November 2026. Each one carries its own quirks, and the quirks are where the money is.

      eBay: 13.6% on everything, plus a per-order fee

      eBay charges a final value fee of 13.6% on the total amount of the sale for most categories, up to $7,500 per item, and 2.35% on the part above $7,500, plus a per-order fee of $0.30 on orders of $10.00 or less and $0.40 above $10.00. The total amount of the sale means the item price, any shipping collected from the buyer, and sales tax. There is no separate payment processing fee: it is folded into the final value fee. The first 250 listings a month are free, so no listing fee is modeled. The rate rose from 13.25% to 13.6% on 14 February 2025. Some categories differ: books, movies, and music are 15.3%, guitars and basses are 6.7%, and Store subscribers pay a lower rate. On an $8,000 sale the tier matters: the final value fee is $1,020.00 on the first $7,500 plus 2.35% of the $500.00 above, which is $11.75, for $1,031.75, plus the $0.40 per-order fee, $1,032.15 in total. The calculator flags the tier whenever the sale total passes $7,500.

      Etsy: three small fees that stack to about 10%

      Etsy charges a $0.20 listing fee per listing, a 6.5% transaction fee on the item price plus shipping, and payment processing of 3% plus $0.25 per order for US sellers, charged on the item price plus shipping plus tax. The three stack to 9.5% of the order plus $0.45 in fixed fees, before tax effects. That fixed $0.45 is why Etsy is relatively expensive on cheap items and relatively cheap on dear ones: on a $30.00 order it is 1.5% extra, on a $825.00 order it is a rounding error. Two Etsy charges are not modeled. The Regulatory Operating Fee runs from 0.05% to 1.97% for sellers in nine listed countries (Canada, France, Hungary, India, Italy, Spain, Türkiye, the United Kingdom, and Vietnam) and changed on 22 June 2026; sellers in the United States do not pay it, so there is nothing to add to the Etsy row. Offsite Ads add 12% or 15% on attributed orders, capped at $100 per order, but only when an ad actually drove the sale. If Offsite Ads apply to you, add them to the Etsy row by hand.

      Poshmark: 20%, or $2.95 under $15

      Poshmark charges a flat $2.95 commission on sales under $15 and 20% on sales of $15 and above, on the item price only. There is no listing fee, no monthly charge, and no separate processing fee: the commission is the whole cut. The tiers were restored on 24 October 2024 after a brief experiment with lower commissions plus buyer-side fees. Poshmark is also the only platform in this comparison where the seller never touches shipping money: the buyer pays Poshmark $6.49 for a USPS Ground Advantage label, up to 5 lb, and the seller prints the prepaid label at no cost. That is why the Poshmark row uses the item price only, and why the shipping fields never change it. Since 26 October 2026, overweight postage is deducted from seller earnings, $5 for 5.01 to 10 lb and $10 for 10.01 to 15 lb; that surcharge is not modeled. One boundary note: Poshmark's own announcement put the $15 line in two places at once, with the body saying the flat fee applies at $15 and under and the FAQ saying under $15. This calculator charges 20% at exactly $15.00, the stricter reading and the one the Fee Policy supports, and says so in the sources.

      Mercari: a flat 10%, and nothing else

      Mercari charges a flat 10% selling fee on the item price plus buyer-paid shipping, for listings created or updated on or after 6 January 2025. There is no listing fee and no payment processing fee for sellers since that date: the old 2.9% plus $0.50 processing charge was removed at the same time the 10% fee was reinstated. The buyer pays a separate 3.6% Buyer Protection fee on the same base, which does not reduce your payout. Mercari's history is the reason this calculator re-checks its rates every quarter: seller fees were removed entirely in March 2024, replaced by a buyer service fee, and then the 10% seller fee came back in January 2025. Any guide that still says Mercari is free for sellers is two years out of date.

      Facebook Marketplace: 10% on shipped orders, free in person

      Facebook Marketplace charges nothing when the buyer collects the item and pays you in person. When you ship through Facebook Checkout, Meta charges a selling fee of 10% of the entire transaction, item price plus shipping plus applicable taxes, with a minimum fee of $0.80 per shipped order. There is no listing fee and no separate processing charge: the 10% includes it. Shipped items are limited to $500.00. The rate took effect on 15 April 2024, replacing 5% with a $0.40 minimum. Meta's own documents disagree about the current rate, and the disagreement is worth a section of its own, below.

      Depop: no selling fee, just processing

      Depop charges US sellers no selling fee at all, since 15 July 2024, when it removed the old 10% commission for US listings and moved the cost to a buyer-side marketplace fee. What remains is Depop Payments processing, run through Stripe: 3.3% plus $0.45 per transaction for US sellers, charged on the item price plus shipping plus any applicable tax. UK sellers pay 2.9% plus 0.30 pounds, Australian sellers 2.6% plus 0.30 Australian dollars, and sellers based anywhere else still pay a 10% selling fee, which this calculator does not model. Boosted Listings, Depop's paid promotion, costs 12% in the US and UK on listings created from 23 March 2026, and is optional, so it is not modeled either. At 3.3% plus $0.45, Depop is the cheapest fee-charging platform in this comparison at almost every price, which is why it sits second in every worked example above.

      Vinted: zero, and the buyer pays the platform

      Vinted charges sellers nothing: no listing fee, no commission, no payment processing fee. Whatever price you list is exactly what lands in your Vinted balance, before postage. The cost falls entirely on the buyer, through a Buyer Protection fee of about 5% of the item price plus a fixed fee of around $0.70 in the US, added at checkout. That makes Vinted the most profitable platform in this calculator on most sales: with no fees, its profit is the order total minus postage minus item cost, and no other platform can beat a zero fee. The exception is a sale where the postage you pay is more than the shipping you charge plus Poshmark's commission: Poshmark's seller pays no postage at all, so on a heavy parcel with free or cheap shipping, Poshmark can pay more than Vinted despite its 20% commission. The catch is demand, not arithmetic. Vinted is strongest in secondhand fashion, and its serious US push, with USPS integration, only began in January 2026, so a US seller may find fewer buyers there than on eBay or Poshmark, and US sellers can currently only sell to US buyers. The cheapest platform only pays if the item actually sells there.

      The Poshmark $15 cliff

      Poshmark's two tiers meet at $15.00, and the meeting point is a cliff, not a slope. Below $15 the fee is a flat $2.95 whatever the price. At $15.00 and above it is 20% of the whole sale price, not 20% of the part above $15. The fee therefore jumps by five cents the moment the price rises by one cent, from $2.95 at $14.99 to $3.00 at $15.00, and what you keep falls by four cents, from $12.04 to $12.00. With an item cost of $5.00, the profit is $7.04 at $14.99 and $7.00 at $15.00: listing one cent higher costs four cents of profit.

      The effect runs further than a single price. At $15.01 the profit is $7.01, at $15.02 it is $7.02, at $15.03 it is $7.02, and at $15.04 it is $7.03, all still below the $7.04 you keep at $14.99. The band closes at $15.05, where 20% of $15.05 is $3.01 and the profit is $7.04 again, exactly tied with $14.99. So any price from $15.00 to $15.04 is strictly worse than $14.99 or $15.05, and the calculator warns you whenever your price sits in that band, working out the exact profit at $14.99 so you can see the gain. The flat fee and the 20% rate cross at exactly $14.75, where both formulas give $2.95. Below that price the flat fee is the worse deal, and it gets worse fast: 29.5% of a $10.00 sale, 59% of a $5.00 sale. On a $4.00 item with a $1.00 cost, Poshmark pays $0.05 profit, because the $2.95 flat fee leaves $1.05 before the item cost.

      Is the Facebook Marketplace fee 5% or 10%?

      Both figures appear on Meta's own pages, and the disagreement is real, not blog noise. Meta's Business Help Center states a selling fee of 5% per shipment, or a flat $0.40 on shipments of $8.00 or less. Meta's merchant and commerce policies state that Meta will charge Individual Sellers a fee of 10% per transaction, with a minimum fee of $0.80, calculated on the entire amount of the transaction including the sale price, any shipping fees, and applicable taxes. The 10% rate took effect on 15 April 2024, replacing the 5% schedule, and the Help Center page was never updated to match. When a platform's help page contradicts its governing legal terms, the terms govern, so this calculator models 10% with a $0.80 minimum, and says so wherever the Facebook row appears.

      The practical difference is large. On a $50.00 item with $8.00 buyer-paid shipping and $4.64 tax, the fee base is $62.64: at 10% the fee is $6.26, at 5% it would be $3.13. A calculator still running the old rate understates the fee by half. The minimum matters too: at 10% the $0.80 minimum binds on any transaction under $8.00, while the old $0.40 minimum bound under $8.00 as well, at the old rate. On a $4.00 item with $3.50 shipping, the order total is $7.50, 10% of that is $0.75, and the $0.80 minimum applies instead, so the fee is $0.80 and the payout is $3.20 after the $3.50 postage is paid. If your own order summary ever shows a different rate, trust the order summary: it is the final word on your sale.

      Why sales tax costs you money you never keep

      Sales tax is the strangest line in this calculator. You collect it from the buyer, you hand it to the tax authority, and you never keep a cent of it, yet four platforms charge you a fee on it. eBay charges 13.6% on it, Facebook charges 10%, Etsy charges 3% processing on it, and Depop charges 3.3% processing on it. Mercari, Poshmark, and Vinted do not charge on tax at all, because their fee bases stop at the item price plus shipping.

      Take a $100.00 item that cost $40.00, with $10.00 shipping charged and $10.00 postage, and compare the same sale with and without $8.80 of tax. Without tax, eBay profits $44.64, Etsy $49.10, Mercari $49.00, Facebook $49.00, and Depop $55.92. With the $8.80 tax added, eBay profits $43.44, down $1.20, Etsy profits $48.84, down $0.26, Facebook profits $48.12, down $0.88, and Depop profits $55.63, down $0.29. Mercari, Poshmark, and Vinted do not move at all. The tax even flips the ranking: without tax, Etsy sits third at $49.10, ahead of the Mercari and Facebook tie at $49.00; with tax, Mercari takes third at $49.00, Etsy drops to fourth at $48.84, and Facebook drops to fifth at $48.12. That is why the tax field exists, and why leaving it at 0 when you do collect tax flatters eBay, Etsy, Facebook, and Depop by exactly the amounts above.

      Shipping: the quiet ranking changer

      Shipping moves the ranking in three ways at once. First, most platforms charge their fee on the shipping you charge the buyer, so a higher shipping charge raises the fee. Second, the postage you actually pay comes straight out of the payout, so a sale with free shipping and a $12.00 label starts $12.00 behind. Third, Poshmark sits outside the whole system, because the buyer pays Poshmark for the label and the seller pays nothing.

      The shipping shortfall is the trap to watch. If you charge the buyer $5.00 for shipping but the label costs $8.00, the $3.00 difference comes out of your payout on every platform except Poshmark, and the calculator warns you with the exact shortfall. Free shipping is the extreme case: charge $0.00 and pay $12.00, and $12.00 of postage comes out of every payout. On a $100.00 item that cost $40.00, free shipping with a $12.00 label cuts every profit by $12.00 except Poshmark's, which is unchanged, because Poshmark never sees the postage. That is also why Poshmark's 20% looks less terrible on heavy items: the $6.49 label the buyer pays covers up to 5 lb, and the seller pays nothing extra however heavy the parcel is, until the overweight surcharge starts above 5 lb.

      Charging more for shipping than the label costs runs the other way. Charge $15.00 for shipping and pay $10.00 for the label, and $5.00 of shipping profit enters the payout, minus the fee each platform charges on the shipping. On a $100.00 item that cost $40.00 with $15.00 charged and $10.00 paid, Vinted profits $65.00, Depop $60.75, Etsy $53.62, Mercari $53.50, Facebook $53.50, eBay $48.96, and Poshmark $40.00, unchanged as always. Poshmark's immunity to shipping cuts both ways: it never pays postage, but it never profits from shipping either.

      When the ranking flips: ties and crossovers

      The ranking in this calculator is not fixed. It moves with price, shipping, and tax, and two features of the arithmetic make it move in ways that surprise sellers. The first is ties. Mercari and Facebook charge the same 10% on the same base whenever no tax is collected, so they tie on every sale without tax, as long as the order total is $8.00 or more and the Facebook minimum does not bind. In the $100.00 example both profit $50.00 and share rank 4. Add tax and the tie breaks, because Facebook charges on tax and Mercari does not. Tied platforms share a rank and the next rank skips, so a two-way tie at rank 4 means the next platform is rank 6, not rank 5. That is competition ranking, the same system sports leagues use, and it stops the table from pretending a tie is a win.

      The second is crossovers. Etsy and Mercari cross at exactly $90.00 of order total when no tax is collected. Etsy's total fee is $0.45 in fixed fees plus 9.5% of the order, while Mercari's is a flat 10% of the order, and the two are equal when 0.5% of the order is $0.45, which is at $90.00. Below $90.00, Etsy's fixed fees make it dearer than Mercari. Above $90.00, Etsy's lower percentage makes it cheaper. At exactly $90.00, with an item cost of $30.00, Etsy, Mercari, and Facebook all charge $9.00 and all profit $51.00, a three-way tie at rank 3, with Vinted first at $60.00, Depop second at $56.58, eBay sixth at $47.36, and Poshmark seventh at $42.00. Tax moves the crossover up: with $8.80 of tax, Etsy stays dearer than Mercari until the order total passes $142.80, because Etsy charges processing on the tax and Mercari does not.

      The smallest sales produce the strangest table of all. On a $0.01 item that cost nothing, Mercari and Vinted tie for first at $0.01 profit, because Mercari's 10% of a cent rounds to $0.00 and Vinted charges nothing. eBay is third at a $0.29 loss, because the $0.30 per-order fee is thirty times the sale price. Etsy and Depop tie at fourth with a $0.44 loss each, Etsy from its $0.20 listing fee plus $0.25 processing fixed fee, Depop from its $0.45 processing fixed fee. Facebook is sixth at a $0.79 loss, because the $0.80 minimum fee applies, and Poshmark is seventh at a $2.94 loss, because the $2.95 flat fee is 295 times the sale price. The ranks read 1, 1, 3, 4, 4, 6, 7. Fixed fees decide tiny sales completely, which is why the cheapest platforms for a $100.00 item are not always the cheapest for a $5.00 one.

      Features

      This calculator is built for one decision, where to list a single item, and every feature serves that decision. It runs one item through all seven major US resale marketplaces at once, so you compare profit, not just fees: the item cost and the postage are part of the math on every row. It ranks the seven by net profit with competition ranking, so tied platforms share a rank and the table never pretends a tie is a win. It shows every fee base under each platform name, so you can see at a glance that eBay charges on tax while Mercari does not. It flags the traps automatically: a shipping shortfall, a loss on some or all platforms, the Poshmark $15 cliff with the exact profit at $14.99, and the Facebook $500 shipped-item limit. It shows the working line by line, one step per platform, with every number balancing on the printed figures, so you can check any row by hand in seconds. And it recalculates as you type, with four example buttons covering a thrift find, a mid-price item, a collectible, and a high-value camera.

      The fee schedules are dated and sourced, not scraped or guessed. Every rate was re-verified against the platform's own published fee page, or against an independent verifier who read that page, on 20 November 2026, and the next review is due on 19 February 2027, because these schedules move every quarter. Where the sources disagree, the calculator says so and names the governing source: the Facebook 5% versus 10% conflict and the Poshmark $15 boundary are both recorded in the sources section below, not smoothed over.

      Use cases

      Thrift flippers run every find through the calculator before listing. A $25.00 jacket bought for $5.00 pays $20.00 on Vinted and $15.00 on Poshmark, a $5.00 difference on one item, which is the entire item cost again. At twenty items a month, listing everything on the cheapest platform instead of the habitual one is worth $100.00.

      Closet cleanouts usually mean low prices, where fixed fees dominate. A $10.00 top that cost $2.00 pays $8.00 on Vinted, $7.22 on Depop, $7.00 on Mercari and Facebook, $6.60 on Etsy, $6.34 on eBay, and $5.05 on Poshmark, where the $2.95 flat fee takes 29.5% of the sale. Below $15.00, Poshmark is almost always the worst choice in dollars, however convenient its prepaid label feels.

      High-value sellers use the calculator for the opposite reason: percentages dominate at high prices, and the caps and tiers matter. On an $8,000.00 sale that cost $3,000.00, Vinted pays $5,000.00 profit, Depop $4,735.55, Etsy $4,239.55, Mercari and Facebook $4,200.00 each, eBay $3,967.85 even with the lower 2.35% rate above $7,500, and Poshmark $3,400.00. The spread is $1,600.00 on one item, and eBay's tier saves $56.25 against a flat 13.6% on the whole $8,000.00, since 13.6% of $8,000.00 would be $1,088.00 against the tiered $1,031.75.

      Cross-listers use the table to price per platform instead of listing one price everywhere. If you want $40.00 profit on an item that cost $20.00 with $8.99 buyer-paid shipping, the listing price that nets it differs by platform, because each fee takes a different bite. The calculator shows the profit at your price; adjust the price until the profit matches your target on each platform, and you have a per-platform price list. Selling somewhere more specialized? Our Niche Marketplace Fee Comparison Calculator runs the same sale through Reverb, Discogs, TCGplayer, Grailed, and BrickLink, and our Inventory Turnover Calculator shows how fast your stock moves.

      Handmade and vintage sellers deciding between Etsy and the resale apps can see exactly what Etsy's stack costs against a flat 10%. Below $90.00 of order total, Etsy costs more than Mercari, because its $0.45 of fixed fees outweighs its lower percentage. Above $90.00, Etsy costs less. Tax moves the crossover higher, to $142.80 of order total with $8.80 of tax, because Etsy charges processing on tax and Mercari does not.

      New sellers choosing a first platform get the honest trade-off in one table. Vinted usually pays the most and Depop is close behind, but both are fashion-led and Vinted's US buyer base is still young. eBay reaches the most buyers and charges for it. Poshmark is the simplest to ship on and usually the most expensive to sell on. The calculator prices the trade-off; only you can weigh the audience.

      What this calculator does not cover

      No calculator models everything, and the honest limits are these. Returns and refunds are not modeled: a return can wipe out the profit on several sales, and each platform handles return postage differently, so price that risk separately with our Seller Return Cost Calculator. Income tax is not modeled: marketplace sales are taxable income, and shipped sales paid through checkout are reported on a 1099-K once you pass the federal reporting threshold, so the profit here is before tax. Promoted listings and ads are not modeled: eBay Promoted Listings, Etsy Ads and Offsite Ads, Depop Boosted Listings at 12%, and Facebook boosted listings all stack on top of the fees shown. Subscriptions are not modeled: eBay Store tiers lower the final value fee, and Etsy Plus costs $10.00 a month, so high-volume sellers pay less per sale than this calculator shows. Etsy's Regulatory Operating Fee, 0.05% to 1.97% in nine listed countries, does not apply to sellers in the United States, so it is not modeled. Poshmark's overweight surcharge, $5 for 5.01 to 10 lb and $10 for 10.01 to 15 lb since 26 October 2026, is not modeled. Facebook local pickup is free and is not a row in the table, because the table models shipped sales; if you sell locally, the Facebook profit is the item price minus the item cost, with no fee at all. Vinted's Buyer Protection fee is paid by the buyer and never touches the seller, so it is noted but not modeled. eBay category rates other than the most-categories 13.6% are not modeled. International sales, currency conversion, and chargebacks are not modeled. If any of these apply to your sale, adjust the row by hand before you decide.

      Sources

      Every rate below was re-verified on 20 November 2026. Where a platform's own page could not be opened directly that day, the rate was verified against an independent verifier who read the page and quoted it, and the conflict, if any, is recorded.

      • eBay: 13.6% final value fee on the total amount of the sale up to $7,500, 2.35% above, plus a $0.30 or $0.40 per-order fee; 250 free listings a month. eBay Seller Center, Selling fees (ebay.com Seller Center). Rate 13.25% to 13.6% on 14 February 2025.
      • Etsy: $0.20 listing fee, 6.5% transaction fee on item plus shipping, 3% plus $0.25 US payment processing on item plus shipping plus tax; Regulatory Operating Fee 0.05% to 1.97% in nine listed countries, changed 22 June 2026 — US sellers do not pay it. Etsy Help Center, Fees and Payments Policy, as checked against Etsy's Help Center on 12 November 2026 by an independent verifier.
      • Poshmark: $2.95 flat commission under $15, 20% at $15 and above, on the item price only; buyer pays $6.49 for the label since 12 September 2025; overweight surcharge since 26 October 2026. Poshmark Support, What are the fees for selling on Poshmark (support.poshmark.com). Boundary conflict recorded: the announcement put the $15 line in two places; this tool charges 20% at exactly $15.00.
      • Mercari: 10% selling fee on item plus buyer-paid shipping for listings created or updated on or after 6 January 2025; no processing fee since that date; buyer pays a 3.6% Buyer Protection fee. Mercari Help Center, Fees on Mercari, fee page updated 7 May 2026, as verified against Mercari's fee page on 20 November 2026 by an independent fee tracker (verifiedfees.com Mercari page). Date conflict resolved: several third-party pages date the 10% fee to 6 January 2026; Mercari's own pages say 6 January 2025, and the platform's own pages govern.
      • Facebook Marketplace: 10% selling fee on the entire transaction, $0.80 minimum, shipped Checkout orders only, effective 15 April 2024; local pickup free; $500 shipped-item limit. Meta Commerce Policies, merchant policies, the governing terms. Conflict recorded: Meta's Business Help Center still states 5% with a $0.40 minimum, the pre-April 2024 schedule; the governing terms state 10% with a $0.80 minimum, and this tool follows the terms. The conflict and the governing quote are set out by an independent verifier (treecat.io Facebook Marketplace fee calculator).
      • Depop: 0% selling fee for US sellers since 15 July 2024; Depop Payments processing 3.3% plus $0.45 on item plus shipping plus tax; Boosted Listings 12% in the US and UK on listings from 23 March 2026. Depop Help Center, Seller fees and charges, and Depop's own announcement (news.depop.com).
      • Vinted: 0% seller fees of any kind; buyer pays a Buyer Protection fee of about 5% of the item price plus $0.70. Vinted Help Center, Is selling on Vinted free (vinted.com help page). US push began January 2026, domestic-only for US sellers.
      • Independent cross-check: five of the seven schedules were verified against the platforms' official fee pages in November 2026 by an independent fee engine (The Fee Ladder, blog.solvinc.io), which confirms the eBay, Poshmark, Mercari, Depop, and Vinted figures used here.

      Next review due 19 February 2027 (quarterly cadence, HIGH maintenance, 7 schedules). At review, re-verify all seven schedules from the platforms' own fee pages, check whether Meta has updated the Help Center rate to match its merchant policies, check whether Poshmark has clarified the $15 boundary, check whether Etsy has added the United States to the Regulatory Operating Fee list, and re-run the 71 fixtures.

      Frequently asked questions

      Which marketplace pays sellers the most profit?

      Vinted, on most sales, because it charges sellers nothing at all: no listing fee, no commission, and no processing fee. The exception is a sale where the postage you pay outweighs the shipping you charge plus Poshmark's commission: Poshmark's seller pays no postage, so Poshmark can win on a heavy parcel with free shipping. On a $100.00 item that cost $40.00 with free shipping, Vinted pays $60.00 profit, Depop pays $56.25, Etsy pays $50.05, Mercari and Facebook Marketplace pay $50.00 each, eBay pays $46.00, and Poshmark pays $40.00. Depop is second almost everywhere, because its only cost is 3.3% plus $0.45 in processing. But the cheapest platform only pays if the item sells there: Vinted is strongest in secondhand fashion and its US buyer base is still young after its January 2026 push, while eBay reaches far more buyers and charges for it. Run your own item through the calculator, then weigh the profit against the audience.

      Why do Mercari and Facebook Marketplace tie so often?

      Because both charge a flat 10% on the same base whenever no sales tax is collected: the item price plus buyer-paid shipping. On a $100.00 item with $10.00 shipping and no tax, both charge $11.00 and both pay $49.00 profit on a $40.00 item cost with $10.00 postage. Tax breaks the tie, because Facebook charges its 10% on the tax too and Mercari does not: add $8.80 of tax and Mercari still pays $49.00 while Facebook drops to $48.12. The Facebook $0.80 minimum breaks the tie the other way on small orders: on a $7.50 order, 10% is $0.75, so Facebook charges the $0.80 minimum while Mercari charges $0.75. Tied platforms share a rank in this calculator, so the next rank skips.

      What is the Poshmark $15 cliff?

      Poshmark charges a flat $2.95 commission on sales under $15 and 20% on sales of $15 and above, on the whole sale price, not just the part above $15. The fee jumps from $2.95 at $14.99 to $3.00 at $15.00, so with a $5.00 item cost the profit is $7.04 at $14.99 and $7.00 at $15.00: one cent more on the price costs four cents of profit. The band runs to $15.04, where the profit is $7.03, and closes at $15.05, where 20% is $3.01 and the profit is $7.04 again, tied with $14.99. Any price from $15.00 to $15.04 is strictly worse than $14.99 or $15.05, and the calculator warns you whenever your price sits in that band. The flat fee and the 20% rate cross at exactly $14.75, where both give $2.95.

      Is the Facebook Marketplace fee 5% or 10%?

      It is 10%. Meta raised the shipped Checkout selling fee from 5% with a $0.40 minimum to 10% with a $0.80 minimum on 15 April 2024, and its merchant policies, the governing legal terms, state 10% on the entire transaction including shipping and taxes. Meta's Business Help Center still states 5% with a $0.40 minimum, the old schedule, and plenty of guides and calculators were never updated. This calculator follows the governing terms and models 10% with a $0.80 minimum. On a $50.00 item with $8.00 shipping and $4.64 tax, the fee base is $62.64 and the fee is $6.26 at 10%, against $3.13 at the old 5% rate. Local pickup paid in person is free either way, and shipped items are limited to $500.00.

      Does the fee apply to shipping and tax?

      It depends on the platform, and the difference is the main reason a comparison tool is needed. eBay charges its 13.6% final value fee on the item price plus shipping plus tax. Facebook charges its 10% on the same full base. Etsy charges its 6.5% transaction fee on the item plus shipping, and its 3% processing on the item plus shipping plus tax. Depop charges its 3.3% processing on the item plus shipping plus tax. Mercari charges 10% on the item plus shipping, never on tax. Poshmark charges on the item price only, and Vinted charges nothing. Tax is the strangest part: you never keep it, but four platforms charge you on it. On a $100.00 item with $10.00 shipping and $8.80 tax, the tax alone costs $1.20 on eBay, $0.88 on Facebook, $0.29 on Depop, and $0.26 on Etsy, and it flips Etsy from third to fourth behind Mercari.

      Why is Poshmark's profit the lowest even though its margin looks high?

      Because Poshmark's margin is measured against a smaller base than the other six. Poshmark collects the item price only: the buyer pays Poshmark $6.49 for the label, so the shipping never enters Poshmark's revenue. On a $25.00 thrift find with $5.00 shipping charged, Poshmark's margin is 60.00% of the $25.00 item price, while the other margins are measured against the $30.00 order total. Poshmark's profit is $15.00, the lowest of the seven, even though its margin percent beats eBay, Etsy, Mercari, and Facebook. A percent is only comparable when the base is the same, and here it is not. Rank by profit dollars, and treat the margin as a description of each row, not as a ranking.

      How do the eBay tiers change the ranking on expensive items?

      eBay charges 13.6% on the total amount of the sale up to $7,500 and 2.35% on the part above, plus a $0.40 per-order fee. On an $8,000.00 sale the final value fee is $1,020.00 on the first $7,500 plus 2.35% of the $500.00 above, which is $11.75, for $1,031.75, plus $0.40, $1,032.15 in total. That tier saves $56.25 against a flat 13.6% on the whole $8,000.00, which would be $1,088.00. Even with the saving, eBay stays sixth on an $8,000.00 sale that cost $3,000.00, at $3,967.85 profit, behind Vinted at $5,000.00, Depop at $4,735.55, Etsy at $4,239.55, and Mercari and Facebook at $4,200.00 each, and ahead of only Poshmark at $3,400.00. The spread on that one sale is $1,600.00.

      What does this calculator leave out?

      Returns and refunds, income tax, promoted listings and ads, subscriptions, Depop Boosted Listings at 12%, Poshmark's overweight postage surcharge, eBay category rates other than the most-categories 13.6%, international sales, currency conversion, and chargebacks. Etsy's Regulatory Operating Fee of 0.05% to 1.97% applies only to sellers in nine listed countries; US sellers do not pay it, so it is not a gap in the Etsy row. Facebook local pickup is free and is not a row in the table, because the table models shipped sales. Vinted's Buyer Protection fee is paid by the buyer and never touches the seller, so it is noted but not modeled. If any of these apply to your sale, adjust the row by hand before you decide: a return can wipe out the profit on several sales, and the calculator's profit is before income tax.